Report Card

[jamf]

Originally Posted by Redskins_P

Why is not fair to grade the players? After all they're supposed to be making the plays, right? Wouldn't you grade the players based on performance? Players play, coaches coach. It's all about execution.

I don't get your grading system.

if you put jeff gordan in a pinto, do you complain when he finishes last?

the WR's ran comeback routes all year. every DB in the league knows that no deep balls will be thrown.
receivers never had a chance to catch the ball while moving downfield. running backs never got into the secondary. all completed passes were dump passes.

coles had 80+ receptions and less than a 1000 yards receiving. it wasnt for lack of effort either.

do you grade coles for a crappy yards per catch or do yo grade for catches? or do you say he was given a pinto to drive...

[Redskins_P]

Originally Posted by jamf

if you put jeff gordan in a pinto, do you complain when he finishes last?

the WR's ran comeback routes all year. every DB in the league knows that no deep balls will be thrown.
receivers never had a chance to catch the ball while moving downfield. running backs never got into the secondary. all completed passes were dump passes.

coles had 80+ receptions and less than a 1000 yards receiving. it wasnt for lack of effort either.

do you grade coles for a crappy yards per catch or do yo grade for catches? or do you say he was given a pinto to drive...

All those things you pointed out falls on the O-line. Except for Coles. The WR's ran post routes, and flys. Problem is the QB didn't have enough time to throw. Or the QB wasn't accurate.