Update: Malcolm Kelly To Be Placed On IR

[saden1]

Originally Posted by tryfuhl

Better than 90% puts him in the top 3ish QBs, which he is not.

Brady, Manning, and Favre....who else is better than McNabb?

[wilsowilso]

Originally Posted by saden1

Brady, Manning, and Favre....who else is better than McNabb?

Drew Brees might be the best QB in the NFL and Aaron Rodgers is going to have another monster year.

I say McNabb is easy top ten, but not top five.

[GTripp0012]

Drew Brees?

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by saden1

Brady, Manning, and Favre....who else is better than McNabb?

For 2010 I'd take Manning, Brady, Aaron Rogers, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, and probably Matt Schaub and Brett Favre over McNabb. I do think he's in the lower half of the top 10 in the league, which is still pretty darn good.

[tryfuhl]

Originally Posted by GMScud

For 2010 I'd take Manning, Brady, Aaron Rogers, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, and probably Matt Schaub and Brett Favre over McNabb. I do think he's in the lower half of the top 10 in the league, which is still pretty darn good.

With Warner's retirement, Roethlisberger's suspension, doubt about the Giants, Favre's uncertainty, he could easily slide in to say the 8 spot.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by tryfuhl

With Warner's retirement, Roethlisberger's suspension, doubt about the Giants, Favre's uncertainty, he could easily slide in to say the 8 spot.

Yeah, I can see #8 this year. I can kinda see the McNabb side of Eli vs. McNabb, but based on recent history (just the last two years) Eli has been a little bit above McNabb in terms of production.

It's just two years though, so I can see the system change propeling McNabb back to second in the division. It's a small leap of faith, but justifiable for a Redskins fan.

[tryfuhl]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Yeah, I can see #8 this year. I can kinda see the McNabb side of Eli vs. McNabb, but based on recent history (just the last two years) Eli has been a little bit above McNabb in terms of production.

It's just two years though, so I can see the system change propeling McNabb back to second in the division. It's a small leap of faith, but justifiable for a Redskins fan.

No doubt.. and John Clayton might agree with us

Ranking the Beast quarterbacks - NFC East Blog - ESPN

9. Donovan McNabb, Washington Redskins

Clayton's analysis: Mike Shanahan offers McNabb play-action options he didn't have with the Eagles' pass-heavy offense. With McNabb at the helm, the Redskins could be one of the surprise teams in the NFC.

Arrow is pointing: Spinning as he adjusts to a new offense

Mosley's take: I have immense respect for McNabb's fine work, but he probably wouldn't make my "elite" list. This is something that McNabb will undoubtedly use as motivation in 2010.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by GMScud

For 2010 I'd take Manning, Brady, Aaron Rogers, Tony Romo, Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, and probably Matt Schaub and Brett Favre over McNabb. I do think he's in the lower half of the top 10 in the league, which is still pretty darn good.

I'm not taking Matt Schaub over McNabb. Sorry but the guy's only done it for one year and is as soft as butter. And I'm not even sure about Romo or Rivers. I'd say right now they're probably even but McNabb has done more with less so you could easily argue that McNabb is better than both of them.

[tryfuhl]

Originally Posted by saden1

Brady, Manning, and Favre....who else is better than McNabb?

Brees, Rodgers, Rivers first come to mind

then you can argue Schaub, Roethlisberger, Romo and little Manning

[saden1]

Originally Posted by tryfuhl

Brees, Rodgers, Rivers first come to mind

then you can argue Schaub, Roethlisberger, Romo and little Manning

Forgot about Drew Brees. Rodgers and Rivers aren't better...they're on par at best. Give them a few years and maybe we can say they are better.

[tryfuhl]

Originally Posted by saden1

Forgot about Drew Breeze. Rodgers and Rivers aren't better...they're on par at best.

Situationally you could make an argument for having any of them, I'm just saying who had the better performances across the season.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by saden1

Forgot about Drew Breeze. Rodgers and Rivers aren't better...they're on par at best. Give them a few years and maybe we can say they are better.

If you value accuracy even in the slightest, it's hard to argue in favor of McNabb.

I can't think of one thing McNabb does better than Rivers. Throw deep? Nah.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

If you value accuracy even in the slightest, it's hard to argue in favor of McNabb.

I can't think of one thing McNabb does better than Rivers. Throw deep? Nah.

they're both very good deep throwers. they're just different types of qb's but both are very good.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

they're both very good deep throwers. they're just different types of qb's but both are very good.

Very good almost undersells Rivers' deep accuracy. McNabb still misses a lot in the deep field, but he ranks a lot higher in those stats than in the intermediate and short field breakdowns. I think he's a top five deep ball thrower, if possibly just fourth or fifth best.

[tryfuhl]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

If you value accuracy even in the slightest, it's hard to argue in favor of McNabb.

I can't think of one thing McNabb does better than Rivers. Throw deep? Nah.

Scramble