Devin Thomas kick returns??

[skinsnut]

The only way Rock is cut is if some of the backup RB's can prove they can pass block and catch too.

I really don't think a one dimensional home run hitting runner is enough to consider cutting a "rock" solid special teamer.

Remember last year?
Mason couldn't pass block, and screwed up his Special teams attempts....and I don't remember how he did catching passes.

The problem with some of these little RBs is this...they are way too small to effectively pick up a delayed blitz.
As much as I like the little guys...in order to get playing time, they need to protect the passer first and foremost

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by skinsnut

The only way Rock is cut is if some of the backup RB's can prove they can pass block and catch too.

I really don't think a one dimensional home run hitting runner is enough to consider cutting a "rock" solid special teamer.

Remember last year?
Mason couldn't pass block, and screwed up his Special teams attempts....and I don't remember how he did catching passes.

The problem with some of these little RBs is this...they are way too small to effectively pick up a delayed blitz.
As much as I like the little guys...in order to get playing time, they need to protect the passer first and foremost

I'm confused, are we talking about the same player? Rock Cartwright? The reason Rock is 3rd on the depth chart is cause he doesn't run as good as Portis and Betts. You mention "home run hitter" ....when? not at RB. He's never been that. So you must be talking about as a KR, which again I would challenge how many times he has run a kick off for a touch down. I'm not exactly sure myself but I'm betting it's only like 2 or 3 times in his 7 yrs in the NFL.

I'm not trying to be a butt hole, honestly, but I get all confused about the love fest for Rock. Yes he is a good KR, not great, but good. He constantly will get your team to the 30 yrd line.

If I had to pick between Betts and Rock I'd pick Betts. The yr Rock was our starting RB under Spurrier Betts did the KR/PR duties very well, because of this Rock is expendable. Yes Dorsey might get eaten up by a pass rush, but most pass rushes the QB has to have a dump off guy anyway. I would put Dorsey in the back field with Portis or Sellers to block. Slide Dorsey out into the open as the dump off guy.

[redskinfan401]

Originally Posted by SBXVII

I'm confused, are we talking about the same player? Rock Cartwright? The reason Rock is 3rd on the depth chart is cause he doesn't run as good as Portis and Betts. You mention "home run hitter" ....when? not at RB. He's never been that. So you must be talking about as a KR, which again I would challenge how many times he has run a kick off for a touch down. I'm not exactly sure myself but I'm betting it's only like 2 or 3 times in his 7 yrs in the NFL.

He didn't say Rock was a home run hitter. He said that giving up the a valuable special teams contributer who consistently gets you out to the 30-35 yard line for a potential home run hitter isn't worth it. Rock doesn't just return kicks. He plays on coverage units as well. Unless one of the young guys shows that they can return kicks, block, and cover kicks on ST, I doubt Rock will go anywhere. The third RB is typically more valuable on special teams than on offense, so having a one-dimensional 3rd RB who can't block doesn't make a lot of sense.