Updated: Redskins Make Major Roster Cuts

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Pocket$ $traight

Throw Quinn or Anderson in instead of the second! lol

So we get rid of our average QB for a mediocre QB (Anderson) or a QB with the situation where the jury is still out on him? Screw that, give me the pick, let's draft Bradford and get a vet QB in free agency if that's the case.

[Pocket$ $traight]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

So we get rid of our average QB for a mediocre QB (Anderson) or a QB with the situation where the jury is still out on him? Screw that, give me the pick, let's draft Bradford and get a vet QB in free agency if that's the case.

Well Rogers is the best player in the trade, Anderson has accomplished a ton more than Campbell ever has and like you said, the jury is still out on Quinn. I would rather have Okung/Davis and either Quinn/Anderson then Bradford and a second round pick.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by Pocket$ $traight

Well Rogers is the best player in the trade, Anderson has accomplished a ton more than Campbell ever has and like you said, the jury is still out on Quinn. I would rather have Okung/Davis and either Quinn/Anderson then Bradford and a second round pick.

REALLY? Anderson??? You've GOTTA be fucking kidding me!!! Anderson sucks balls. Rogers was hurt during the latter part of the season, and the Browns actually won when he was hurt. And if we're going to go with an unproven QB, then let's draft one.

[Pocket$ $traight]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

REALLY? Anderson??? You've GOTTA be fucking kidding me!!! Anderson sucks balls. Rogers was hurt during the latter part of the season, and the Browns actually won when he was hurt. And if we're going to go with an unproven QB, then let's draft one.

I thought the trade in general was amusing so I threw in one of their QBs.

But to my point, Anderson has undoubtedly accomplished more than JC. Don't believe me, look it up.

[GusFrerotte]

Originally Posted by Pocket$ $traight

Well Rogers is the best player in the trade, Anderson has accomplished a ton more than Campbell ever has and like you said, the jury is still out on Quinn. I would rather have Okung/Davis and either Quinn/Anderson then Bradford and a second round pick.

Always take the pick, especially with the bunch of guys you are talking about. Anderson is better than Quinn, but that is not saying too much. Do you take Anderson/ Quinn or get an extra pick where you could draft a QB. If the pick is for this draft we could draft another QB with it. Only QBs slated to be taken by the second round are the "fab" 4 and maybe Brown from WVa. We could land Bradford/Clausen and Lefevour/Stull/Hall/etc. I rather use our first two picks for linemen, but just saying I rather draft an extra QB in a QB deep draft than get Anderson.

[Pocket$ $traight]

Originally Posted by GusFrerotte

Always take the pick, especially with the bunch of guys you are talking about. Anderson is better than Quinn, but that is not saying too much. Do you take Anderson/ Quinn or get an extra pick where you could draft a QB. If the pick is for this draft we could draft another QB with it. Only QBs slated to be taken by the second round are the "fab" 4 and maybe Brown from WVa. We could land Bradford/Clausen and Lefevour/Stull/Hall/etc.

Why the hell would we take 2 quarterbacks in the first two rounds when we had the worst line in the league?

[GusFrerotte]

Originally Posted by Pocket$ $traight

Why the hell would we take 2 quarterbacks in the first two rounds when we had the worst line in the league?

It is a hypothetical Pocket. I rather would draft two QBs than trade for Anderson or Quinn. THose guys suck. The rationale from that would be similar to why we drafted Frerotte after we got Shuler, that being a young backup, and a possible replacement if the experiment goes awry. IF I was the GM the first two picks are O linemen no matter what. Just saying the choice of a second drafted QB is preferable to Anderson or Quinn in my opinion. Think about it now. Yeah I want Okung and Bruce Campbell if I was the GM, but say Shanny has his eye on Bradford and gets a additional second round pick. He could get a top LT and possibly get Lefevour or Max Hall, etc in the second round. If your stud falters you have another stud that might take over. Not that crazy of a scenario. Not likely to happen, but who knows.

[Pocket$ $traight]

Originally Posted by GusFrerotte

It is a hypothetical Pocket. I rather would draft two QBs than trade for Anderson or Quinn. THose guys suck. The rationale from that would be similar to why we drafted Frerotte after we got Shuler, that being a young backup, and a possible replacement if the experiment goes awry. IF I was the GM the first two picks are O linemen no matter what. Just saying the choice of a second drafted QB is preferable to Anderson or Quinn in my opinion. Think about it now. Yeah I want Okung and Bruce Campbell if I was the GM, but say Shanny has his eye on Bradford and gets a additional second round pick. He could get a top LT and possibly get Lefevour or Max Hall, etc in the second round. If your stud falters you have another stud that might take over. Not that crazy of a scenario. Not likely to happen, but who knows.

Gotcha. I think the whole trade scenario is unrealistic. But I would not pass on a tackle in the first if we were going to take a QB (or two) in the second. I also don't think Bradford is making it to us.