McNabb a REDSKIN!

[BigHairedAristocrat]

GREAT move! we are set at QB for the next 5 years. now we have plenty of time to fill our myriad of other needs and draft a franchise QB in 3-4 years. best QB we've had in twenty years.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by BigHairedAristocrat

GREAT move! we are set at QB for the next 5 years. now we have plenty of time to fill our myriad of other needs and draft a franchise QB in 3-4 years. best QB we've had in twenty years.

Or five months. Whichever comes first.

McNabb probably is the best quarterback we've had in 20 years. But he's still the 4th best quarterback in the division, which means we're going to need to look elsewhere to get that competitive advantage against our rivals.

[tryfuhl]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Or five months. Whichever comes first.

McNabb probably is the best quarterback we've had in 20 years. But he's still the 4th best quarterback in the division, which means we're going to need to look elsewhere to get that competitive advantage against our rivals.

I don't know.. by stats he's 2nd, including the advanced type of stats that you like.. until you say that stats don't matter then back it up with stats

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by tryfuhl

I don't know.. by stats he's 2nd, including the advanced type of stats that you like.. until you say that stats don't matter then back it up with stats

I did this once before and I'll do it again.....

NFL - Head to Head Stats...

McNabbs stats are not that much better especially with a better OL.

[tryfuhl]

Originally Posted by SBXVII

I did this once before and I'll do it again.....

NFL - Head to Head Stats...

McNabbs stats are not that much better especially with a better OL.

look past just those basic stats

ProFootballFocus.com - By Position

Philly wasn't so hot at pass blocking anyways.. they were a good run blocking team, but McNabb took quite a few sacks and were ranked in the 20s as well

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by tryfuhl

I don't know.. by stats he's 2nd, including the advanced type of stats that you like.. until you say that stats don't matter then back it up with stats

In 2009 DVOA, Romo was 7th, Eli was 11th, Kolb (who barely qualified) was 16th, and McNabb was 20th. Campbell was 25th.

We could argue all day whether McNabb or Kolb is the better 2010 QB, but the team that had them both thinks Kolb is. We think McNabb is.

[tryfuhl]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

In 2009 DVOA, Romo was 7th, Eli was 11th, Kolb (who barely qualified) was 16th, and McNabb was 20th. Campbell was 25th.

We could argue all day whether McNabb or Kolb is the better 2010 QB, but the team that had them both thinks Kolb is. We think McNabb is.

We may think that Kolb is as well, but if they're enamored then it probably isn't worth us giving it up. Plus we probably want a veteran to lead us into the next "era"

People put value on potential play.. we've seen it before.. kind of like Favre/Rodgers just because of different reasons