I See QB Rumors (2012 QB Thread: The Sixth Sense)

[NYCskinfan82]

There comes a time when you need NEW QB's, that way the OLD QB's cant teach the NEW QB's bad habits, and that time might be now IMO.

[12thMan]

With Peyton Manning on his way out the door it really makes no sense for the Colts NOT to draft Andrew Luck with the number one pick. That is if they really believe that Luck is a once in a generation quarterback who could put the Colts back on a trajectory of becoming a winning franchise again.

The possibility of Manning not playing for Colts next season (if that indeed happens), I think, is probably Irsay's way of nudging him into retirement out of a genuine concern for his health -- probably moreso than his perceived inability to co-exist with Andrew Luck.

[skinsguy]

Originally Posted by 12thMan

With Peyton Manning on his way out the door it really makes no sense for the Colts NOT to draft Andrew Luck with the number one pick. That is if they really believe that Luck is a once in a generation quarterback who could put the Colts back on a trajectory of becoming a winning franchise again.

The possibility of Manning not playing for Colts next season (if that indeed happens), I think, is probably Irsay's way of nudging him into retirement out of a genuine concern for his health -- probably moreso than his perceived inability to co-exist with Andrew Luck.

And that might be the way the Colts wants everybody to think - that there's no possible way they'd not draft Andrew Luck at #1. Don't get me wrong, I think it's likely the Colts still draft Andrew Luck, but I'm starting to believe it may not be their best option.

[CrustyRedskin]

If thats the case and MS goes less than 9-7 its going to be hard to keep the Buzzards from circling.

[Bubba305-ST21-]

I am not sold on Hoyer or Flynn at all and dont get how people can be. They have barely played! I wouldnt mind picking one of them up for competition with a rookie and really see what they can do. I really am hoping for a trade up for RG3 or i wouldnt mind bradford or luck either, but i feel like whatever i want we never do, I agree with Smoot I can so see us not getting anyone going into next year. I wouldnt be surprised at all.

[NYCskinfan82]

*DREAMING* Indy RGIII, St. Lou Luck, Skins trade back twice pick up 2 additional 2nd rd picks trade their 1st & 2nd for Bradford or Luck. If Indy, St. Lou & Skins were smart they would have an agreement were the skins keep tradeing back in the 1st & keep picking up additonal picks and then they all share the picks. Sounds crazy but remember I'm just dreaming.

[Bubba305-ST21-]

I really want RG3 i think he can be very special but I feel like with all the talk of us moving up to get it him it wont happen, it never works out how everyone says there will be a curveball from him and we wont get him. I hope im wrong

[diehard]

Hoyer = A.J. Feeley = don't believe the hype

[Bubba305-ST21-]

Originally Posted by diehard

Hoyer = A.J. Feeley = don't believe the hype

I agree. What has the guy proven really? same with Flynn. Yea they have played good when they had the chance but in very limited time, its too little to go by for me and to count on being our qb solution.

[Higskin]

Originally Posted by diehard

Hoyer = A.J. Feeley = don't believe the hype

When I see Hoyer's name mentioned, I just can't help but think of the game he came in to last year when the Pats had it wrapped up. He started screwing up and threw an INT and back in came Brady.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Let's say we go Tannehill/Foles/Cousins in round 2, what do we do round 1 if we stay at 6? Who do we prefer Smoot? Blackmon or Claiborne? Chances are one of them will be there at 6 and if one person tells me they both will be gone I will blow up their house and revive The Never Ending Thread.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

Let's say we go Tannehill/Foles/Cousins in round 2, what do we do round 1 if we stay at 6? Who do we prefer Smoot? Blackmon or Claiborne? Chances are one of them will be there at 6 and if one person tells me they both will be gone I will blow up their house and revive The Never Ending Thread.

Tough to say, but probably Claiborne since they expect to make some moves for WR during free agency.

If we stay at 6, and he's not taken yet, I think Claiborne is probably at the top of our list. Or they may go with someone like Riley Reiff

I know a lot of people think they'd just take Tannehill at #6, but I've never thought that. And, for various reasons, I'm starting to have some doubts on just how much they really like him.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Tough to say, but probably Claiborne since they expect to make some moves for WR during free agency.

If we stay at 6, and he's not taken yet, I think Claiborne is probably at the top of our list. Or they may go with someone like Riley Reiff

I know a lot of people think they'd just take Tannehill at #6, but I've never thought that. And, for various reasons, I'm starting to have some doubts on just how much they really like him.

Am I the only one would be upset with a 1st round top 10 pick OT?

[Dirtbag59]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

Am I the only one would be upset with a 1st round top 10 pick OT?

Depends on what the other picks are, but generally speaking it wouldn't be the worst thing we could do.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by Dirtbag59

Depends on what the other picks are, but generally speaking it wouldn't be the worst thing we could do.

Not the worst thing but it's definitely not what I want to see happen:

1st choice: Andrew Luck
2nd choice: Robert Griffin III
3rd choice: Morris Claiborne
4th choice: Justin Blackmon
5th choice: Trent Richardson
6th choice: Trade down
7th choice: Dre Kirkpatrick
8th choice: 1st round offensive lineman