2012 QB Prospects (Part 2)

[skinsfaninok]

NE- Loss
@ NYG- Loss
Minn - Loss
@ Phili - Loss

1-5 in the division ad 4-12 overall. Skins will draft 3 or 4 in 2012

[Mechanix544]

I say we end up drafting 5th with Minny, St.Louis, Indy and tampa ahead of us. I think that every one of those teams is fine at the QB position, but Indy WILL take Luck. So the question is, will Tampa take one qb, or will both great qbs drop to the 5th pick, giving us our choice?

Point is, if we end up with Matthew Barkley as our signal caller coming out of the 2012 draft, this draft was a great one. If we end up without him and RG3 turns out to be our qb, then it still will be a good draft. But if we do not get either of them, and Shanny takes a chance on "his" type of guy, say in the 2nd round in order to groom him and such, then I am not so sure...........I wouldnt hate to see Tannehill running our O, shit, he would be better than what we have right now the first day he stepped onto the field, AS A ROOKIE. If that is Shannys direction, then who could you see him rolling with in the first round if he targets tannehill in the 2nd? Would it be a WR? Or would he go OLine?

[Mechanix544]

Or, would he, and I know this would not be very popular in DC right now, but, could he say "**** it Im going D", and ignore the offense for say a shut down corner, or the stud MLB we need to complete our corps?

[mbedner3420]

Originally Posted by Mechanix544

I say we end up drafting 5th with Minny, St.Louis, Indy and tampa ahead of us. I think that every one of those teams is fine at the QB position, but Indy WILL take Luck. So the question is, will Tampa take one qb, or will both great qbs drop to the 5th pick, giving us our choice?

Point is, if we end up with Matthew Barkley as our signal caller coming out of the 2012 draft, this draft was a great one. If we end up without him and RG3 turns out to be our qb, then it still will be a good draft. But if we do not get either of them, and Shanny takes a chance on "his" type of guy, say in the 2nd round in order to groom him and such, then I am not so sure...........I wouldnt hate to see Tannehill running our O, shit, he would be better t
han what we have right now the first day he stepped onto the field, AS A ROOKIE. If that is Shannys direction, then who could you see him rolling with in the first round if he targets tannehill in the 2nd? Would it be a WR? Or would he go OLine?

My only real concern at this point is Cle. SS has already mentioned that the browns are deeply interested in Barkley...

[SFREDSKIN]

One thing I worry about Shanahan is that he would pass Barkley and go for Landry Jones if he decides to enter the draft. I smell a Ryan Leaf vs Manning scenario. Redirect Notice

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

One thing I worry about Shanahan is that he would pass Barkley and go for Landry Jones if he decides to enter the draft. I smell a Ryan Leaf vs Manning scenario. Redirect Notice

I want to say: "well you gotta trust Shanahan and his decision" but then I remember that he went with Rex and Beck this season.

[mbedner3420]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

I want to say: "well you gotta trust Shanahan and his decision" but then I remember that he went with Rex and Beck this season.

I really felt they went with rex and beck because of the lockout. They felt they wouldn't have time coach up a rookie or FA. All bets off if there was no lockout. To me, that decision made sense. No one could have predicted how well Newton and Dalton are doing.

[SkinzWin]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

I want to say: "well you gotta trust Shanahan and his decision" but then I remember that he went with Rex and Beck this season.

Not directed specifically at you, you just brought up the thought in my mind, but I get tired of so many people belittling Shanny for having Rex/Beck as the QB combo this year. If he didn't like the guys available in the draft, then he didn't like them. If he didn't think any FA's were a good fit, then why would he get them. Especially after the bad taste left in his mouth from going out and getting another FA that doesn't pan out the year before in McNabb. You know how all over him people and the media would be?

We have so many problems he can't fix them all in one year. We got some good FA's and some good draft picks. I am confident we will address QB this year in the draft. Rome wasn't built in a day.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

To me if we dont go qb in the first which would be stupid as hell if we have our choice of rg or bark then we go Claiborne or Trent Richardson.

[itvnetop]

308/446 69.1% 3528 yards 39 TDs 7 INTs
261/373 70% 3170 yards 35 TDs 9 INTs

These are the season's stats for two QBs, both in the Pac-12. You may be surprised as to which one is which.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by itvnetop

308/446 69.1% 3528 yards 39 TDs 7 INTs
261/373 70% 3170 yards 35 TDs 9 INTs

These are the season's stats for two QBs, both in the Pac-12. You may be surprised as to which one is which.

Andrew Luck with the 70% and Barkley with the more TDs and ints

[itvnetop]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

Andrew Luck with the 70% and Barkley with the more TDs and ints

Um, you may want to check those stats again. The guy with more TDs has less INTs than the other guy.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by itvnetop

Um, you may want to check those stats again. The guy with more TDs has less INTs than the other guy.

my bad wasnt paying attention but Barkley with the more tds fewer picks and luck with the 70% comp.

[musicmaster45]

Idk Richardson wouldn't be my first choice. I say if no QB or no guard either Claiborne or Vontae Burfect. Both are defensive beasts and would be studs in our defense.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by musicmaster45

Idk Richardson wouldn't be my first choice. I say if no QB or no guard either Claiborne or Vontae Burfect. Both are defensive beasts and would be studs in our defense.

Passing on a talent like Richardson if no qbs are on the board could be like passing on Peterson for Landry. Richardson is a monster and while I love Helu and think he will be a great running back, Trent Richardson will be a special player.