Peyton Manning or RGIII your choice

[mredskins]

Originally Posted by celts32

You underestimate a healthy PM. If he is not good enough to make the redskins a contender then explain why the Colts are 2-14 without him and a Super bowl contender with him?

The Redskins are not just any QB upgrade away from being a Super bowl contender but they may be the right QB away.

If the Colts are such a SB contender with him why are they letting him hit the open market. Hmmmmm???? Hmmmmmm????

[celts32]

Originally Posted by mredskins

If the Colts are such a SB contender with him why are they letting him hit the open market. Hmmmmm???? Hmmmmmm????

The answer to your question is Andrew "Best prospect since Elway" Luck. Plus they are not even sure he's healthy and have to pay him 28 million before they will know for sure. I am sure you know all this...but you did ask the question.

I am not in favor of signing Peyton as my #1 QB plan, my only objection is to the notion that the Redskins could not win with a healthy Manning. The Redskins and 31 other teams could win with him.

[mredskins]

Originally Posted by celts32

The answer to your question is Andrew "Best prospect since Elway" Luck. Plus they are not even sure he's healthy and have to pay him 28 million before they will know for sure. I am sure you know all this...but you did ask the question.

I am not in favor of signing Peyton as my #1 QB plan, my only objection is to the notion that the Redskins could not win with a healthy Manning. The Redskins and 31 other teams could win with him.

I don't think you can win with him anymore because he is not healthy. If he was truly healthy and his old self the Colts keep him and trade that pick for a king's ransom.

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by mredskins

I don't think you can win with him anymore because he is not healthy. If he was truly healthy and his old self the Colts keep him and trade that pick for a king's ransom.

Uh... no. See PM is getting old and will need to be replaced. Now would be the perfect time to either move on with Luck or keep PM and let Luck develope. PM probably has as has been mentioned 2-3 yrs left. No way the Colts pass on their chance to get another PM.

[celts32]

Originally Posted by mredskins

I don't think you can win with him anymore because he is not healthy. If he was truly healthy and his old self the Colts keep him and trade that pick for a king's ransom.

Did you stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night?

No one knows if he will be healthy including the Colts. The point was if he is healthy then he would make the Redskins or anyone else a contender.

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by mredskins

If the Colts are such a SB contender with him why are they letting him hit the open market. Hmmmmm???? Hmmmmmm????

Surely it has nothing to do with PM probably telling the owner he won't play if they draft Luck. Hmmmm???? Hmmmmm?????

New GM, New HC, New Coaching staff... screams of we don't want anything from the past era clouding the new era. But if you really want to know.... we can wait and see instead of jumping to conclusions. If Irsay didn't want to keep PM he would not be wanting to meet with him. He would just cut him like the Raider did Routt. So there still is a chance PM stays probably depending on how their meeting goes.

In other words would PM take a back seat to Luck and I expect the answer would be no and PM released.