Vinny tips his hand on the final 53

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by dmvskinzfan08

Out of those top 10 in stats. How many of them play other roles on their teams besides kick returner? Exactly!!

3. Darren Sproles. Excellent RB. Pass catcher and return man.
4. Quintin Demps - Starting safety for Philly. Might be mistaken.
5. Jerious Norwood - Excellent RB. Pass catcher and return man.
7. Ellis Hobbs - Starting CB and return man
10. Leon Washington - Excellent RB. Pass catcher and return man.
11. Josh Cribbs - Decent WR and Excellent return man. Even played Qb in college. Versatile
12. Andre Davis - Decent WR and Excellent return man.

Rock - Excellent ST tackler and decent return man..LMAO

Devin Hester is 28th on the list. Rock must be better than him and Josh Cribbs. ROTFL

Your comical dude!!

Devin Hester Play WR. Josh Cribbs also..

Stat that...lol

interesting that Devin Hester had 0 KR/PR for TD according to the stats hmmm.
and the Number 1 returner had, hmmm, 0 tds.
fascinating.

[dmvskinzfan08]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

interesting that Devin Hester had 0 KR/PR for TD according to the stats hmmm.
and the Number 1 returner had, hmmm, 0 tds.
fascinating.

Okay. Answer this question honestly.

Who would you rather have?

Devin Hester or Rock?
Josh Cribbs or Rock?

Like I said stats are important but they aren't EVERYTHING

As far as the 0 td comment. I think he has been in the league for 7 goingon 8 yrs. So he should havemore than 1 return for a TD..

Look at the versatility of the players on this list. Also look at their ages.

Most play a prominent role on defense or offense. Rock doesn't

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by dmvskinzfan08

Okay. Answer this question honestly.

Who would you rather have?

Devin Hester or Rock?
Josh Cribbs or Rock?

Like I said stats are important but they aren't EVERYTHING

As far as the 0 td comment. I think he has been in the league for 7 goingon 8 yrs. So he should havemore than 1 return for a TD..

Look at the versatility of the players on this list. Also look at their ages.

Most play a prominent role on defense or offense. Rock doesn't

THIS WAS NEVER, EVER THE QUESTION.

You can't have Cribbs or Hester to replace him. You're making a half-wit argument.

If you cut Rock to get a 3rd string RB on the roster who, if he isn't better, at least is younger, then Rock's contribution get replaced by people who probably aren't very good at them. Hey, maybe you get lucky and find another special teams demon in Devin Thomas. But you don't count on it, certainly, and you expect to take a hit on special teams.

Which is justifiable, if you are getting a LOT better on offense. But this is not what is happening here.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by dmvskinzfan08

Okay. Answer this question honestly.

Who would you rather have?

Devin Hester or Rock?
Josh Cribbs or Rock?

Like I said stats are important but they aren't EVERYTHING

As far as the 0 td comment. I think he has been in the league for 7 goingon 8 yrs. So he should havemore than 1 return for a TD..

Look at the versatility of the players on this list. Also look at their ages.

Most play a prominent role on defense or offense. Rock doesn't

This is quite a nice false dilemna. If it were Madden or Fantasy, I personally would want Sproles. BUT this is the NFL, real contracts, real people. We have 3 or 4 people to consider, none of whom are a Hester, Cribbs, or Sproles. Rock is a proven top 6 returner for the past 3 years. That is a good thing. I would like to see DT tonight, see what he can do, and maybe we do let Rock go. But lets not kid ourselves and think Mason, or Aldridge, or Dorsey are equal to Hester/Cribbs/Sproles.

[dmvskinzfan08]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

This is quite a nice false dilemna. If it were Madden or Fantasy, I personally would want Sproles. BUT this is the NFL, real contracts, real people. We have 3 or 4 people to consider, none of whom are a Hester, Cribbs, or Sproles. Rock is a proven top 6 returner for the past 3 years. That is a good thing. I would like to see DT tonight, see what he can do, and maybe we do let Rock go. But lets not kid ourselves and think Mason, or Aldridge, or Dorsey are equal to Hester/Cribbs/Sproles.

Who the hell said that?

the statement I made was about STATS. I am saying that jsut because a player has formidable stats doesn't mean he is the best player. That's why I used Cribbs and Hester as an example. Mason, Aldridge or Dorsey are no where in the league as those guys. But one thing is for sure. Rock is not goign to get any better. Let's just let M.A.D go (Mason, Aldridge & Dorsey) and stick with Rock. then maybe TTB will be available in the future.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by dmvskinzfan08

Who the hell said that?

the statement I made was about STATS. I am saying that jsut because a player has formidable stats doesn't mean he is the best player. That's why I used Cribbs and Hester as an example. Mason, Aldridge or Dorsey are no where in the league as those guys. But one thing is for sure. Rock is not goign to get any better. Let's just let M.A.D go (Mason, Aldridge & Dorsey) and stick with Rock. then maybe TTB will be available in the future.

You just rebutted CRedskinsRule accusation of a false alternative with a false alternative. You are quite a piece of work.

You don't HAVE to release Rock to keep one of Mason/Alridge/Dorsey. It was your idea that Rock should go and make room. It was incredibly shortsighted to ignore that Rock has nothing to do with your desire for a younger, more explosive RB, but yet, that's where we're at.

[Lotus]

We could resolve this argument by having Haynesworth return kicks. It would revolutionize the game.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Lotus

We could resolve this argument by having Haynesworth return kicks. It would revolutionize the game.

Now that would be a sight. Imagine his face as hes huffing down the field, it may be enough to scare the defenders out of the way!

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Lotus

We could resolve this argument by having Haynesworth return kicks. It would revolutionize the game.

Or start another thread about the same topic where you can argue about it in a new setting? LOL.

[dmvskinzfan08]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

Or start another thread about the same topic where you can argue about it in a new setting? LOL.

NO I want to concentrate on the RB position solely and if Rock is expendable..That's why I started the thread. its more straight forward. So people can weigh in..