Your 2010 NFL MVP is?

[saden1]

lol @ GTripp...you are needlessly so full of it. Foster = Vick my ass.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by saden1

lol @ GTripp...you are needlessly so full of it. Foster = Vick my ass.

Hey, you were the first one to say Foster = Vick. I said they are equally valuable to their teams and in the MVP race. They don't even play the same position.

Vick's a quarterback. If you can't appreciate my position that other players at other positions are having as good of a year as Vick -- a guy who has played in just 11 of his teams 14 games -- then it should be a QB award only.

And Vick is clearly not one of the best two quarterbacks this year...even once you include his league-leading rushing value.

[sportscurmudgeon]

I think Brady will win.

If you think Jamal Charles is worthy, then you have to think Maurice Jones-Drew is equally worthy.

Foster is hampered by the fact that his team will not make the playoffs.

Rivers is hampered by the "no-show" status of his team for about 4 games this year.

Some folks who WILL NOT win the award and have not been mentioned here but who have had very good years on 2010:

Jay Cutler
Josh Freeman
Troy Polamalu
Peyton Hillis
Matt Cassel
Darren McFadden

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by sportscurmudgeon

If you think Jamal Charles is worthy, then you have to think Maurice Jones-Drew is equally worthy.[/INDENT]

Maurice Jones-Drew is a great player having a great year. Saying that he's equally worthy as Jamaal Charles would be the same as saying that Drew Brees is equally worthy to Tom Brady.

If you expand the scope of the argument beyond this season, you might find Brees to be every bit as good as Brady historically. But based on just performance in 2010, they're not close. Neither are Jones-Drew and Charles. Which is not a knock on Jones-Drew or Brees. They're just not in the MVP discussion in 2010.