Carson Palmer to Oakland Raiders for 1st/2012

[Meks]

wins, division titles, post. season success albeit no rings..

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Meks

wins, division titles, post. season success albeit no rings..

Are you counting McNabb's accomplishments before 2005, because since 2005, the Bengals won more division titles under Palmer than McNabb won.

But you're being silly. You asked me to reconsider/retract a statement that Palmer in his prime was much better than McNabb in his prime. Then you're talking about how many wins and playoff wins they have.

Regular season, Palmer's been better by every measure except longevity. Playoffs, we'll see. But it's not relevant to this argument or the trade.