The Case For...

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by Angry

PETA is requesting that Vick take a Psych eval before being reinstated. In the event that he passes it and he has met their requirements, then they would have no choice but to STFU and back down.

As far as Vick being rusty, that is what training camp is for. It's not like we would need him to come out and be a QB right away if at all.

I doubt that after all he has done, and is going to do to repent for his wrong doing that the commish is actually going to keep him banned. He is more deserving of a second chance than several other players who have gotten second chances.

I don't know why you would want Vick to begin with. Character issues aside, the guy was never really that great a Quarterback to begin with and now you want to bring him back after a year out of the league. The only time Vick was really "successful" was when Reeves protected him by limiting the amount of times he threw.

However what really did Vick in was the Cover 2 defense. Having those two corners on the aside, fast linebackers, quick DE's, and a QB who wasn't really that accurate went a long way towards exposing him as nothing more then a glorified running back.

Once teams realized that they didn't have to worry so much about him throwing the jig was up, as before teams would psyche themselves out by thinking they had to defend the run and the pass on passing plays.

He's not worth the trouble and media circus that he would bring. And remember I've possibly watched Vick more then anyone else on this forum so for once I know what I'm talking about.