Around the NFL Free Agency Thread 2013

[MTK]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

But are they really better than Hall? Winfield is 40

35, 40 same thing apparently

Using that logic Hall is 35

Always amazed at the love for Hall, I don't get it.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

35, 40 same thing apparently

Using that logic Hall is 35

Always amazed at the love for Hall, I don't get it.

Ive wanted to mention this after a couple comments this week.

Apparently Hall cant do any wrong now, but he gets crushed repeatedly during the season as the worst thing on this Earth.

I dont get it. There was no love for Carlos when he left (who was a much better, more talented player), but there is love for a guy who is clearly at the end of his career.

Dont get me wrong, I've been a Hall defender in the past. Thought he was better than what the stats say. But clearly his play has been much more eratic the last couple years (i.e. this year: first 8 games horrible, last 8 games improved play).

Its time to move on, we need more stable, consistent coverage from our starting corner.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

Ive wanted to mention this after a couple comments this week.

Apparently Hall cant do any wrong now, but he gets crushed repeatedly during the season as the worst thing on this Earth.

I dont get it. There was no love for Carlos when he left (who was a much better, more talented player), but there is love for a guy who is clearly at the end of his career.

Dont get me wrong, I've been a Hall defender in the past. Thought he was better than what the stats say. But clearly his play has been much more eratic the last couple years (i.e. this year: first 8 games horrible, last 8 games improved play).

Its time to move on, we need more stable, consistent coverage from our starting corner.

Like I posted the other day, I hope Hall signs with Dallas so RGIII can torch his ass on a regular basis.

[Skinzman]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Like I posted the other day, I hope Hall signs with Dallas so RGIII can torch his ass on a regular basis.

And teach Dez Bryant how to keep his cool with the refs.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Like I posted the other day, I hope Hall signs with Dallas so RGIII can torch his ass on a regular basis.

No offense dude, but you sound like a cry baby here. Get over it.

This is the type of complaining/b*tching I am relieved not to hear now that Hall is gone. Thank God.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Like I posted the other day, I hope Hall signs with Dallas so RGIII can torch his ass on a regular basis.

I'm not a huge Hall of fan either, but you have to give him credit. He was w/out question our best DB the last half of the season. He played great against Dez Bryant the last game of the season.

[Alvin Walton]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

But are they really better than Hall? Winfield is 40

Uh nope....
He turns 36 in June.

[SkinzWin]

I think people's thing is not putting him up on a pedestal like he is great, but that he is a serviceable player who ALREADY KNOWS out system, and there aren't any other FA CBs out there that we can afford. So maybe he gives us a hometown discount and comes back. I think that is all it is.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by SkinzWin

I think people's thing is not putting him up on a pedestal like he is great, but that he is a serviceable player who ALREADY KNOWS out system, and there aren't any other FA CBs out there that we can afford. So maybe he gives us a hometown discount and comes back. I think that is all it is.

Knowing the system isn't a sole reason to keep someone.

[SkinzWin]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

Knowing the system isn't a sole reason to keep someone.

Read more carefully. I am saying that the other FA players at his position are no better than he, or are not attainable due to our limited cap. Since he knows our system already, he gets the edge over other similar players. I was not insinuating that is the only reason. Just the one that could tip the scales in his favor if all things are equal.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by SkinzWin

Read more carefully. I am saying that the other FA players at his position are no better than he, or are not attainable due to our limited cap. Since he knows our system already, he gets the edge over other similar players. I was not insinuating that is the only reason. Just the one that could tip the scales in his favor if all things are equal.

I understand that, I am saying there are some that say keep Hall just because he knows the system.

[donofriose]

Originally Posted by SkinzWin

I think people's thing is not putting him up on a pedestal like he is great, but that he is a serviceable player who ALREADY KNOWS out system, and there aren't any other FA CBs out there that we can afford. So maybe he gives us a hometown discount and comes back. I think that is all it is.

So we should not upgrade positions with more talent because they do not know the system? Well RG3 shouldn't have been drafted then cause grossman already knew the system...

The only reason hall would agree to a discount is if no one else wants him. Which could happen.

[Skinzman]

Originally Posted by donofriose

So we should not upgrade positions with more talent because they do not know the system? Well RG3 shouldn't have been drafted then cause grossman already knew the system...

The only reason hall would agree to a discount is if no one else wants him. Which could happen.

You do realize that all he was doing was giving a "possible" explanation as to why some would want D Hall back. He never once said that RG3 sucks and Rex is the greatest QB ever.

[donofriose]

Originally Posted by Skinzman

You do realize that all he was doing was giving a "possible" explanation as to why some would want D Hall back. He never once said that RG3 sucks and Rex is the greatest QB ever.

He was stating that the skins should keep hall because he already knew the system. All I'm saying is that is not a legit reason to keep someone

Nevermind he just cleared it up above. My mistake

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by Mattyk

35, 40 same thing apparently

Using that logic Hall is 35

Always amazed at the love for Hall, I don't get it.

I don't love Hall I'm just saying he's better than winfield.