JLC...Being JLC (Colors Critique of Haynesworth Deal with Nonsense)

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

The comments about people being laid off was stupid. But I think it's safe to say Tenn has better personel on defense than we did. Don't you?

You can say with certainty that Cortland Finnegan and Nick Harper is a better CB duo than Hall and Rogers? LDE Javon Kearse had 3.5 sacks last year with the Titans and RDE Kyle Vanden Bosch had 4.5 (granted he only played 10 games). LDE Jason Taylor had 3.5 sacks (didn't play a full season) and RDE Andre Carter had 4 sacks. They had Haynesworth in the middle, Carter and Taylor had Golston.

[JoeRedskin]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

You can say with certainty that Cortland Finnegan and Nick Harper is a better CB duo than Hall and Rogers? LDE Javon Kearse had 3.5 sacks last year with the Titans and RDE Kyle Vanden Bosch had 4.5 (granted he only played 10 games). LDE Jason Taylor had 3.5 sacks (didn't play a full season) and RDE Andre Carter had 4 sacks. They had Haynesworth in the middle, Carter and Taylor had Golston.

See, it's these kinds of things that rob JLC of all credibility these days. He's taken on the mentality "If Vinny or Dan did it, it must be bad" (well, he's had it for some time - it's just so consistently blatant anymore).

Minimal research destroys the premise of his argument. Now that's integrity!

While I agree that a beat reporter probably should not be a fan, unremitting hostility is no better.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by JoeRedskin

See, it's these kinds of things that rob JLC of all credibility these days. He's taken on the mentality "If Vinny or Dan did it, it must be bad" (well, he's had it for some time - it's just so consistently blatant anymore).

Minimal research destroys the premise of his argument. Now that's integrity!

While I agree that a beat reporter probably should not be a fan, unremitting hostility is no better.

It's like he starts with a pretty solid argument but then it gets all personal and he just throws in a bunch of nonsense which invalidates everything else he writes.

He's a weird dude and if I see him with his FUBU wear one more time....