Randle El Fair Catches His Way to the Bench

[Meks]

randle el sucks, point blank

[Beemnseven]

Originally Posted by Meks

randle el sucks, point blank

Thank you. It's a complete mystery to me why people want to keep giving him the benefit of doubt. He's done NOTHING for us. No, it's not his fault that he was overpaid. The only positive thing about his acquisition is that it was one of the few that didn't involve us parting with draft picks to get him.

I, for one will be glad when his overrated ass is gone in favor of somebody who gives a sh*t.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by Beemnseven

Thank you. It's a complete mystery to me why people want to keep giving him the benefit of doubt. He's done NOTHING for us. No, it's not his fault that he was overpaid. The only positive thing about his acquisition is that it was one of the few that didn't involve us parting with draft picks to get him.

I, for one will be glad when his overrated ass is gone in favor of somebody who gives a sh*t.

Thomas and Kelly are the ones that have done nothing if you want to talk about production.

If ARE was making the vet min would you think differently?

[warpaint]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

Thomas and Kelly are the ones that have done nothing if you want to talk about production.

If ARE was making the vet min would you think differently?

I would to be honest, but I still wouldnt want him to be back there as a punt returner. He just doesnt put fear in anyone now.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by warpaint

I would to be honest, but I still wouldnt want him to be back there as a punt returner. He just doesnt put fear in anyone now.

I don't want him on returns either, he should have been replaced a while ago.

However as a receiver he's not a horrible #3 guy. Granted he is way overpaid but that's a function of how our FO works. If he were a vet min guy I think people would look at him differently.

[Beemnseven]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

Thomas and Kelly are the ones that have done nothing if you want to talk about production.

If ARE was making the vet min would you think differently?

Thomas and Kelly suck too. But that doesn't change the fact that Randle El has been a miserable free agent pickup. Can you think of one game since 2006 where we could collectively say, "thank goodness we signed Randle El, he REALLY came through for us today."

As far as his salary goes, it would be nice if we built this team with guys who are hungry, and eager to prove themselves as opposed to flashy guys who in the back of their minds know they will be well compensated no matter how they produce. Antwaan personifies that failed approach.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by Beemnseven

Thomas and Kelly suck too. But that doesn't change the fact that Randle El has been a miserable free agent pickup. Can you think of one game since 2006 where we could collectively say, "thank goodness we signed Randle El, he REALLY came through for us today."

As far as his salary goes, it would be nice if we built this team with guys who are hungry, and eager to prove themselves as opposed to flashy guys who in the back of their minds know they will be well compensated no matter how they produce. Antwaan personifies that failed approach.

If ARE is a miserable pickup as you say, what does that make someone like Lloyd?

[warpaint]

Originally Posted by Beemnseven

Thomas and Kelly suck too. But that doesn't change the fact that Randle El has been a miserable free agent pickup.

I think it is to early to say that. True they haven't done any thing of yet,but neither has any one on offense. JC has not done anything to make any one look good, he misses wide open recievers, wide open recievers drop catchable balls, the O-line cant open up a run lane, RB's cant find a hole when they do they run out of gas, JC doesn't have enough time to throw, while running the 2 minute offense thats when Zorn decides to jump in throw the timing off by calling plays. Zorn did finally get something right benching ARE or was it a diffrent set of eyes.

[mlmdub130]

Originally Posted by Beemnseven

Thank you. It's a complete mystery to me why people want to keep giving him the benefit of doubt. He's done NOTHING for us. No, it's not his fault that he was overpaid. The only positive thing about his acquisition is that it was one of the few that didn't involve us parting with draft picks to get him.

I, for one will be glad when his overrated ass is gone in favor of somebody who gives a sh*t.

nothing for us? that's one of the dumbest things i have read on here, granted he is not a number two receiver, we got him for that position(not his fault) and he has done pretty damn good for us as far as a receiver, to say he has done nothing for us is just crazy to me, but as for special teams he should have been replaced two years ago he hasn't done much for us there and seems to be getting worse, but he has been a damn good receiver across the middle somthing we have lacked since lossing lav coles

[Beemnseven]

Originally Posted by mlmdub130

nothing for us? that's one of the dumbest things i have read on here, granted he is not a number two receiver, we got him for that position(not his fault) and he has done pretty damn good for us as far as a receiver, to say he has done nothing for us is just crazy to me, but as for special teams he should have been replaced two years ago he hasn't done much for us there and seems to be getting worse, but he has been a damn good receiver across the middle somthing we have lacked since lossing lav coles

In terms of what he was supposed to do for our offense, he simply hasn't produced. Yes, he catches some passes. Occasionally he'll have a 6 or 7 catch game. Whoopee. Go back and listen to Gibbs rave about his abilities on special teams when we first signed him. ARE has been woefully inept as a punt returner.

And no, you cannot cite him as an example of a receiver who has been "pretty damn good" for us. In fact, outside of Moss, (and even he has been more down than up recently) you can't say that about ANY receiver for the Washington Redskins for years. Just look at our offense since 2006 -- what "damn good" contribution have you seen from Randle El? The offense has done nothing but suck balls.

Again, it's not his fault that he was signed and overpaid. As I said in my original post, he exemplifies the fallacy of the philosophy of this front office.