Redskins No. 1 pick in 2010 NFL Draft

[skinsfaninok]

Sam Bradford

[Big C]

snead is overrated. people want to believe there is another elite qb to rival tebow in the sec but i dont think there is. snead is good, not near elite though.

[SmootSmack]

SCSkins, I think you make some strong points. And that's all I'm going to say about that

[over the mountain]

yeah real good post SC. you did a really good job of summarizing (atleast imo) how I and im sure others feel. it doesnt have to be so polar, so black and white, so hater or believer on JC. there is a gray area, a middle ground that feels hes decent/good but not a franchise qb that will win you games. JC is our best option this year to win games, i support and cheer him on. i really want the guy to do well given all the criticism hes taken here but its on him.

for the record, i would much much rather have JC over leftwich. i just threw him out there to hint that favorable stats do not automatically equal a great qb.

go skins!!

[CRedskinsRule]

I think the point of anticipation is a good one. Question, can that be taught? I think about the failure to step up in game 1, and in game 2 he did a much better job, like Zorn said ok this is how you do it and stressed it enough that there was visible improvement. Can he do the same about "anticipation"?

[wilsowilso]

JC does lack nuance in some aspects of the game. I wonder if they have tried to teach him how to manipulate safeties? I'm sure they have tried, but JC really is lacking in that aspect. He doesn't even bother looking off safeties and rarely uses a pump fake.

It's one of Big Ben's biggest assets. That crazy pump fake he uses screws up opposing safeties all day.

[Sean"Big Hurt"Taylor]

Let's just be honest Campbell can only be a good quarterback and not an elite quarterback we want him to be. In the offseason we just need to cut our losses. Campbell is a Gibbs quarterback who is just a game manager. Zorn needs west coast quarterback. When you change your offensive philosophy then you need the roster to make it work. Once we get that particular quarterback and offensive lineman will be alright. It just seems the FO tried to build the outside first instead of building the inside (O-line)and that's why we are behind in the offense.

[ChickenMonkey]

Originally Posted by Sean"Big Hurt"Taylor

If you watch ESPN now you will see our future starter at quarterback playing the South Carolina Gamecocks and his name is Jevan Snead.

If thats true, id rather keep Campbell, Sneed looked shaky against South Carolina.....

[Son Of Man]

I'd rather have Jake Locker than Jevan Snead.

But I'll go on record now and say COLT MCCOY in 2010! We need a winner and he's it! Period!

[redskin4n]

I hope we get the 32nd pick!!!

[GTripp0012]

I think you can also have a really, really good debate on whether Campbell can blossom into a GREAT quarterback, or if the end game for him is simply a little bit better than he already is. Maybe that's the one we are already having. I'd conditionally agree that if Campbell doesn't have great anticipatory ability, he probably can't be more than a one or two time pro bowler at best.

Aaron Brooks also never had any sort of anticipatory ability, but that's just the thing: once his personnel went through a minor overhaul and once the league got some film on him, he stopped producing. I think we can all agree that Campbell is not another Aaron Brooks, but I still have to question the assertion that either Garrard or Leftwich can't get it done in this league.

Leftwich has a very measurable deficiency: he's never going to play 16 games in a season. Garrard's in a pretty similar situation to Campbell in that, you can look at the people on the offense around him and wonder exactly how that 2007 season happened.

I think this season will tell us a lot about Campbell, and I'll just suggest that what you want to know about him probably could be measured statistically, and fairly easily I would suggest, although sample size will be an issue.

[dmvskinzfan08]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

I think you can also have a really, really good debate on whether Campbell can blossom into a GREAT quarterback, or if the end game for him is simply a little bit better than he already is. Maybe that's the one we are already having. I'd conditionally agree that if Campbell doesn't have great anticipatory ability, he probably can't be more than a one or two time pro bowler at best.

Aaron Brooks also never had any sort of anticipatory ability, but that's just the thing: once his personnel went through a minor overhaul and once the league got some film on him, he stopped producing. I think we can all agree that Campbell is not another Aaron Brooks, but I still have to question the assertion that either Garrard or Leftwich can't get it done in this league.

Leftwich has a very measurable deficiency: he's never going to play 16 games in a season. Garrard's in a pretty similar situation to Campbell in that, you can look at the people on the offense around him and wonder exactly how that 2007 season happened.

I think this season will tell us a lot about Campbell, and I'll just suggest that what you want to know about him probably could be measured statistically, and fairly easily I would suggest, although sample size will be an issue.

Is it me or am I seeing a trend with these QB comparisons?? Maybe more telling than not. I don't mean that in a good way. Besides that. I think the thing that needs to be said is there is a grey area. Campbell is productive but not a great QB. I do think the difference is manipulating the defenses. The little nuances like looking off the safety. Pump faking. Being able to call audibles or having permission to call audibles. Knowing when to run and when to hang in there. I really think he will blossom. I think its the attention to detail is lacking. But the play calling and inconsistencies in the coaching staff doesn't help. I have been a staunch JC supporter. But if he doesn't prove himself at the end of the season he will be gone. for the simple reason his contract is up. If not we would sign someone and keep him as a backup.

[Eknox]

I like Ryan Mallett Arkansas , the guy has a serious arm and deadly accurate and around 6-foot-7, unfortunately just a sophomore though..

[#56fanatic]

I know we will get one of the big 3 QB's coming out. Bradford probably more NFL ready by running an NFL style offense. Danny will not let that get away (ala Sanchez). he will give up what ever is needed to get him. Unless for some ungodly reason he loves Timmy T and gets him at our pick on 2nd round.

I sure hope that isn't the case...i just dont think Timmy T is going to translate into an NFL QB.

[Redskin Warrior]

Originally Posted by #56fanatic

I know we will get one of the big 3 QB's coming out. Bradford probably more NFL ready by running an NFL style offense. Danny will not let that get away (ala Sanchez). he will give up what ever is needed to get him. Unless for some ungodly reason he loves Timmy T and gets him at our pick on 2nd round.

I sure hope that isn't the case...i just dont think Timmy T is going to translate into an NFL QB.

Like I said before all that running Tebow is doing will not happen in the NFL. Ray Lewis, Pat Willis & others that play linebacker will welcome him to the NFL quickly. If Randle El could not make it as a QB in the NFL neither will Tebow. If you take away Percy Harvin, Louis Murphy, Will Demps & Brandon James during his college career he is not that effective he averages between 95-110 passing yards per game.