NFL Awards Show (RGIII is offensive ROY)

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

Luck had plenty of "help".

Avery had 60 catches, Hilton had 50 as a rookie, Allen and Fleener combined for 71 catches at the TE spot. In the running game Ballard and Brown combined for over 1200 yards.

Luck didn't have to deal with losing his top WR & TE for half the season either.

...yeah but he did lose his coach for most of it.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Giantone

...yeah but he did lose his coach for most of it.

Did you notice in Arians' COY award that he specifically mentioned Reggie Wayne, not Andrew Luck? I really thought that was interesting.

I think Arians had as much, if not way more, at keeping that team together and getting them back into games.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by Giantone

...yeah but he did lose his coach for most of it.

Yeah and the guy that stepped in was only head coach of the year so...

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

Yeah and the guy that stepped in was only head coach of the year so...

I agree ,my point is that could really shake up a rookie QB.

[Giantone]

I know we have only mention the big 3,Wilson, RGIII and Luck but lets not forget this guy...Colin Kaepernick,YES I know it's his second year but he might as well be a rookie.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Giantone

I know we have only mention the big 3,Wislon, RGII and Luck but lets not forget this guy...Colin Kaepernick,YES I know it's his second year but he might as well be a rookie.

umm he can't be rookie of the year, if he's not a rookie, So I wouldn't think he would come up in this context.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

umm he can't be rookie of the year, if he's not a rookie, So I wouldn't think he would come up in this context.

As I said I realise he's not a rookie but in the context of a first year starting QB all 4 did a great job.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Giantone

As I said I realise he's not a rookie but in the context of a first year starting QB all 4 did a great job.

ok, but that wasn't what the context of the discussion was.

[SCRedskinsFan]

Originally Posted by Giantone

I know we have only mention the big 3,Wislon, RGII and Luck but lets not forget this guy...Colin Kaepernick,YES I know it's his second year but he might as well be a rookie.

This is the second time you've brought RGIII's father (RGII) into a discussion on this board. C'mon get with it already -- and who in blazes is Wislon?

And yes this thread is about Rookie of the Year, not quasi, not alternate, not kind-a-like...

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by SCRedskinsFan

This is the second time you've brought RGIII's father (RGII) into a discussion on this board. C'mon get with it already -- and who in blazes is Wislon?

And yes this thread is about Rookie of the Year, not quasi, not alternate, not kind-a-like...

Thank you,it's what hat happens when I type when I'm tired.I apologize.

[artmonkforhallofamein07]

Originally Posted by Giantone

...yeah but he did lose his coach for most of it.

I actually think that may have helped a little bit. The extra emotional charge it gave the team.

Let's not downplay anything about any of these teams. All three made the playoffs. All three Qbs had help. Hell we were the only one of the three to win the division also.