2009 Free Agents

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Bubba305-ST21-

I personally think picking up one of these studs would put our good defense over the top and give us an elite defense. The question is which would you guys prefer?? Both around the same age Peppers 28 and Hayneworth 27

I would say Peppers...he had a down year last year, but has bounced nicely. Unlike Haynesworth, I think Peppers has been a bit under the radar, and I do like the fact that Peppers has been pretty consistent (save for last year), unlike Haynesworth. Both Carter and Taylor are in their 30s, and having Peppers along with Taylor or Carter would give us some time to develop a young DE (hopefully through the draft).

I still think that we need a better DT, however I think Haynesworth has higher risk of becoming a bust than Peppers; furthermore, there are a few character issues with Haynesworth.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

I would say Peppers...he had a down year last year, but has bounced nicely. Unlike Haynesworth, I think Peppers has been a bit under the radar, and I do like the fact that Peppers has been pretty consistent (save for last year), unlike Haynesworth. Both Carter and Taylor are in their 30s, and having Peppers along with Taylor or Carter would give us some time to develop a young DE (hopefully through the draft).

I still think that we need a better DT, however I think Haynesworth has higher risk of becoming a bust than Peppers; furthermore, there are a few character issues with Haynesworth.

A strong case can be made for both of them, and against both of them. If one of them wins a Super Bowl this year they may be more inclined to go for the big payday now. Peppers may stay if he is franchised of course, which is likely to happen. Though it's going to cost the Panthers a pretty penny to do that. Which may free up Gross to FA. And that's great for us, potentially.

Haynesworth does have potential "complacent free agent bust" written all over him, but he could also be the total stud on the interior that we need. I think Golston is gone this year, Griffin and/or Daniels could be gone as well, and who knows about Evans. So the interior could come down to Montgomery (assuming he stays), and Alexander. Which is ok, but not great.

If it were me though, I don't know that I would sign either.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

A strong case can be made for both of them, and against both of them. If one of them wins a Super Bowl this year they may be more inclined to go for the big payday now. Peppers may stay if he is franchised of course, which is likely to happen. Though it's going to cost the Panthers a pretty penny to do that. Which may free up Gross to FA. And that's great for us, potentially.

Haynesworth does have potential "complacent free agent bust" written all over him, but he could also be the total stud on the interior that we need. I think Golston is gone this year, Griffin and/or Daniels could be gone as well, and who knows about Evans. So the interior could come down to Montgomery (assuming he stays), and Alexander. Which is ok, but not great.

If it were me though, I don't know that I would sign either.

Why does it make sense to non-tender Golston? It costs us barely anything to keep him.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Why does it make sense to non-tender Golston? It costs us barely anything to keep him.

Didn't say it makes sense. Just saying I know going into this season that the staff and coaches had decided he wasn't a huge priority to keep and they were inclined to let him go. That's not to say they haven't changed their mind on that though.

Personally, I'd love to see him come back