WFT Quarterback Thread - Post SEASON 2021

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by Scalper

None. I would draft and develop a QB.

That wasn't the question.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by Scalper

None. I would draft and develop a QB.

Just curious, how long do you give the drafted qb to develop. And if he fails?

You do realize that even befoee the DAN took over the team this organization has never developed a qb effectively. I dont know why but holding out hope they can finally do that borders on insanity.

Heath Schuler is asking for his football career back

Sent from my SM-G973U using Tapatalk

[Chief X_Phackter]

A little over 3 years ago the Redskins traded for Alex Smith. They likely would have won the NFC East the last 3 years in a row if he didn't suffer that unfortunate leg injury. What if they did the same thing this year, with a guy like Derek Carr, who at this point in his career is better than Alex Smith? I'd be ok with that. With Daniel Jones, Carson Wentz, Jalen Hurts, or even Dak Prescott, I believe the WFT would have the best quarterback in the division.

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by Chief X_Phackter

A little over 3 years ago the Redskins traded for Alex Smith. They likely would have won the NFC East the last 3 years in a row if he didn't suffer that unfortunate leg injury. What if they did the same thing this year, with a guy like Derek Carr, who at this point in his career is better than Alex Smith? I'd be ok with that. With Daniel Jones, Carson Wentz, Jalen Hurts, or even Dak Prescott, I believe the WFT would have the best quarterback in the division.

I don't love Carr but he would easily be our best QB when accounting for both ability and availability. I'd offer a 3rd for him assuming the counter would be a 2nd, which I would also do.

I'd take Carr because he is solid, and Mariota because he is good for our offense.

I'd offer a 4th for Mariota assuming the counter would be a 3rd, which I would also do.

[mooby]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

Just curious, how long do you give the drafted qb to develop. And if he fails?

You do realize that even befoee the DAN took over the team this organization has never developed a qb effectively. I dont know why but holding out hope they can finally do that borders on insanity.

Heath Schuler is asking for his football career back

Sent from my SM-G973U using Tapatalk

We drafted Kirk Cousins effectively.

Also a drafted qb would get about 3 years, maybe less if he's too immature to put in the work.

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by mooby

We drafted Kirk Cousins effectively.

Also a drafted qb would get about 3 years, maybe less if he's too immature to put in the work.

How would Kirk have done without RGIII in front of him, would not sitting have hurt or helped him?

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by mooby

We drafted Kirk Cousins effectively.



Also a drafted qb would get about 3 years, maybe less if he's too immature to put in the work.

We drafted KC as an afterthought and he is still a divisive topic. But the vikings after 3 years with KC finished with the same record as us with 4 qb's.

But let's play out the draft a qb scenario:
So we draft a qb or two this year. We give him 3 years. Meanwhile our awesome dline gets older and we let 2 go due to contract. And at the end of 3 years we realize we still suck at selecting qbs and have zero to show for our dline.

That is as likely a scenario as our FO hitting on a qb not picked in the top10. And if we are trading to get into the top 10, I am just as content trading for a qb with known NFL ability that our coaching staff thinks they can succeed with.

Sent from my SM-G973U using Tapatalk

[Giantone]

Originally Posted by rocnrik

Darnold, Carr,Wentz,Minshew, Winston ... which one of these would you pick ?

Darnold, still on his rookie contract and was in a crap situation with the Jets. You could all so afford to draft one and groom to your liking.

[punch it in]

Originally Posted by rocnrik

Darnold, Carr,Wentz,Minshew, Winston ... which one of these would you pick ?

The one i can try for a year and get rid of if he doesn’t pan out that doesn’t really cost us much. Wentz still intrigues me even though he had such an awful year.

[Chico23231]

I just couldn’t imagine trading for Derek Carr...he had a decent year, but shit isn’t it a huge red flag that the raiders want to move on? Like is anyone seeing that here? Detroit is in rebuild, I get that...raiders trying to win...

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by Chico23231

I just couldn’t imagine trading for Derek Carr...he had a decent year, but shit isn’t it a huge red flag that the raiders want to move on? Like is anyone seeing that here? Detroit is in rebuild, I get that...raiders trying to win...

Yeah I just don't see Carr leading us to playoff wins.. He's always been an average QB. He's in that Cousins category. I wouldn't mind having him but not for a 1st

[GridIron26]

Yeah I'm in the same boat, I wouldn't oppose to trading for Carr as long as we are not giving up our 1st round pick.

[PorkSkins]

Originally Posted by GridIron26

Yeah I'm in the same boat, I wouldn't oppose to trading for Carr as long as we are not giving up our 1st round pick.

Supposedly, the Raiders want two first round picks for Carr. Hell no!

EDIT: I just noticed a couple posters above mentioned the Raiders wanting two first rounders for Carr.

https://www.nbcsports.com/washington...-really-stupid

[MTK]

If the best we can do is Carr, that's not a bad thing. He's put up some very productive seasons. He can give you B level QB play and with this defense that could take us pretty far.

[Chico23231]

Originally Posted by MTK

If the best we can do is Carr, that's not a bad thing. He's put up some very productive seasons. He can give you B level QB play and with this defense that could take us pretty far.

The window is opening, but we shouldn’t be irrational in getting a QB. Yes poor front office QB decisions lead us here, making another poor one does not help.

So here would be my perimeters in a trade...

1. Derek Carr does not get an extension. He is under contract at 20 mill for both 2021 and 2022...let him play it out and as we get to see if he is a fit. Do not Alex Smith where we are still reeling from an already poor trade.

2. Under no circumstances do you give A first round pick for Carr. He isn’t worth it.