The never ending Jason Campbell player haters ball

[mredskins]

2010 Week One QB ratings

McNabb 63.4

Drum roll

JC 69.7

Just say'n

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by mredskins

2010 Week One QB ratings

McNabb 63.4

Drum roll

JC 69.7

Just say'n

McNabb - About 6 dropped passes, 1 being a potential TD. 5.32 YPA. 0 ints.

JC - 4.86 YPA (A stat that might be more important then Passing efficiency once you factor in a TD:INT ratio)

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag359

McNabb - About 6 dropped passes, 1 being a potential TD. 5.32 YPA. 0 ints.

JC - 4.86 YPA (A stat that might be more important then Passing efficiency once you factor in a TD:INT ratio)

McNabb 1-0

JC 0-1

the more important stat

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

McNabb 1-0

JC 0-1

the more important stat

I personally try to steer clear of that stat. From what I've seen it's not exactly fair to peg wins and losses solely on the QB. My favorite example being 2008 Drew Brees. In 2008 the Saints were 7-9 when Brees posted a 96.2 passer rating with an 8.0 YPA. 2008 also saw Aaron Rodgers post a 93.2 passer rating with 7.5 YPA for a 6-10 team.

By the Wins-Loss rational Kerry Collins, Tavaris Jackson, and Jake Delhome were all better QB's in 2008 then Brees and Rodgers.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag359

I personally try to steer clear of that stat. From what I've seen it's not exactly fair to peg wins and losses solely on the QB. My favorite example being 2008 Drew Brees. In 2008 the Saints were 7-9 when Brees posted a 96.2 passer rating with an 8.0 YPA. 2008 also saw Aaron Rodgers post a 93.2 passer rating with 7.5 YPA for a 6-10 team.

By the Wins-Loss rational Kerry Collins, Tavaris Jackson, and Jake Delhome were all better QB's in 2008 then Brees and Rodgers.

Yeah I know it not particularly fair, I think there is some truth to it. Does Redskins win that game with JC at QB Sunday nite? Its not all stats all the time.

But I was mostly just fueling this pointless debate:FIREdevil

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by mredskins

2010 Week One QB ratings

McNabb 63.4

Drum roll

JC 69.7

Just say'n

LOL. The difference was McNabb didn't turn the ball over and he only took one sack. But this thread is stupid. Not even Peyton Manning would do well out in Oak. As someone else mentioned, what is an average QB going to do on a team that is worse than the 09 Skins? This thread should be closed.

[mredskins]

Originally Posted by mredskins

2010 Week One QB ratings

McNabb 63.4

Drum roll

JC 69.7

Just say'n

Wow this sparked some debate, I personally could careless and wish JC the best.

QB rating is is like WHiP in baseball the number really doesn't tell the whole story of how good the QB or pitcher played. So many intangibles that those stats don't capture.

McNabb on the final drive was awesome he kept us alive and the ball out of the Cowboys hands, hard to measure that in a QB rating but it played a major role in the outcome of the game.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by mredskins

Wow this sparked some debate, I personally could careless and wish JC the best.

QB rating is is like WHiP in baseball the number really doesn't tell the whole story of how good the QB or pitcher played. So many intangibles that those stats don't capture.

McNabb on the final drive was awesome he kept us alive and the ball out of the Cowboys hands, hard to measure that in a QB rating but it played a major role in the outcome of the game.

Good analogy. Accurate, too.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by mredskins

2010 Week One QB ratings

McNabb 63.4

Drum roll

JC 69.7

Just say'n

Irrelevant, just like this thread.