RGIII undergoing total reconstructive surgery: out 6-8 months

[44ever]

Originally Posted by BigHairedAristocrat

Would anyones opinion on when RGIII should come back vary based on Kirk Cousins performance?

For example, if we start 0-3, Cousins doesnt look good, and RGIII is cleared to play, but still not moving as quickly as he has in the past, would you want him to come in, wear a brace, and pretty much be a pocket passer?

On the flip side, lets say RGIIIs recovery is slower than expected. Lets say we start the season 8-0, Cousins looks awesome, and the offense is in a clicking. Do you bench Cousins and let RGIII take his job back, or do you rest him for the remainder of the season so he comes back completely fresh in 2014?

No Brainer Here!!! If we are 8-0 with Cousins, I say give RG3 another season to rest that knee

No matter what the situation, we cant bring RG3 back until he is really 100%

I'll take it a bit further, if Cousins brings us into the playoffs, then trade RG3.

[mbedner3420]

Originally Posted by 44ever

No Brainer Here!!! If we are 8-0 with Cousins, I say give RG3 another season to rest that knee

No matter what the situation, we cant bring RG3 back until he is really 100%

I'll take it a bit further, if Cousins brings us into the playoffs, then trade RG3.

Uhhhmmmm... What?

[los panda]

Originally Posted by mbedner3420

Uhhhmmmm... What?

i see where he's coming from, i don't agree with it at all, but i understand it.

he's got the fear

[RedskinRat]

Originally Posted by los panda

i see where he's coming from, i don't agree with it at all, but i understand it.

he's got the fear

I got it....

Trade all our best players so we can avoid any hope of success. Better consistent failure than occasional success.

[44ever]

Originally Posted by los panda

i see where he's coming from, i don't agree with it at all, but i understand it.

he's got the fear

You are right and I thank you for seeing my point. I do fear the injury and would rather play it safe with Cousins. Keep in mind that the question by BHA was hypothetical and my answer is as well, and it 100% hinges on Cousins success.

[44ever]

Originally Posted by RedskinRat

I got it....

Trade all our best players so we can avoid any hope of success. Better consistent failure than occasional success.

If Cousins takes us into the playoffs or better, he then is our best player... Keep RG3 and you have to eventually trade Cousins, your choice.

[BigHairedAristocrat]

Originally Posted by 44ever

No Brainer Here!!! If we are 8-0 with Cousins, I say give RG3 another season to rest that knee

No matter what the situation, we cant bring RG3 back until he is really 100%

I'll take it a bit further, if Cousins brings us into the playoffs, then trade RG3.

In that situation, I dont think we'd find a single team who would want RG3. They'd want Cousins. He would be cheaper to acquire and come with less question marks. In contrast, RG3 would be very expensive to trade for and he's already proven to be a constant injury concern.

Even when he comes back, you're always going to be worried and theres no evidence to beleive he will ever last an entire NFL season. its much easier for a player like RG3 to withstand a 12 game college season vs. an NFL season where he's exposed to contact in 19-24 games (if you include normal pre-season work and a potential superbowl run).

Its noteworthy that RGIII suffered his knee injury in week 15. It was the 17th game RGIII played in this year, 4 games more than he'd ever played in a college season. RGIII is very muscular and athletic, but his body frame is pretty lanky and his previous injuries mean he will be more succeptable to re-injurying his knees. After what we've seen in his first NFL season, its hard to have any confidence that his body can withstand the rigors of an NFL season. RGIIIs knees just might not be able to handle all the running, flexing, cutting, etc. that he makes in 19+ games.