Who's your pick's for next HC, DC and OC?

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Not numbers that I look at.

He's on pace for over100 catches , that's a top 20 IMO

[JoeRedskin]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

He's on pace for over100 catches , that's a top 20 IMO

Pffft. Who judges a WR by how many catches they make?

[Bucket]

Originally Posted by JoeRedskin

Pffft. Who judges a WR by how many catches they make?

Everyone but Gtripp.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by JoeRedskin

Pffft. Who judges a WR by how many catches they make?

Is there even one single front office that uses total catches as a measure of receiver quality?

[skinsfaninok]

I'm with Tripp on some issues but name me 30 WRs better than PG , besides the obvious top 7 or.so this season

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

I'm with Tripp on some issues but name me 30 WRs better than PG , besides the obvious top 7 or.so this season

Is Garcon better than Reggie Wayne? Is he better than Dez Bryant? Is he better than Jordy Nelson? How about Randall Cobb? Demaryius Thomas? Keenan Allen? Brandon Marshall? Antonio Brown? Michael Crabtree?

I kinda feel like anyone who honestly feels that Garcon is one of the best receivers in the NFL is going to dismiss the idea that someone who has been in the league three or fewer years can be better than him...but I think that's just flawed process. There's a lot of players that were drafted in the last three years at receiver who are more productive than Garcon.

[Bucket]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Is Garcon better than Reggie Wayne? Is he better than Dez Bryant? Is he better than Jordy Nelson? How about Randall Cobb? Demaryius Thomas? Keenan Allen? Brandon Marshall? Antonio Brown? Michael Crabtree?

I kinda feel like anyone who honestly feels that Garcon is one of the best receivers in the NFL is going to dismiss the idea that someone who has been in the league three or fewer years can be better than him...but I think that's just flawed process. There's a lot of players that were drafted in the last three years at receiver who are more productive than Garcon.

You named 9.. You got 21 more?

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Bucket

You named 9.. You got 21 more?

Of course there are 21 more. I wasn't going to bother with the pro bowlers, because this was a Pierre Garcon conversation.

If you want a list of receivers that have been more productive this season, you can start with these 44:

FOOTBALL OUTSIDERS: Innovative Statistics, Intelligent Analysis | WIDE RECEIVERS 2013

I don't recommend making career evaluations off 9 games though. Garcon however, has been the same guy his whole career, regardless of whether his QB was Manning, Painter, or Griffin. 2012 was probably his best year, and he only played half a season.

[Bucket]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Of course there are 21 more. I wasn't going to bother with the pro bowlers, because this was a Pierre Garcon conversation.

If you want a list of receivers that have been more productive this season, you can start with these 44:

FOOTBALL OUTSIDERS: Innovative Statistics, Intelligent Analysis | WIDE RECEIVERS 2013

I don't recommend making career evaluations off 9 games though. Garcon however, has been the same guy his whole career, regardless of whether his QB was Manning, Painter, or Griffin. 2012 was probably his best year, and he only played half a season.

Because players cant improve right? Some players regress and others improve. Garcon has improved and hes 100% a top 20 WR right now.

[Skinzman]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Of course there are 21 more. I wasn't going to bother with the pro bowlers, because this was a Pierre Garcon conversation.

If you want a list of receivers that have been more productive this season, you can start with these 44:

FOOTBALL OUTSIDERS: Innovative Statistics, Intelligent Analysis | WIDE RECEIVERS 2013

I don't recommend making career evaluations off 9 games though. Garcon however, has been the same guy his whole career, regardless of whether his QB was Manning, Painter, or Griffin. 2012 was probably his best year, and he only played half a season.

Jericho Cotchery is the 4th best WR in the league according to you? Jordy Nelson is the number 1 WR overall in the entire NFL this year? Larry Fitzgerald is the 58th best WR? That is what that stat is telling me. That is just all kinds of useless to judge a WR on. I really doubt there are many calling Cotchery a top 5 WR and Nelson the best this year.

[CrustyRedskin]

Mike Singletary

[skinsfaninok]

No way crab or cobb are better than PG ,crab has had 1 good season 1. Cobb has had half a.season. I think Pierre is around 20

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

No way crab or cobb are better than PG ,crab has had 1 good season 1. Cobb has had half a.season. I think Pierre is around 20

Depending on how you count 2012, one could argue that Garcon hasn't had a good season yet, and that anyone who has had only one good season should be ahead of him.

I think the whole industry would take Cobb over him. Most people are incredibly bullish on Cobb. I think they are more split on Crabtree, but I'd still take Crabtree over Garcon. I just think he's a more refined player. But if you want to take Garcon because he's available (healthy) more often, that's fine too.

[skinsfaninok]

I'm no Bill Parcells but here's my top 20 as of right now this season.
No particular order

Mega
AJ Green
D Thomas
Dez Bryant
Fitz
Julio Jones
Nelson
Vincent Jackson
Welker
Marshall
Steve Johnson
Josh Gordon
Desean Jackson
Cruz
T Smith
Garcon
Andre Johnson
Justin Blackmon (not high)
K.Allen
Colston

May switch Cobb and Allen if Cobb was healthy

[GTripp0012]

They don't technically play the same position, but does anyone here think Garcon is a better offensive player than Jordan Reed? Because I think Reed is so, so much better that I would assume all Redskins fans would vouch for me on that one, getting to watch the both of them on the same field.