Thomas should be the third wideout

[johnerotten]

i'd take james thrash over thomas at 3rd string everytime.

[NYCskinfan82]

I'm dieing to see DT on the field more often, but he needs to earn it.

[Paintrain]

I think that Thomas can do AT LEAST what Thrash gives us in the passing game, which is usually a dropped streak pass or a fade run 3 yards out of bounds per game.

[TurlockSkinsFan]

Originally Posted by Paintrain

I think that Thomas can do AT LEAST what Thrash gives us in the passing game, which is usually a dropped streak pass or a fade run 3 yards out of bounds per game.

Thank you Paintrain maybe I didn't specify this clearly enough when I started this thread, but this pretty much hit the nail on the head. I like Thrash, he's a good guy, dependable player but Thomas has more upside. And as far as being raw, to debut what every one is saying in response to my initial statement Thomas is a big physical guy you can't learn to perfect that in practice. The offensive pass interference calls will give way to first downs. If I remember right the was some guy in Dallas that would push off all the time, he never got called for it. Guarantee you he didn't learn that in non-contact practice.

[KLHJ2]

The government should pay me money for doing jack shit because I am entitled. Screw working for it!

[sportscurmudgeon]

If the Skins play Thomas as the #3 WR now, they risk a locker-room problem. On good NFL teams, the coaches play the players who produce - - not the ones who were drafted high or the ones with great potential or the ones with high ratings in Madden 08 - - the ones who produce.

Unless I dozed off during a game this season, Thomas has produced precisely NOTHING yet. He's been on the field; he's drawn penalties; he's made ZERO plays of any consequence.

When he takes advantage of his time on the field and starts to do something positive, he can become the #3 WR - - and maybe someday the #1 WR. But to toss him into that slot now when he has not earned it and when the guy ahead of him has not been carried off the field on the cart would be a bad coaching move for this team. I think Jim Zorn knows that...

[GMScud]

Originally Posted by sportscurmudgeon

If the Skins play Thomas as the #3 WR now, they risk a locker-room problem. On good NFL teams, the coaches play the players who produce - - not the ones who were drafted high or the ones with great potential or the ones with high ratings in Madden 08 - - the ones who produce.

Unless I dozed off during a game this season, Thomas has produced precisely NOTHING yet. He's been on the field; he's drawn penalties; he's made ZERO plays of any consequence.

When he takes advantage of his time on the field and starts to do something positive, he can become the #3 WR - - and maybe someday the #1 WR. But to toss him into that slot now when he has not earned it and when the guy ahead of him has not been carried off the field on the cart would be a bad coaching move for this team. I think Jim Zorn knows that...

Well, he has produced just slightly more than nothing- he had a big 3rd down grab against the Eagles, but I suppose his three bonehead offensive pass interference penalties thus far negate that effort.

Apparently the fact that he isn't more involved is his own doing. He didn't show up for training camp in good enough shape, and he's struggled to pick up the offense. Maybe he's not too sharp, maybe it's a tough offense to learn, and maybe he isn't studying enough. Or it could just be an combination of all three factors. Either way, it's up to him. Step it up Devin.

[HipHipHooray]

DT will get there soon enough. Seems like many of his screw ups also nullified big or at least decent plays on his part. He will have to jsut earn his way. In regards to him returning the ball...nope. Did you watch him do it in the preseason? Every time he ran it was like he was concentrating on taking the hit as opposed to just running and trying to get past. He would always hesitate, square up, and take the hit. Not even trying to make a cut or move. I kept thinking the play must be to run straight into the first person you see and fall down. But - i think he will become a real good receiver and soon.....needs to work on his TD dance though. Even if his first TD hadn't been called back for penalty...the dance alone should have cancelled it out.

[CA_Redskins]

I agree that this is a "character" team and players need to earn their spot on the field.

But... we are talking about the #3 WR here. What, is Thrash that great that he isn't easily interchangeable with DT?

Give me a break. Put in DT and let him develop. Trust me, you will be thankful come week 16 and we are getting ready for the playoffs

[SFREDSKIN]

Could this be the week he has a breakout day? He's going back home to Michigan and I'm sure he will have family and friends in the stands. Will Zorn feature him more this week?

[johnerotten]

i'd rather have thrash on the field any day before thomas,especially now since all he does is committ penalities now.