AH trade II La Canfora insists AH is indeed on the trading block.

[BigHairedAristocrat]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

How about Haynesworth alone for both of the Titans 3rd round picks?

Absolutely not.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by BigHairedAristocrat

Absolutely not.

But you would trade Haynesworth, Rogers and Kelly for a first round pick?

[BigHairedAristocrat]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

But you would trade Haynesworth, Rogers and Kelly for a first round pick?

Yes. I stated that felt Haynesworth was worth 700 points.

The titans natural 3rd round pick is worth only 205 points. the titans second 3rd rounder is a compensatory pick (for losing haynesworth last year) and is not trade-able. even if it was tradeable, it would only be worth about 115points. Those two picks are nowhere near worth Haynesworths value (to me).

Since the Titans 1st round pick is worth 1000 points, and I value Haynesworth at 700 points, we'd need to find a way to make up the remaining 300 points. a pick near the bottom of the 2nd round is worth 300 points. Bringing in Buchanon makes rogers somewhat expendable. I personally think Rogers is worth a 2nd rounder, but evidently no one else does or he would have been traded a long time ago. we'd need to offer something else to sweeten the deal. Enter Malcom Kelly. He's been rumored to be part of half a dozen potential trades SmootSmack has mentioned over the past couple of months so I think including him would make some sense.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by BigHairedAristocrat

Yes. I stated that felt Haynesworth was worth 700 points.

The titans natural 3rd round pick is worth only 205 points. the titans second 3rd rounder is a compensatory pick (for losing haynesworth last year) and is not trade-able. even if it was tradeable, it would only be worth about 115points. Those two picks are nowhere near worth Haynesworths value (to me).

Since the Titans 1st round pick is worth 1000 points, and I value Haynesworth at 700 points, we'd need to find a way to make up the remaining 300 points. a pick near the bottom of the 2nd round is worth 300 points. Bringing in Buchanon makes rogers somewhat expendable. I personally think Rogers is worth a 2nd rounder, but evidently no one else does or he would have been traded a long time ago. we'd need to offer something else to sweeten the deal. Enter Malcom Kelly. He's been rumored to be part of half a dozen potential trades SmootSmack has mentioned over the past couple of months so I think including him would make some sense.

Rumored to be part of one trade, and that was a package deal for Brandon Marshall.

Also,

Redskins' Allen Sees Draft As Chance To Improve

Anytime a first round pick is traded, Jimmy Johnson’s famous point value chart is cited to determine if each team got fair value.

Allen and Shanahan don’t subscribe to that philosophy.

“It really is a deterrent to trading,” Allen said. “If you analyze [the chart], it takes so many draft choices to move up just a few slots. That’s prevented a lot of people from making more moves on draft day.”

[freddyg12]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Rumored to be part of one trade, and that was a package deal for Brandon Marshall.

Also,

Redskins' Allen Sees Draft As Chance To Improve

Anytime a first round pick is traded, Jimmy Johnson’s famous point value chart is cited to determine if each team got fair value.

Allen and Shanahan don’t subscribe to that philosophy.

“It really is a deterrent to trading,” Allen said. “If you analyze [the chart], it takes so many draft choices to move up just a few slots. That’s prevented a lot of people from making more moves on draft day.”

Of what I've seen of the draft chart it really seems dated & backwards in relation to the cap. The Patriots try to move back every year to draft more in the 2nd & 3rd rounds. These picks aren't high value on the chart compared to top 10 picks, but they don't cost so much. It seems every team has figured out that trading into the top 10 is rarely worth it due to the salary & the cost in picks to move up.

If anything, the chart should weigh the economic impact of the top picks, thus reducing their point totals. As it is now, most teams operate counter intuitively to the chart.