2012 QB Prospects (Part 2)

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by CultBrennan59

Man if we got those 3 guys in the first 3 rounds I'd be one happy fan

I'd have reservations about it.

I like the 1st round pick, but do we need a ILB? I think that position could hold off for a later round as a back up. and CB in the 3rd? I'd take a FS first. We have no FS at all. We are stacked at SS and CB (young and not matured yet) and I don't know that I would even do that FS pick so high. I'd either go(QB, WR, OL-RT/G), or I'd go (QB, OL, FS,) < the latter if we found a FA almost #1 WR.

[SouperMeister]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

2012 3 Round Mock Draft: Andrew Luck all but guarenteed to be a Colt - NFL Mocks - Covering the 2012 NFL draft, Mock Draft Database, Scouting Reports, and Fantasy Football

If we don't take an O-lineman with any of the first three rounds, we will still have significant depth issues up front. I'm OK with Barkley in the 1st round, but I definitely prefer Griffin.

[SkinzWin]

Originally Posted by SBXVII

I'd have reservations about it.

I like the 1st round pick, but do we need a ILB? I think that position could hold off for a later round as a back up. and CB in the 3rd? I'd take a FS first. We have no FS at all. We are stacked at SS and CB (young and not matured yet) and I don't know that I would even do that FS pick so high. I'd either go(QB, WR, OL-RT/G), or I'd go (QB, OL, FS,) < the latter if we found a FA almost #1 WR.

I am pretty confident you are joking about this fact. I hope so anyway...

DeAngelo Hall (Hot or Cold, can't be consistent, gets burned too much)
Josh Wilson (Hasn't played up to the hype)
Kevin Barnes (Has not played well)
Phillip Buchanon (Can't keep out of suspension)

[skinsfaninok]

If it's not Luck Barkley or RGIII don't bother IMO

[Jontrem]

#1 pick of Griffin or Barkley (if a trade for #1 pick is deemed to pricey) I am fine with. ILB in the second is too early. We will resign Fletcher. CB in 3rd round is also a no for me. Idealy I would like to see #1 Qb #2 RT #3RG for depth if nothing else. This draft/offseason needs to be about landing us a franchise QB and shoring up the Oline...anything else would be very disappointing.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Why stop there? Let's use all of our draft picks on OL just for depth purposes.

[30gut]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Tyler Wilson's coming out?

Anyhow, my sleeper remains Tannehill. I mean sleeper in the sense that not many are talking about him as an option for the Redskins.

I forgot Tyler was a Junior.

Is Tannehill really a sleeper?
He's got as good physical skillset as any of the top prospects, if not better, and he's plays in the college version of our offense.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by SkinzWin

I am pretty confident you are joking about this fact. I hope so anyway...

DeAngelo Hall (Hot or Cold, can't be consistent, gets burned too much)
Josh Wilson (Hasn't played up to the hype)
Kevin Barnes (Has not played well)
Phillip Buchanon (Can't keep out of suspension)

Let's start by identifying the problematic areas this year:
1-QB
2-OL
3-CB

I would draft a CB with the 2nd pick cause chances are you can get a starter than a 3rd rounder (Barnes as an example).

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by 30gut

I forgot Tyler was a Junior.

Is Tannehill really a sleeper?
He's got as good physical skillset as any of the top prospects, if not better, and he's plays in the college version of our offense.

Well like I said sleeper in the sense everyone is talking Barkley or RG3

[GusFrerotte]

Why isn't the QB from Okie St in the picture for us? The guy has a cannon and is 6'4". I think Weedlan could be a good NFL QB. Not saying we should necessarily put him ahead of Barkely or RG III on our wish list, but I haven't seen him in any QB prospect discussion yet, unless I bring him up.

[30gut]

Originally Posted by GusFrerotte

Why isn't the QB from Okie St in the picture for us? The guy has a cannon and is 6'4". I think Weedlan could be a good NFL QB. Not saying we should necessarily put him ahead of Barkely or RG III on our wish list, but I haven't seen him in any QB prospect discussion yet, unless I bring him up.

Here's mine:

Originally Posted by 30gut

Here's how I rate this QB draft class/Redskins QB draft board:
Luck
Barkley
Weeden
Tannehill
Landry Jones
Griff
Russell Wilson


Overall:
Griffin
Luck
Tannehill
Weeden
Jones
Barkley
Russell Wilson (would be much higher if he wasn't under 6')

[skinsfaninok]

Weedon is not a better QB than Jones not even close

[SmootSmack]

I know it's age discrimination but I don't want a rookie 28 year old

[skinsfaninok]

Yeah not only that he's 28 but he's really not that great, good arm but can't move and makes bad decisions

[CultBrennan59]

Originally Posted by The Goat

Idk about ILB in the 2nd round. If Fletcher is gone it's worth it otherwise we have more pressing needs at RT, NT, WR, CB, FS.

I agree that CB is a greater need, but if Vontaze Burfict (the next ray lewis IMO) or possibly Donta Hightower are there, I say we get one of them. CB-wise, the only one that I want with my 2nd rounder would probably be Janoris Jenkins. I'm not that high on Alfonzo Dennard, Hosley I loved until he got compared to DHall, now I don't want him. Chase Minnefield is someone whose good but not great or anything.