Ocho Cinco In B&G

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by SBXVII

Ok, work with me here. CJ has had roughly 7 TD's a year. Last yr was a bad yr but I took his overall 53 TD's for the last 8 yrs he's played and got an average of 7 TD's per yr. Now Moss has been in the league for the same 8 yrs but only has 43 TD's overall. So I took the 43 TD's overall and divided by his 8 yrs and came up with 5 TD's per yr average. So in a nutshell 7 TD's and 5 TD's together is 12 TD's out of a 16 game season. In most of those games we lost we were like 3 points down so if we were able to pick up one more TD then naturally we would be winning by 4 points. I took the 4 points and divided it into the 16 game season and that would mean 4 extra games we would have won. Our season was 8-8, but if you add the 4 extra games won our season would have been 12-4, basically sweeping our division. So in essance he would have been 50% of our offense. Of course not including ARE, Portis, Betts, Cooley or Sellers.

Eh. Way too many variables for that to be a valid argument. Chad put up those numbers on an offense without a TE like Cooley or the rushing attack a guy like Portis brings. Also, it's hard to dispute that a healthy Carson Palmer is a good bit better than Jason Campbell right now. Plus the offenses are so different on each team. And to compare Chad's stats to Moss' is tough to do because Santana never had a Houshmanzadeh caliber #2 to draw coverage. To say Chad's numbers on that Bengals team would directly translate into his production as a Redskin isn't a great argument IMO.