Final Cuts Looming - any surprises on the horizon

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by IrMitchell

Haha to the people suggesting Wilson would be cut. David Amerson has been borderline pathetic during the pre-season.

Wilson has been one of the best bargain FA signings in recent years. Cutting him and assuming Biggers/Amerson can suddenly cover would be a huge mistake. Especially since the other guy (DHall) is infamous for his cover skills, or lack there of.

Chase Minnifield is playing better than Amerson right now, it will take a little while for Amerson to learn.

[IrMitchell]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

Chase Minnifield is playing better than Amerson right now, it will take a little while for Amerson to learn.

I honestly don't know if Amerson could have been any worse. He's been laughably bad out there.

He and LeRibeus are starting a short list of Shanahan draft busts.

[MTK]

Originally Posted by IrMitchell

I honestly don't know if Amerson could have been any worse. He's been laughably bad out there.

He and LeRibeus are starting a short list of Shanahan draft busts.

Amerson hasn't even played a regular season game yet, might want to pump the brakes on labeling him a bust just yet. I don't think he's been that bad. He's had his ups and downs. Like a rookie usually does.

[CultBrennan59]

Originally Posted by IrMitchell

Haha to the people suggesting Wilson would be cut. David Amerson has been borderline pathetic during the pre-season.

Wilson has been one of the best bargain FA signings in recent years. Cutting him and assuming Biggers/Amerson can suddenly cover would be a huge mistake. Especially since the other guy (DHall) is infamous for his cover skills, or lack there of.

Pat White will be gone, he's bad.
Grossman will be gone, he wastes a roster spot.
Stallworth will be gone, the heartwarming return is over.
LeRibeus will be gone, Matthews replaced him as backup C and frankly he sucks.
Niles Paul hopefully will be gone, We've seen more out of Reed in 2 weeks than Paul in 2 years.
Gomes hopefully will be gone, I'm shocked he's still here. Nothing but terrible coverage from that guy since day 1.

Jamison goes to the PS.

Thompson makes the team as 4th RB.

I disagree. I think Amerson has been very hot and cold throughout the preseason. The Tennessee game he should his tackling and his size and speed very well. He's made a couple of errors, but is still a young rookie with big upside.

Had Cousins of been healthy, I would agree with you that he would be gone, but he's hurt and RG3 is coming off a major injury so it wouldn't be wise for Shanahan to cut him so a team like the Jets or Giants (as a backup) sign him for help or knowledge of the playbook.

Niles Paul won't be gone. He can return kicks, play special teams and has improved big time from last year. Also Jordan Reed has just started coming along because he's just started practicing. He just started practicing because he's been hurt. Its very risky to cut a guy who does many things for a high potential rookie who hasn't been 100% healthy. If Jordan Reeds gets injured, then its Paulsen and Fred Davis who is about 9 months removed from a torn Achilles. Who would we find out there who knows the playbook as good as Paul? You're probably thinking Paul. But with so many teams losing TE's this year, I can easily see Paul getting picked up by someone else if we cut him.

Also you said Thompson makes it as the 4th RB. Is that including our FB? Who's your 4 RBs then if it isn't including Daryl Young?

[IrMitchell]

Wait, you guys think Pat White has value? He's a 27 year old with zero accuracy and his only NFL highlight was getting knocked out.

[JoeRedskin]

Amerson has gotten good grades from folks who get paid to know these things. Not outstanding, but good. He's a rookie and is going to make mistakes but, by all accounts has belongs and may challenge for a starting spot somewhere in the not too distant future. From what I have seen, he's been decent and has flashed some really good moments.

[Lotus]

Amerson has many more rookie mistakes to make. But such is required for his long-term development. Same goes for Rambo. They're like puppies - you have to put up with some chewed shoes if you want them to turn into awesome dogs.

[RedskinRat]

Originally Posted by Lotus

They're like puppies

This is EXACTLY why I'm a cat person. They never do anything wrong, by my standards.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2

[skinsfaninok]

U guys take too much stock into PS. Amerson will be fine, is he Patrick Peterson? No but not many players are.

[Bushead]

Where are you getting the idea that Amerson didn't play well? He had the one long pass where in did pass interference and a penalty, but i saw a lot of athletic ability and wonderful closing ability on Wide Receivers. He seems to really want to come up and lay a hit.

I thought Wilson was on the bubble with Crawford, but he stays now. This Pat White stuff needs to stop. Hankerson has too much upside to cut him and keep Stallworth instead.

[IrMitchell]

Originally Posted by Bushead

Where are you getting the idea that Amerson didn't play well? He had the one long pass where in did pass interference and a penalty, but i saw a lot of athletic ability and wonderful closing ability on Wide Receivers. He seems to really want to come up and lay a hit.

I thought Wilson was on the bubble with Crawford, but he stays now. This Pat White stuff needs to stop. Hankerson has too much upside to cut him and keep Stallworth instead.

Well where would you get that idea?

Josh Wilson is far and away our best corner. He's the only stability we have back there.

Also, Amerson has been bad. No reason to sugar coat it, he looks like a deer in headlights in coverage.

[Skinzman]

Originally Posted by IrMitchell

Well where would you get that idea?

Josh Wilson is far and away our best corner. He's the only stability we have back there.

Also, Amerson has been bad. No reason to sugar coat it, he looks like a deer in headlights in coverage.

Did you only watch one play all preseason? The pass interference against the Bills. As for Wilson, he cant cover one on one. He is good when he has safety help over the top because he understands positioning (which is why he was pretty bad all last year, because we had no one who could give help over the top) but other than that, he is below average. Amerson can already cover one on one as good as Wilson.

[DynamiteRave]

Originally Posted by IrMitchell

Well where would you get that idea?

Josh Wilson is far and away our best corner. He's the only stability we have back there.

Also, Amerson has been bad. No reason to sugar coat it, he looks like a deer in headlights in coverage.

If Josh Wilson is our best corner, I fear for the secondary this season.

I don't know if I'd label Amerson as BAD. Inconsistent, yes, but eh, he's a rookie.

[SirLK26]

Originally Posted by Bushead

Where are you getting the idea that Amerson didn't play well? He had the one long pass where in did pass interference and a penalty, but i saw a lot of athletic ability and wonderful closing ability on Wide Receivers. He seems to really want to come up and lay a hit.

I thought Wilson was on the bubble with Crawford, but he stays now. This Pat White stuff needs to stop. Hankerson has too much upside to cut him and keep Stallworth instead.

I agree with every point you make. Good post.

[JoeRedskin]

Who's better than Wilson? Hall? At times. At times, he is much worse than Wilson. Biggers? Okay, not seeing it, but, if not Wilson or Hall, he is next man up. Minnifield? Can we see him a regular season game first.

I mean, Wilson is an average corner. Unfortunately, an average corner is probably our best bet.