Madden '10 xbox 360 league

[MTK]

I'm all for changing up the 4th down stuff, I just think something should be in place to help keep things a little more realistic.

[Skinny Tee]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

I'm all for changing up the 4th down stuff, I just think something should be in place to help keep things a little more realistic.

I like having specific rules in place but anything that alters the legal gameplay of any player shouldn't be considered.

Going for it on 4th down is the weakest thing you can do, I agree, but unfortunately it's something you just can't crack down on. Any person who does so is just severely handicapping their team so that is punishment enough.

If it's legal on the field then it shouldn't have to be penalized outside of the rules of the game.

...that's my contention.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

I'm all for changing up the 4th down stuff, I just think something should be in place to help keep things a little more realistic.

I'm fine with keeping the rules the way you have it. I like playing a somewhat realistic game. This is one of the reasons why I dislike those people that play with the scrambling QBs ALL THE TIME (and I'm glad no one that I've played so far has done this in this league and I thank you all for it). While everyone wants to win, it just takes away from the game when people win on fluke plays and glitches and whatnot.