Roy Williams done for preseason

[dmek25]

Originally Posted by sandtrapjack

Wow, can they even have a full season before passing such judgement?

The guy has played a total of 7 regular season games wih his QB.

But of course all those trades and high-priced free agent signings over the years by Snyder have paid HUGE dividends now haven't they?

calm down. you are usually a pretty rational person. i wasn't giving any opinion. i just wanted your take on the trade

[sandtrapjack]

Originally Posted by dmek25

calm down. you are usually a pretty rational person. i wasn't giving any opinion. i just wanted your take on the trade

Sorry, but have had a lot shots directed my way lately (all justified I assure you).

But was in a "instinctive defensive posture" if you get my meaning.

But actually what I said is what I feel about this trade. RW came in mid season last year, had to learn a new offense without mini-camps or training camp to help. Then the starting QB goes down for 3 weeks.

Now he has a full off season under his belt, I just want to see what he can do before I pass any judgement.

He does not have to be T.O. like most sports writers think. If the Cowboys wanted a T.O. they would not have released him. He just needs to be Roy Williams and play his football. If it does not work, it is not his fault, it is all on Jones. This is his risk, not RW's.

[Monkeydad]

Originally Posted by sandtrapjack

Sorry, but have had a lot shots directed my way lately (all justified I assure you).

But was in a "instinctive defensive posture" if you get my meaning.

But actually what I said is what I feel about this trade. RW came in mid season last year, had to learn a new offense without mini-camps or training camp to help. Then the starting QB goes down for 3 weeks.

Now he has a full off season under his belt, I just want to see what he can do before I pass any judgement.

He does not have to be T.O. like most sports writers think. If the Cowboys wanted a T.O. they would not have released him. He just needs to be Roy Williams and play his football. If it does not work, it is not his fault, it is all on Jones. This is his risk, not RW's.

You're a Dallas fan on a Redskins board...of course you're going to "have a lot of shots directed your way".

I'd expect the same if I ventured onto Jerrahsfairyland.com boards for some unknown reason.

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by sandtrapjack

Sorry, but have had a lot shots directed my way lately (all justified I assure you).

But was in a "instinctive defensive posture" if you get my meaning.

But actually what I said is what I feel about this trade. RW came in mid season last year, had to learn a new offense without mini-camps or training camp to help. Then the starting QB goes down for 3 weeks.

Now he has a full off season under his belt, I just want to see what he can do before I pass any judgement.

He does not have to be T.O. like most sports writers think. If the Cowboys wanted a T.O. they would not have released him. He just needs to be Roy Williams and play his football. If it does not work, it is not his fault, it is all on Jones. This is his risk, not RW's.

Although T.O. is a head case he takes a lot of punishment in order to get the job done. In other words he is a physical WR. True he does not like to get creamed by a Safety but otherwise he will fight for the ball. Taking his lumps and playing week in and week out.

I'm not sticking up for T.O. Just trying to point out that Williams has not been that type of WR since he came to the league which is why Detroit got rid of him. Oh he has size and some speed but for some reason he has not panned out. Maybe he will with Dallas.

I think my big question is who's going to step up on the opposite side of the field? The Eagles have the same problem. We (and I'm refering to Skin fans) know what it's like to have only one legitimate WR. Moss got doubled all the time and other teams stacked the box. I feel sorry for the Giants who lost 2 good WR's.

As for the whole in Snyder's pocket......blah, blah, blah. He has kept it in his pocket for a few yrs now. Last yr we had to do something about the DE position due to injury. This yr Snyder understood he needed a pass rush. He went out and got the best DL in the league and best DE/LB (LOL) in the draft. Heck he even went out and picked up Jarmin. So he understood what the team drastically needed vs. spending or a name. Just like JJ did when he went and picked up Williams knowing he was going to most likely let T.O. go but wanted the replacement first.