Who will make the cut?

DBUCHANON101 · 08-23-2009, 03:13 PM

i think if it did come to that he would be gone to another team.

SmootSmack · 08-23-2009, 03:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DBUCHANON101

i think if it did come to that he would be gone to another team.

Agreed. Much as I like what Chase has done, I think Colt is the more likely of the two to be picked up by another team

That Guy · 08-23-2009, 03:32 PM

I believe you have to be active for 9 games in a year to lose PS squad eligibility.

poorly formatted, but thorough:
Seahawks Insider - Practice Squad Rules

2BIG2BSKINNY · 08-23-2009, 04:08 PM

What if Chase has another big game!!! Colt and Chase need to be developed. It is a tough choice. If Chase does it again, I say Colt is PS material. This is Colt's 2nd preseason and he should be getting better not regressing.
Pre-season does not mean much but the pre-season is the time to help depth for the future!
I would love to see Mason and Marko make the team!

SBXVII · 08-23-2009, 04:16 PM

I'll eat some crow, all the RB's looked good. However I still like Mason and felt he had a good showing again last night even if it was against 2nd stringers. He makes good decisions and actually ran over some people last night.

Colt or Chase, Chase or Colt. I like both. Chase made two good drives down the field. Quick reads quick release. Decisive. Colt had a good drive going eating up the clock. The only thing ya have to keep in mind is Colt is very (very) similar to Bret Favre. He throws sideways, he takes chances with the ball, and will more then likely have more interceptions. Colt has a little more going for him cause he understands the play book better most likely but Chase looked better. My choice, I'd get rid of Collins and majorly coach up the two young guys.

The interception on Collins was Thomas's fault. He needs to always be looking for the ball.

Bye bye Hackett, Hagens and Shelton. Mitchell looks to be the real deal and adds the hight we need. He'll be gone if put on the PS. Eloi, Eloi, Eloi, I like him but he's killing me right now. He's definitly not a KR or it was our blocking that sucked or both. Because of this I would make Mitchell the #5 and put Eloi on the PS to either get better or until someone better comes along.

Tryon= gone. Westbrook actually impressed me last night otherwise I would say...gone. Barnes I hope shows better in the next two games otherwise he's either PS or gone.

My list:
QB: JC, Brennan, Daniels.
RB: Portis, Mason, Dorsey. Personal feeling included. between Mason or Dorsey....Dorsey. we need a speed back plus he looked awsome.
WR: Moss, Kelly, ARE, Thomas, Mitchell, Eloi-PS.
TE: Cooley, Davis, Agnone.
CB: Hall, Rogers, Smoot, Horton, ???? As good as Westbrook looked maybe keep and put Barnes on PS.

Just a few of my picks so far. Batiste looked horrible. Let him go and keep it Heyer, Bridges and Williams.

backrow · 08-23-2009, 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SBXVII

I'll eat some crow, all the RB's looked good. However I still like Mason and felt he had a good showing again last night even if it was against 2nd stringers. He makes good decisions and actually ran over some people last night.

Colt or Chase, Chase or Colt. I like both. Chase made two good drives down the field. Quick reads quick release. Decisive. Colt had a good drive going eating up the clock. The only thing ya have to keep in mind is Colt is very (very) similar to Bret Favre. He throws sideways, he takes chances with the ball, and will more then likely have more interceptions. Colt has a little more going for him cause he understands the play book better most likely but Chase looked better. My choice, I'd get rid of Collins and majorly coach up the two young guys.

The interception on Collins was Thomas's fault. He needs to always be looking for the ball.

Bye bye Hackett, Hagens and Shelton. Mitchell looks to be the real deal and adds the hight we need. He'll be gone if put on the PS. Eloi, Eloi, Eloi, I like him but he's killing me right now. He's definitly not a KR or it was our blocking that sucked or both. Because of this I would make Mitchell the #5 and put Eloi on the PS to either get better or until someone better comes along.

Tryon= gone. Westbrook actually impressed me last night otherwise I would say...gone. Barnes I hope shows better in the next two games otherwise he's either PS or gone.

My list:
QB: JC, Brennan, Daniels.
RB: Portis, Mason, Dorsey. Personal feeling included. between Mason or Dorsey....Dorsey. we need a speed back plus he looked awsome.
WR: Moss, Kelly, ARE, Thomas, Mitchell, Eloi-PS.
TE: Cooley, Davis, Agnone.
CB: Hall, Rogers, Smoot, Horton, ???? As good as Westbrook looked maybe keep and put Barnes on PS.

Just a few of my picks so far. Batiste looked horrible. Let him go and keep it Heyer, Bridges and Williams.

Quickly, out of the gate: Welcome new AF guy!

SB, I agree with you on Todd Collins, but what about Betts and Cartwright?

Marko does appear to be a stud, but I'd pass on Eloi!

tryfuhl · 08-23-2009, 10:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SBXVII

I'll eat some crow, all the RB's looked good. However I still like Mason and felt he had a good showing again last night even if it was against 2nd stringers. He makes good decisions and actually ran over some people last night.

Colt or Chase, Chase or Colt. I like both. Chase made two good drives down the field. Quick reads quick release. Decisive. Colt had a good drive going eating up the clock. The only thing ya have to keep in mind is Colt is very (very) similar to Bret Favre. He throws sideways, he takes chances with the ball, and will more then likely have more interceptions. Colt has a little more going for him cause he understands the play book better most likely but Chase looked better. My choice, I'd get rid of Collins and majorly coach up the two young guys.

The interception on Collins was Thomas's fault. He needs to always be looking for the ball.

Bye bye Hackett, Hagens and Shelton. Mitchell looks to be the real deal and adds the hight we need. He'll be gone if put on the PS. Eloi, Eloi, Eloi, I like him but he's killing me right now. He's definitly not a KR or it was our blocking that sucked or both. Because of this I would make Mitchell the #5 and put Eloi on the PS to either get better or until someone better comes along.

Tryon= gone. Westbrook actually impressed me last night otherwise I would say...gone. Barnes I hope shows better in the next two games otherwise he's either PS or gone.

My list:
QB: JC, Brennan, Daniels.
RB: Portis, Mason, Dorsey. Personal feeling included. between Mason or Dorsey....Dorsey. we need a speed back plus he looked awsome.
WR: Moss, Kelly, ARE, Thomas, Mitchell, Eloi-PS.
TE: Cooley, Davis, Agnone.
CB: Hall, Rogers, Smoot, Horton, ???? As good as Westbrook looked maybe keep and put Barnes on PS.

Just a few of my picks so far. Batiste looked horrible. Let him go and keep it Heyer, Bridges and Williams.

no way are we ridding ourselves of betts AND cartwright

09AFTacoma · 08-23-2009, 04:25 PM

Campbell Goes, Collins falls to the 3 Spot, Brennan and Daniels battle it out for that starting Jobs the last 2 Pre-Season Game!!.. We should Trade Campbell and a Draft pick to Dallas for Witten, and Run the Best Dual TE team ever

skinsfaninok · 08-23-2009, 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 09AFTacoma

Campbell Goes, Collins falls to the 3 Spot, Brennan and Daniels battle it out for that starting Jobs the last 2 Pre-Season Game!!.. We should Trade Campbell and a Draft pick to Dallas for Witten, and Run the Best Dual TE team ever

LOL Slow down chief, JC is our guy atleast until wk 9 or 10, but I personally think he will have a good yr and leads us to a WC game..

09AFTacoma · 08-23-2009, 04:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

LOL Slow down chief, JC is our guy atleast until wk 9 or 10, but I personally think he will have a good yr and leads us to a WC game..

JC is not my guy I almost threw my remote through the TV when we drafted him.. We would be better off bring back Mark Rypien..

It's time to put the ball in new hands.

wilsowilso · 08-23-2009, 04:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 09AFTacoma

JC is not my guy I almost threw my remote through the TV when we drafted him.. We would be better off bring back Mark Rypien..

It's time to put the ball in new hands.

Now I'm convinced.

SBXVII · 08-23-2009, 04:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 09AFTacoma

JC is not my guy I almost threw my remote through the TV when we drafted him.. We would be better off bring back Mark Rypien..

It's time to put the ball in new hands.

I don't think he was any of ours either. If I remember correctly the team went out to see Carlos Rogers (I think) and someone pointed out Campbell to the team as well. I think it kinda supprised all of us that the team went and picked him. Now we have him. Atleast for this last yr. He either shines and gets paid for it, or he flops and gets let go. In order for the Skins to make the play offs or even think SB then ya kinda have to root that Campbell does well cause the team is not going to simply cut him now.

Now you could always hope for an injury but then your dealing with Collins.

SmootSmack · 08-23-2009, 04:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 09AFTacoma

Campbell Goes, Collins falls to the 3 Spot, Brennan and Daniels battle it out for that starting Jobs the last 2 Pre-Season Game!!.. We should Trade Campbell and a Draft pick to Dallas for Witten, and Run the Best Dual TE team ever

Umm....welcome to the board

09AFTacoma · 08-23-2009, 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Umm....welcome to the board

Hi, *Waves* I've read the board for a while, Made an account when I was deployed back in 07, but lost the account info some time ago, and kinda forgot about this place started reading through the forums again last week, and tried to recover my old account info but cant remember what my log in or what email account i used... Sorry if I sound like someone new that is just shootin off his mouth.. Im just a big fan of Dumpin Campbell and moving on..

Been a Redskins fan all my life, which was hard, living near Dallas, Texas from 94-04.

SmootSmack · 08-23-2009, 05:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 09AFTacoma

Hi, *Waves* I've read the board for a while, Made an account when I was deployed back in 07, but lost the account info some time ago, and kinda forgot about this place started reading through the forums again last week, and tried to recover my old account info but cant remember what my log in or what email account i used... Sorry if I sound like someone new that is just shootin off his mouth.. Im just a big fan of Dumpin Campbell and moving on..

Been a Redskins fan all my life, which was hard, living near Dallas, Texas from 94-04.

I was more interested actually in your comment about trading a draft pick for Witten? I'm more than content with Cooley and Davis, aren't you? Plus it'd cost a fortune to trade for Witten.

08-23-2009, 03:13 PM	#1
DBUCHANON101 The Starter Join Date: May 2009 Location: Louisiana Posts: 1,373	Re: Who will make the cut? i think if it did come to that he would be gone to another team. __________________ But there's booze in the blender. And soon it will render. That frozen concoction that helps me hang on.

08-23-2009, 03:32 PM	#3
That Guy Living Legend Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: VA Age: 43 Posts: 17,620	Re: Who will make the cut? I believe you have to be active for 9 games in a year to lose PS squad eligibility. poorly formatted, but thorough: Seahawks Insider - Practice Squad Rules

08-23-2009, 04:08 PM	#4
2BIG2BSKINNY Special Teams Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Franklin, TN Posts: 214	Re: Who will make the cut? What if Chase has another big game!!! Colt and Chase need to be developed. It is a tough choice. If Chase does it again, I say Colt is PS material. This is Colt's 2nd preseason and he should be getting better not regressing. Pre-season does not mean much but the pre-season is the time to help depth for the future! I would love to see Mason and Marko make the team!

08-23-2009, 04:25 PM	#8
09AFTacoma Camp Scrub Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Pope AFB, NC Age: 41 Posts: 43	Re: Who will make the cut? Campbell Goes, Collins falls to the 3 Spot, Brennan and Daniels battle it out for that starting Jobs the last 2 Pre-Season Game!!.. We should Trade Campbell and a Draft pick to Dallas for Witten, and Run the Best Dual TE team ever

08-23-2009, 04:16 PM	#5
SBXVII Franchise Player Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Virginia Posts: 7,766	Re: Who will make the cut? I'll eat some crow, all the RB's looked good. However I still like Mason and felt he had a good showing again last night even if it was against 2nd stringers. He makes good decisions and actually ran over some people last night. Colt or Chase, Chase or Colt. I like both. Chase made two good drives down the field. Quick reads quick release. Decisive. Colt had a good drive going eating up the clock. The only thing ya have to keep in mind is Colt is very (very) similar to Bret Favre. He throws sideways, he takes chances with the ball, and will more then likely have more interceptions. Colt has a little more going for him cause he understands the play book better most likely but Chase looked better. My choice, I'd get rid of Collins and majorly coach up the two young guys. The interception on Collins was Thomas's fault. He needs to always be looking for the ball. Bye bye Hackett, Hagens and Shelton. Mitchell looks to be the real deal and adds the hight we need. He'll be gone if put on the PS. Eloi, Eloi, Eloi, I like him but he's killing me right now. He's definitly not a KR or it was our blocking that sucked or both. Because of this I would make Mitchell the #5 and put Eloi on the PS to either get better or until someone better comes along. Tryon= gone. Westbrook actually impressed me last night otherwise I would say...gone. Barnes I hope shows better in the next two games otherwise he's either PS or gone. My list: QB: JC, Brennan, Daniels. RB: Portis, Mason, Dorsey. Personal feeling included. between Mason or Dorsey....Dorsey. we need a speed back plus he looked awsome. WR: Moss, Kelly, ARE, Thomas, Mitchell, Eloi-PS. TE: Cooley, Davis, Agnone. CB: Hall, Rogers, Smoot, Horton, ???? As good as Westbrook looked maybe keep and put Barnes on PS. Just a few of my picks so far. Batiste looked horrible. Let him go and keep it Heyer, Bridges and Williams.

Who will make the cut?

Locker Room Main Forum