The "Inside Word" on the QB Search

[irish]

Originally Posted by #56fanatic

I disagree with that statement slightly. You dont need a QB like Vick, but the QB needs to be able move around. Rogers, Drew Brees, Rothlisberger, Dalton. Most of the QB's have the ability to extend the play and make throws on the run. What RGIII brings is that ability plus the ability to beat you with his legs. Look at Cam Newton. He has been exceptional this season. If you can get a guy that can make all the throws in the pocket as well as out of the pocket plus run like he can, I dont see how you can pass that up. Plus the kid is extremely football smart.

Cam Newton is going to make the Panthers a playoff team year in and year out. They lost so many games because the D couldn't sustain the early game intensity and gave up 4th quarter leads. When they get healthy on D and add some pieces, they will be dangerous.

You dont need a QB that can beat you with his legs, you need a QB who can beat you with accurate passes. A QB does need to be able to move around but that movement is only 2 or 3 steps in any direction. BR cant run a lick but he can move a couple of steps to get away from the heat plus he's a mountain of a man which makes him tough to bring down. Cam's biggest assett is his size and RGIII doesnt have that. Cam played 1 good season but time will tell if he's a Big Ben or a big version of Vick. Until a run style QB wins something in the pros I'll stick with a pocket passer any day.

[Bushead]

Originally Posted by irish

You dont need a QB that can beat you with his legs, you need a QB who can beat you with accurate passes. A QB does need to be able to move around but that movement is only 2 or 3 steps in any direction. BR cant run a lick but he can move a couple of steps to get away from the heat plus he's a mountain of a man which makes him tough to bring down. Cam's biggest assett is his size and RGIII doesnt have that. Cam played 1 good season but time will tell if he's a Big Ben or a big version of Vick. Until a run style QB wins something in the pros I'll stick with a pocket passer any day.

I can kind of see where you are coming from. Watching the Qbs play yesterday, the biggest thing I noticed is moving around in the pocket and extending plays that way. It's funny that when Rex has plenty of time to throw an no one gets open, he has absolutely no idea what to do and that's where most of his bad plays came from.

But, RGIII isn't just a pure runner. He's got plenty of other strong QB skills, so it won't be just a tuck and run situation. He's going to be able to extend plays in similar ways to pass the ball down the field.

[irish]

Originally Posted by Bushead

I can kind of see where you are coming from. Watching the Qbs play yesterday, the biggest thing I noticed is moving around in the pocket and extending plays that way. It's funny that when Rex has plenty of time to throw an no one gets open, he has absolutely no idea what to do and that's where most of his bad plays came from.

But, RGIII isn't just a pure runner. He's got plenty of other strong QB skills, so it won't be just a tuck and run situation. He's going to be able to extend plays in similar ways to pass the ball down the field.

What I'm saying is when you look at the playoff QBs they are pocket passers who can move a bit to avoid the rush. RGIII is a mover who is a semi-accurate passer and that doesnt work in the NFL.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by irish

What I'm saying is when you look at the playoff QBs they are pocket passers who can move a bit to avoid the rush. RGIII is a mover who is a semi-accurate passer and that doesnt work in the NFL.

People said similar things about Cam last year too.

[irish]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

People said similar things about Cam last year too.

Yep, Cam had 1 decent season and hasnt won anything yet. Time will tell.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by irish

Yep, Cam had 1 decent season and hasnt won anything yet. Time will tell.

Decent?

Give the guy credit, he's going to be the offensive rookie of the year and he broke Manning's record for passing yards as a rookie.

He was very impressive.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

Decent?

Give the guy credit, he's going to be the offensive rookie of the year and he broke Manning's record for passing yards as a rookie.

He was very impressive.

I watched almost every Panthers game this season and the guy is just untouchable, he's really almost unstoppable

[Paintrain]

Originally Posted by irish

Yep, Cam had 1 decent season and hasnt won anything yet. Time will tell.

Damn, how would you define a great rookie season? Broke most rookie PASSING records, protected the ball relatively well, looked like a seasoned pro. Sounds like you have a problem giving credit to QB who have any type of running ability and dismiss all other aspects of their game.

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by Paintrain

Damn, how would you define a great rookie season? Broke most rookie PASSING records, protected the ball relatively well, looked like a seasoned pro. Sounds like you have a problem giving credit to QB who have any type of running ability and dismiss all other aspects of their game.

I'll give him credit for this year. But it's usually the sophomore year they digress, just look at Bradford.

[Swarley]

Originally Posted by irish

What I'm saying is when you look at the playoff QBs they are pocket passers who can move a bit to avoid the rush. RGIII is a mover who is a semi-accurate passer and that doesnt work in the NFL.

What exactly tells you that RGIII doesn't have the accuracy to be a big time NFL QB?

[polywog]

Originally Posted by irish

What I'm saying is when you look at the playoff QBs they are pocket passers who can move a bit to avoid the rush. RGIII is a mover who is a semi-accurate passer and that doesnt work in the NFL.

I disagree.....

Originally Posted by Mattyk

Helu isn't going to be traded for a 2nd and a 4th, that's for sure. That's not even possible in Madden.

Correct, Helu has proven to be an excelent back, but runningbacks in general just don't have that kind of value anymore.