Poll: Pick a knucklehead

[firstdown]

Originally Posted by GusFrerotte

DB, Vick was one of the most athletic guys in the NFL, but was too inconsistent as a passer to want him on our squad. JC is a better passer than Vick hands down. If we had a real "Posse" for JC he would be hitting the 3,000-3,500 yards passing range every season. Not sure if we could do that with Vick.

Funny everytime someone mentions JC's stats it always followed with an "if". If he had a line, If he had better WR's, If the coach would let him take more chances, "if" he had more time in the system. When will he use up all his "if's".

[MonkFan4Life]

Originally Posted by firstdown

Funny everytime someone mentions JC's stats it always followed with an "if". If he had a line, If he had better WR's, If the coach would let him take more chances, "if" he had more time in the system. When will he use up all his "if's".

THANK YOU !!!!

I swear I get sick and tired of every excuse in the world thrown out there for Jason Campbell. He doesn't have a line but there is enough of a line for Portis to go over 1,000. The Defense needs to give him better chances by creating turnovers. I mean let's be serious. And I say that to say this, it would be Vick. You could get me all the receivers in the world but until we have someone that will throw that ball then it won't matter. I'd love to have Brandon but if you won't throw the ball then there's no point. Get me Vick, so the guys I have now can feel as though the ball might come their way when they run down the field.

[Slingin Sammy 33]

Originally Posted by MonkFan4Life

THANK YOU !!!!

I swear I get sick and tired of every excuse in the world thrown out there for Jason Campbell. He doesn't have a line but there is enough of a line for Portis to go over 1,000. The Defense needs to give him better chances by creating turnovers. I mean let's be serious. And I say that to say this, it would be Vick. You could get me all the receivers in the world but until we have someone that will throw that ball then it won't matter. I'd love to have Brandon but if you won't throw the ball then there's no point. Get me Vick, so the guys I have now can feel as though the ball might come their way when they run down the field.

Ah yes, Vick would be a much better passing option than JC.....

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by Slingin Sammy 33

Ah yes, Vick would be a much better passing option than JC.....

Can you imagine Vick starting for us last year? Receivers running the wrong routes, the line breaking down, and Vick at the helm? It would've looked like the Keystone Kops out there.

[Slingin Sammy 33]

Originally Posted by 53Fan

Can you imagine Vick starting for us last year? Receivers running the wrong routes, the line breaking down, and Vick at the helm? It would've looked like the Keystone Kops out there.

Not only that, but we would've likely been in position to draft Sanchez (ugh) rather than have Orakpo fall to us.

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by Slingin Sammy 33

Not only that, but we would've likely been in position to draft Sanchez (ugh) rather than have Orakpo fall to us.

I don't even want to think about that. Thank God it didn't happen.