Rank the NFC East teams position by position....

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

I never said Eli was better. I just think when his team needed him to play his best he did. Overall I think Romo is a more talented player.

And I wasn't comparing Manning to Bradshaw, I just used Bradshaw as an example that he was never really a great passer, he was just great when his team really needed him to be. But I never compared the two.

I know you didnt. The post you quoted was the one I was using to compare Eli and Romo to another poster. I was just referring to why I brought out those stats.

As for Bradshaw I agree he may of never been a great passer so I understand why you brought him up to compare. I just didnt think it was the best comparison since Bradshaw really stepped up in big games and Eli overall hasnt. Yes Eli had a solid 2007 playoff run and won the Super Bowl with the Giants. I just think besides the wild card game against the Bucs he really didnt do anything great except play a safer game. Even then if certain defenders caught his wild throws the Giants wouldnt be world champs.

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

I think McNabb is one of the top QB's in the NFL. I also think when it comes to passing he's streaky. He's hot and cold. I think most would agree w/ that statement. I don't think that's a bad thing. I think he's always been that way as a pure passer.

Maybe in some games he has been streaky. To a certain extent all QBs go through certain moments. I just think there is a difference between Elis "streaky" and McNabbs "streaky".

[pick-ups]

Originally Posted by Brian Orakpo

I know you didnt. The post you quoted was the one I was using to compare Eli and Romo to another poster. I was just referring to why I brought out those stats.

As for Bradshaw I agree he may of never been a great passer so I understand why you brought him up to compare. I just didnt think it was the best comparison since Bradshaw really stepped up in big games and Eli overall hasnt. Yes Eli had a solid 2007 playoff run and won the Super Bowl with the Giants. I just think besides the wild card game against the Bucs he really didnt do anything great except play a safer game. Even then if certain defenders caught his wild throws the Giants wouldnt be world champs.

Lets not forget that Eli has been one and done in 3 of his 4 attempts in the playoffs(twice at the hands of the Eagles).
The year before and after their SB run.
`05 vs Panthers 0-24
`06 vs Eagles 17-20
`08 vs Eagles 11-23

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by pick-ups

Lets not forget that Eli has been one and done in 3 of his 4 attempts in the playoffs(twice at the hands of the Eagles).
The year before and after their SB run.
`05 vs Panthers 0-24
`06 vs Eagles 17-20
`08 vs Eagles 11-23

yeah, and were has that gotten you? Like it or not Eli brought out the best in his team ,he's dealt with more problems then any other QB on the list.Remeber we still beat Carolina even after losing Plax,name me one other QB on the list that has an MVP of the Super Bowl ....and I'll shut up.:yeahright

Originally Posted by Giantone

yeah, and were has that gotten you? Like it or not Eli brought out the best in his team ,he's dealt with more problems then any other QB on the list.Remeber we still beat Carolina even after losing Plax,name me one other QB on the list that has an MVP of the Super Bowl ....and I'll shut up.:yeahright

...ill go get his reservation for Canton. Im sure that one SB MVP Trophy will negate his 76.1 career QB rating. Because the way you keep hyping him up he must be Canton bound.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by Brian Orakpo

...ill go get his reservation for Canton. Im sure that one SB MVP Trophy will negate his 76.1 career QB rating. Because the way you keep hyping him up he must be Canton bound.

Never said one word about HOF, just pointing out facts that others tend to forget.McNabb maybe he will go to the HOF but he has no ring, and well as for Romo............LOL...sorry,Campbell is still young...and as I said I like the kid,just give him an O line.

Originally Posted by Giantone

Never said one word about HOF, just pointing out facts that others tend to forget.McNabb maybe he will go to the HOF but he has no ring, and well as for Romo............LOL...sorry,Campbell is still young...and as I said I like the kid,just give him an O line.

Dude everyone knows Eli won the Super Bowl MVP. This whole thread thats all you have brought up.

The Canton comment was a joke since you keep bringing up Eli and SB MVP every post.

Dude if you think hes that good (ahead of Romo) because of one SB MVP award you really need to stop watching football. Eli is average at best and his stats prove it over his career.

Id really like to know out of the projected 32 starting QBs where you rank Eli because if you think hes better than Romo id like to see who else you think hes better than because of one SB MVP.