nfl week 15

[CRedskinsRule]

the reason he doesn't get the looks is cause he drops and fumbles too much. He's not a huge talent.

[Kalisto2010]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

the reason he doesn't get the looks is cause he drops and fumbles too much. He's not a huge talent.

I respectfully disagree. Sure he's had some inconsistencies but he doesn't get enough reps. Jerry Jones didn't give up a 1st round pick for him because he's a bum. And yes he's a huge talent, you don't start for Texas or go in the first round if your not a huge talent. Don't let your hatred for Dallas derail your objectivity.

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

I respectfully disagree. Sure he's had some inconsistencies but he doesn't get enough reps. Jerry Jones didn't give up a 1st round pick for him because he's a bum. And yes he's a huge talent, you don't start for Texas or go in the first round if your not a huge talent. Don't let your hatred for Dallas derail your objectivity.

Ryan Leaf.

[Kalisto2010]

Originally Posted by 53Fan

Ryan Leaf.

Ryan leaf never had a stellar season in the NFL. Roy's best season he had 82 receptions with over 1300 yards and made the Pro-bowl. Ryan leaf never attained over a 60 QB rating.

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

Ryan leaf never had a stellar season in the NFL. Roy's best season he had 82 receptions with over 1300 yards and made the Pro-bowl. Ryan leaf never attained over a 60 QB rating.

I'm just pointing out that being drafted in the first round doesn't make you a huge talent. And yes, I do...hate the Cowboys.

[Kalisto2010]

Originally Posted by 53Fan

I'm just pointing out that being drafted in the first round doesn't make you a huge talent

Yes it does. No one wastes a first round pick on anyone who's not a huge talent. We'll agree to disagree.

[mlmdub130]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

Yes it does. No one wastes a first round pick on anyone who's not a huge talent. We'll agree to disagree.

there is a huge difference between nfl talent an collee talent though andyou can't always el hich colee talntwill bereat nfl talents

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

Yes it does. No one wastes a first round pick on anyone who's not a huge talent. We'll agree to disagree.

Teams blow millions of dollars in the 1st round every year on guys who flash potential in college.

Aside from one really solid year in Detroit, Roy Williams hasn't done shit in the NFL. I'd love to know why you're singling him out and defending him. He sucks man. Show me stats to prove otherwise (not from a few years back on another team). If he was so great, he'd be taking reps away from undrafted Miles Austin. He's a gigantic underachiever just like every other Matt Millen WR not named Calvin Johnson.

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

Yes it does. No one wastes a first round pick on anyone who's not a huge talent. We'll agree to disagree.

Everyone who has ever been drafted has some talent. That doesn't mean they become good NFL players. That's why there have been many first round "busts". Williams had a good year in Detroit but is not the player he was thought to be. Whether it's a lack of effort or what, I don't know. I would have no problem blaming Romo for anything, but in this case, I can't. Williams is underachieving.

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

I respectfully disagree. Sure he's had some inconsistencies but he doesn't get enough reps. Jerry Jones didn't give up a 1st round pick for him because he's a bum. And yes he's a huge talent, you don't start for Texas or go in the first round if your not a huge talent. Don't let your hatred for Dallas derail your objectivity.

His work ethic is consistently challenged and he drops a lot of passes. You think he sucks as a Cowboy simply because Romo doesn't throw to him enough? Please. If Miles Austin can work his way into all these reps, than your superstar 1st round Texas Talent should be able to do the same. Reps are earned. Roy Williams = BUM/BUST. Flat out.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

I respectfully disagree. Sure he's had some inconsistencies but he doesn't get enough reps. Jerry Jones didn't give up a 1st round pick for him because he's a bum. And yes he's a huge talent, you don't start for Texas or go in the first round if your not a huge talent. Don't let your hatred for Dallas derail your objectivity.

Dude this isn't college, he failed in Detroit, and hasn't stepped up in Dallas. Has nothing to do with hating Dallas, I will give props if a guy deserves it, but RW11 hasn't shown anything in the last couple years to be getting those props.

[12thMan]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

I respectfully disagree. Sure he's had some inconsistencies but he doesn't get enough reps. Jerry Jones didn't give up a 1st round pick for him because he's a bum. And yes he's a huge talent, you don't start for Texas or go in the first round if your not a huge talent. Don't let your hatred for Dallas derail your objectivity.

That's fine. I maintain, however, Williams is a bum. Without looking, I think Williams and Devin Thomas are having comparable seasons. I haven't checked in a while, but I will when I'm done typing this.

As far as him having talent and playing for Texas, a big SO WHAT. What does that have to do with anything? The list is very long of those who were great in college and busts in the NFL. Did it ever occur to you that Roy Williams doesn't get looks because he's not open? Roy Williams runs one or two good routes (slants and posts), take those away and he's a very, very ordinary NFL reciever.

[Kalisto2010]

Originally Posted by 12thMan

That's fine. I maintain, however, Williams is a bum. Without looking, I think Williams and Devin Thomas are having comparable seasons. I haven't checked in a while, but I will when I'm done typing this.

As far as him having talent and playing for Texas, a big SO WHAT. What does that have to do with anything? The list is very long of those who were great in college and busts in the NFL. Did it ever occur to you that Roy Williams doesn't get looks because he's not open? Roy Williams runs one or two good routes (slants and posts), take those away and he's a very, very ordinary NFL reciever.

And I maintain that bums don't make probowls. Roy Williams did. End of story.

[redskins5044]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

And I maintain that bums don't make probowls. Roy Williams did. End of story.

Pro Bowls are a popularity contest.

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by Kalisto2010

And I maintain that bums don't make probowls. Roy Williams did. End of story.

Wait, which Cowboys Roy Williams are you talking about? Because the safety Roy Williams made a few pro-bowls despite being below average at best year in and year out.

You gonna enlighten us as to why you're defending such a worthless joke of a WR who happens to play for our archrival?