Redskins Talking Trade with Raiders?

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by 30gut

Maybe, but he would still be an upgrade from Jammal Brown.

No he is not!! Cooley for Barnes would be a very stupid trade. I've seen plenty of Raider games and Barnes is lucky to be on a team, he is horrible. I would much rather have Polumbus or Smith in there. Barnes just flat out sucks!!

[30gut]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

No he is not!! Cooley for Barnes would be a very stupid trade. I've seen plenty of Raider games and Barnes is lucky to be on a team, he is horrible. I would much rather have Polumbus or Smith in there. Barnes just flat out sucks!!

Yes he is!! lol
I never said anything about Cooley for Barnes.
But not only did Barnes play 16 games (which automatically makes him better then Jammal Brown).
But based on Profootball Focus Barnes graded out better then Brown.
Again its not saying much, but it is what it is.

-httr

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by 30gut

Yes he is!! lol
I never said anything about Cooley for Barnes.
But not only did Barnes play 16 games (which automatically makes him better then Jammal Brown).
But based on Profootball Focus Barnes graded out better then Brown.
Again its not saying much, but it is what it is.

-httr

Enough said:

Oakland Raiders Positions that Could be a Liability in 2012: Right Tackle - SB Nation Bay Area

[Lotus]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Enough said:

Oakland Raiders Positions that Could be a Liability in 2012: Right Tackle - SB Nation Bay Area

Something tells me that Barnes did not write that. Very unflattering. And the article mentions the same penalty-prone behavior that you listed.

[30gut]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Enough said:
Oakland Raiders Positions that Could be a Liability in 2012: Right Tackle - SB Nation Bay Area

How does this man's opinion make Barnes worse then Jammal Brown?

Lets start with the simplest tennant for being a good player: be available.
Barnes started 16 games. Jammal Brown started 14 (and didn't finish all of them).

Profootball Focus produces some of the most objective advanced metrics you can find, here's how they rank them:

Originally Posted by PFF

Jammal Brown (-18.5) Brown looked spent while Chester was never going to live up to the contract the Redskins gave him. At least Chester is decent at something (pass protection), can you say that about Brown?

Originally Posted by PFF

Worst Player: It could have been a lot worse starting Khalif Barnes (-16.1), so perhaps his season was something of a best-case scenario.

Ranking the 2011 Offensive Lines - Part 1 | ProFootballFocus.com