Brandon or T.O. ?

[McD5]

I would love to see us ship a player out, or some combination of a player and low round draft pick for Marshall.

A TE maybe? Landry? Anything like that would work.

[Lotus]

I cannot fathom the continuing talk about Brandon Marshall and the Redskins. Shanny wanted to ditch him in Denver. Therefore Shanny is not bringing him to Washington. End of story, it seems to me.

As for TO, I don't want him taking playing time from Thomas and Kelly.

[skinsfaninok]

I would take Marshall only if we gave Denver our 2011 1st round pick not this years first rder. The guy is easilly a top 3 WR behind fitz and a.Johnson . He gets 100 rec every year.

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by McD5

I would love to see us ship a player out, or some combination of a player and low round draft pick for Marshall.

A TE maybe? Landry? Anything like that would work.

For some reason I pictured the Rams fans saying.....

"I'll take Jason Campbell, I'd would love to see us ship a player out and a low round draft pick for Campbell."

and right about now you guys are saying...."Hell no! Jason is worth more then that. We want a 1st round draft pick." Then their is the more reality based fans who would be saying "We'll take a second or a third round draft pick."

My point. Denver wants a 1st round draft pick for one of the elite WR's in the league. Not a 1st for a mediocre QB or middle of the road WR.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by SBXVII

For some reason I pictured the Rams fans saying.....

"I'll take Jason Campbell, I'd would love to see us ship a player out and a low round draft pick for Campbell."

and right about now you guys are saying...."Hell no! Jason is worth more then that. We want a 1st round draft pick." Then their is the more reality based fans who would be saying "We'll take a second or a third round draft pick."

My point. Denver wants a 1st round draft pick for one of the elite WR's in the league. Not a 1st for a mediocre QB or middle of the road WR.

But no one wants to give them that. Just like the Redskins want at least a 3rd for JC, but no one wants to give them that

[SFREDSKIN]

I would take TO over Marshall. TO is a good guy with a huge ego, Marshall is just a punk with a bad attitude. TO would be cheaper and he stomped on that Dallas star when he was with the niners. I have a feeling he will be a Redskin in 2010.

[Ade Jimoh Fan Club]

I personally think this would be a fair trade for Brandon Marshall:

* We trade 1st round picks with Denver
* We trade 2nd round picks with Denver
* We give them our 4th round pick

DEN gets the 4th, 37th and 103rd

WAS gets the 11th, 45th and Brandon Me-First Marshall

According to the Trade Value Matrix, DEN would get a value of 2,418 and WAS would get 1,700 + Marshall. The 718 difference equates to the 25th pick in the first round of the draft - so in short, DEN would be getting the equivalent of a 1st rounder, and we'd be maintaining our first two picks in a very deep draft AND picking up a legit WR1.

Your thoughts?? Is this too logical for NFL GM's?

Option #2 - bring back THE ADE!!

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by Ade Jimoh Fan Club

I personally think this would be a fair trade for Brandon Marshall:

* We trade 1st round picks with Denver
* We trade 2nd round picks with Denver
* We give them our 4th round pick

DEN gets the 4th, 37th and 103rd

WAS gets the 11th, 45th and Brandon Me-First Marshall

According to the Trade Value Matrix, DEN would get a value of 2,418 and WAS would get 1,700 + Marshall. The 718 difference equates to the 25th pick in the first round of the draft - so in short, DEN would be getting the equivalent of a 1st rounder, and we'd be maintaining our first two picks in a very deep draft AND picking up a legit WR1.

Your thoughts?? Is this too logical for NFL GM's?

Option #2 - bring back THE ADE!!

I'll take option #2 please.

[saden1]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

But no one wants to give them that. Just like the Redskins want at least a 3rd for JC, but no one wants to give them that

If a third string QB like Charlie Whitehurs is worth swap of second round picks (a 20 spot move up for the Chargers) and next year's third rounder I can't imagine why we couldn't get at least a 3rd rounder. The Skins' must want more than a 3rd rounder.

[SirClintonPortis]

Originally Posted by saden1

If a third string QB like Charlie Whitehurs is worth swap of second round picks (a 20 spot move up for the Chargers) and next year's third rounder I can't imagine why we couldn't get at least a 3rd rounder. The Skins' must want more than a 3rd rounder.

"Prices" for QBs always tend to be on the extreme side. They cost a lot if they're even "just good", and they're dirt cheap if no one wants them. Apparently, no one wants to "buy" Campbell for a 2nd or 1st rounder, and for damn good reason.
Campbell's not a sure thing. It's basically gambling with Campbell vs. gambling with grabbing a stud 1st or 2nd round player from the draft, and most would rather gamble with the draft than with a QB who has not shown much in all of his years in the league and has two attributes that leads to near-certain QB failure: bad accuracy and bad pocket presence.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by saden1

If a third string QB like Charlie Whitehurs is worth swap of second round picks (a 20 spot move up for the Chargers) and next year's third rounder I can't imagine why we couldn't get at least a 3rd rounder. The Skins' must want more than a 3rd rounder.

Well they're no longer asking for more than a 3rd rounder (they haven't lately at least). I think others have mentioned it but it seems like Whitehurst has more "value" because of what he has the potential to accomplish. I think most execs feel like they've seen enough of Campbell to know what to expect from him.

Redskins and Broncos, to my knowledge, had very preliminary talks at the beginning of free agency about Marshall but nothing came out of that. Right now, no team is budging on giving up a 1st for Marshall. Redskins will wait and see if it gets to the point that the Broncos feel forced to get rid of Marshall, and the talk was that some package could involve Landry and Kelly.

Who knows for sure though

[joethiesmanfan]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Well they're no longer asking for more than a 3rd rounder (they haven't lately at least). I think others have mentioned it but it seems like Whitehurst has more "value" because of what he has the potential to accomplish. I think most execs feel like they've seen enough of Campbell to know what to expect from him.

Redskins and Broncos, to my knowledge, had very preliminary talks at the beginning of free agency about Marshall but nothing came out of that. Right now, no team is budging on giving up a 1st for Marshall. Redskins will wait and see if it gets to the point that the Broncos feel forced to get rid of Marshall, and the talk was that some package could involve Landry and Kelly.

Who knows for sure though

Smoot got to disagree. Whitehurst is grabidge

[celts32]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Well they're no longer asking for more than a 3rd rounder (they haven't lately at least). I think others have mentioned it but it seems like Whitehurst has more "value" because of what he has the potential to accomplish. I think most execs feel like they've seen enough of Campbell to know what to expect from him.

Redskins and Broncos, to my knowledge, had very preliminary talks at the beginning of free agency about Marshall but nothing came out of that. Right now, no team is budging on giving up a 1st for Marshall. Redskins will wait and see if it gets to the point that the Broncos feel forced to get rid of Marshall, and the talk was that some package could involve Landry and Kelly.

Who knows for sure though

Ugh not Landry...I really think he can still be a good player with different coaching. He's one of the very few players on the roster i would rather not trade.

[McD5]

Originally Posted by SBXVII

For some reason I pictured the Rams fans saying.....

"I'll take Jason Campbell, I'd would love to see us ship a player out and a low round draft pick for Campbell."

and right about now you guys are saying...."Hell no! Jason is worth more then that. We want a 1st round draft pick." Then their is the more reality based fans who would be saying "We'll take a second or a third round draft pick."

My point. Denver wants a 1st round draft pick for one of the elite WR's in the league. Not a 1st for a mediocre QB or middle of the road WR.

I'd take a 4th, maybe even a 5th for JC. Being realistic. I hate to trade draft picks.