Another Haynesworth Thread: Will AH Be The Next Dana Stubblefield?

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

I think he was referring to me.

Ruhskins:

The Giants signed Boley and Bernard all they have left is Canty. Like I said yesterday, if he's signed that Giants D will be unbelievable. Don't tell me it won't? Be realistic, we need to shore our OL to counteract them. My point was we put all our eggs into 2 signing when we could have been doing what the Giants have done smartly and will do if Canty is signed. Filling many holes which we have still.

I hate the Giants by the way!!

And if they don't sign Canty, the Giants will also have only made two signings and still won't have addressed their needs at WR, LT, or in the secondary

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

And if they don't sign Canty, the Giants will also have only made two signings and still won't have addressed their needs at WR, LT, or in the secondary

Don't forget Mario Manningham (could be great, could be a bust) LT? They have the best OL according to all the experts, CB they are pretty good, I guess they could use one more. It's not like they have many holes like us and they can address those needs in this upcoming draft.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Don't forget Mario Manningham (could be great, could be a bust) LT? They have the best OL according to all the experts, CB they are pretty good, I guess they could use one more. It's not like they have many holes like us and they can address those needs in this upcoming draft.

If Mario Manningham is going to be their next Plaxico, more power to them. I didn't forget him, but then I hope you're not forgetting Thomas, Kelly, and Davis. They are looking to add depth to both their OL (ideally move Diehl inside and McKenzie to the bench, I think that's what I heard) and their secondary (particularly at safety where they are very young and inexperienced)

Really how many holes do we have that they don't have? And why can't we address needs in the draft? I understand they have more picks than we do right now but it's not like we don't have any picks and can't get more

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

If Mario Manningham is going to be their next Plaxico, more power to them. I didn't forget him, but then I hope you're not forgetting Thomas, Kelly, and Davis. They are looking to add depth to both their OL (ideally move Diehl inside and McKenzie to the bench, I think that's what I heard) and their secondary (particularly at safety where they are very young and inexperienced)

Really how many holes do we have that they don't have? And why can't we address needs in the draft? I understand they have more picks than we do right now but it's not like we don't have any picks and can't get more

Kenny Phillips was a stud as a rookie for them and Michael Johnson was solid. We are weak at LB with the loss of Washington, McIntosh had a bad year and Fletch is getting up there in age, on the DE Taylor and Carter are undersized and getting up in age, Evans might be gone, Daniels is Pre-historic. We need two OL players and RB I would start finding someone for the future.

We can argue about this till we are blue in the face, but if don't address those holes in the draft, we will still lose to the Giants despite our FA signings. They have made some nice moves themselves and if they sign Canty, that would be quite a D.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Kenny Phillips was a stud as a rookie for them and Michael Johnson was solid. We are weak at LB with the loss of Washington, McIntosh had a bad year and Fletch is getting up there in age, on the DE Taylor and Carter are undersized and getting up in age, Evans might be gone, Daniels is Pre-historic. We need two OL players and RB I would start finding someone for the future.

We can argue about this till we are blue in the face, but if don't address those holes in the draft, we will still lose to the Giants despite our FA signings. They have made some nice moves themselves and if they sign Canty, that would be quite a D.

Well they still haven't signed Canty, and I'm not saying they didn't make some good moves. Just saying so did we, and just like us they have holes to fill.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Kenny Phillips was a stud as a rookie for them and Michael Johnson was solid. We are weak at LB with the loss of Washington, McIntosh had a bad year and Fletch is getting up there in age, on the DE Taylor and Carter are undersized and getting up in age, Evans might be gone, Daniels is Pre-historic. We need two OL players and RB I would start finding someone for the future.

We can argue about this till we are blue in the face, but if don't address those holes in the draft, we will still lose to the Giants despite our FA signings. They have made some nice moves themselves and if they sign Canty, that would be quite a D.

Dude, just let it go with the Giants. I'm sure the front office will address the offensive line in the draft, they'd be ridiculously stupid not to do so. Besides, you never know how the Giants' signings are going to work out. We don't know how durable Jacobs is going to be now that they don't have Ward, heck Canty could not work out for them, or Boley. Like I said, what's done is done in regards of the Hall and Haynesworth signings, there's nothing we can do to change that.

The draft and what happens there will determine how good our offensive line will be. Hopefully at team above us makes a mistake and lets one of the top tackles fall to 13th. Like I said, anything can happen. As I said, my only concern is that right tackle position, and I hope we can address that with our #13 pick.