Broncos to trade Cutler

[djnemo65]

I see posts talking about Campbell being good, but not good enough to take us all the way to the Superbowl. Superbowl? Shouldn't we try and win a playoff game first?

[Skinny Tee]

Originally Posted by djnemo65

I see posts talking about Campbell being good, but not good enough to take us all the way to the Superbowl. Superbowl? Shouldn't we try and win a playoff game first?

True that.

People said that about Marty Schottenheimer. "He can take you to the Conference Championship but he can't win a Super Bowl"...Was that a bad thing?

I'd love to be talked about in the playoffs while 2/3rds of the teams sat at home and watched you play. We've won more high profile free agent contracts in the last 5 years than playoff games.

[irish]

Originally Posted by djnemo65

I see posts talking about Campbell being good, but not good enough to take us all the way to the Superbowl. Superbowl? Shouldn't we try and win a playoff game first?

Good point. Unfortunately the Skins are closer to the Bengals than the Steelers. I dont see JC even taking the Skins to the playoffs. I think Cutler for JC is an obvious upgrade at QB and dont really have a problem with the Skins making this move but I'd prefer to see the Skins hold on to their picks. Denver's problem wasnt O last year and I cant imagine that Cutler can do a lot to get the Skins O moving.

[SC Skins Fan]

Originally Posted by irish

Good point. Unfortunately the Skins are closer to the Bengals than the Steelers. I dont see JC even taking the Skins to the playoffs. I think Cutler for JC is an obvious upgrade at QB and dont really have a problem with the Skins making this move but I'd prefer to see the Skins hold on to their picks. Denver's problem wasnt O last year and I cant imagine that Cutler can do a lot to get the Skins O moving.

Yeah, Cutler for Campbell would be an upgrade, but that is not a Redskins trade. The Redskins have overpaid in every trade they have made in the DS era and if they make a move for Cutler they will give up a king's ransom. It will be a package of picks, maybe some young players, something that makes no sense and hurts the team in the long term. That is the Skins formula for trades. And the Broncos have benefited more than most. The only decent trade they have made was the one with Atlanta during the draft last year. Your "I don't even see JC taking the Skins to the playoffs" is a patently ridiculous statement btw.

[irish]

Originally Posted by SC Skins Fan

Yeah, Cutler for Campbell would be an upgrade, but that is not a Redskins trade. The Redskins have overpaid in every trade they have made in the DS era and if they make a move for Cutler they will give up a king's ransom. It will be a package of picks, maybe some young players, something that makes no sense and hurts the team in the long term. That is the Skins formula for trades. And the Broncos have benefited more than most. The only decent trade they have made was the one with Atlanta during the draft last year. Your "I don't even see JC taking the Skins to the playoffs" is a patently ridiculous statement btw.

JC hasent really done anything to show me that he could lead the team to the playoffs but anything can happen.

The Skins also gave up a ton to get Campbell and like you said, its how the skins do business. I have really stopped caring how the Skins do business all I am looking for is a team that can win now so if Cutler can do that then bring him on.

The Skins have become an organization that is sucking the life out of its fans. They dont seem to have a plan and most things they do seem to turn to crap.

[SC Skins Fan]

Originally Posted by irish

JC hasent really done anything to show me that he could lead the team to the playoffs but anything can happen.

The Skins also gave up a ton to get Campbell and like you said, its how the skins do business. I have really stopped caring how the Skins do business all I am looking for is a team that can win now so if Cutler can do that then bring him on.

The Skins have become an organization that is sucking the life out of its fans. They dont seem to have a plan and most things they do seem to turn to crap.

Well we can certainly agree on that point.