Rank the NFC East teams position by position....

[pick-ups]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

Talent wise you're probably right. But don't under estimate what Eli did. He stepped his game up when it mattered most. Plus he drove his team down the field for a SB win. I was very impressed with his performace in 07. McNabb threw 3 INTS in his SB. I think McNabb is better though.

Like I said before about Eli and that final drive....he threw two passes that should've been INTs and was fortunate they weren't.

The Giants offense had amassed 3 points total going into the 4th quarter and if it wasn't for the extraordinary performance by the Giants defense(holding the Pats to 14pts/lowest all year)then what Eli does,doesn't really matter.

McNabb also threw for 357yds and 3 TDs along with those 3 INTs(the last one being a final heave with no time left).

The Eagles offense this season can be one of the best in the league,let alone the division.
They are stacked.

[firstdown]

Originally Posted by pick-ups

Like I said before about Eli and that final drive....he threw two passes that should've been INTs and was fortunate they weren't.

The Giants offense had amassed 3 points total going into the 4th quarter and if it wasn't for the extraordinary performance by the Giants defense(holding the Pats to 14pts/lowest all year)then what Eli does,doesn't really matter.

McNabb also threw for 357yds and 3 TDs along with those 3 INTs(the last one being a final heave with no time left).

The Eagles offense this season can be one of the best in the league,let alone the division.
They are stacked.

Yea but you have to take away style points for McNabb puking on you center.

You Tube

[pick-ups]

Originally Posted by firstdown

Yea but you have to take away style points for McNabb puking on you center.

You know the crazy thing is that every time McNabb has puked during a drive.....the end result is always a TD(maybe he should puke on every drive)

[firstdown]

Originally Posted by pick-ups

You know the crazy thing is that every time McNabb has puked during a drive.....the end result is always a TD(maybe he should puke on every drive)

If I'm correct when he pucked in the SB they did not score and the game was over.

[pick-ups]

Originally Posted by firstdown

If I'm correct when he pucked in the SB they did not score and the game was over.

Actually he was puking in the huddle according to the center(Hank Fraley)so Freddie Mitchell called one of the plays and two plays later he hit Greg Lewis in the endzone for a TD.

Also did it vs the Bucs and VT(in college).

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by pick-ups

Like I said before about Eli and that final drive....he threw two passes that should've been INTs and was fortunate they weren't.

The Giants offense had amassed 3 points total going into the 4th quarter and if it wasn't for the extraordinary performance by the Giants defense(holding the Pats to 14pts/lowest all year)then what Eli does,doesn't really matter.

McNabb also threw for 357yds and 3 TDs along with those 3 INTs(the last one being a final heave with no time left).

The Eagles offense this season can be one of the best in the league,let alone the division.
They are stacked.

Like I said, I think McNabb is better but don't act like Eli is chopped liver. He's a streaky passer, just like McNabb is. And lets also not forget how well Eli played the whole 07 playoff run.