The annual QB carousel

BaltimoreSkins · 09-26-2025, 09:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdskinsfan2001

Jamf is my official new QB scout. Hopefully it's moot for another 10 years, but he's my go to guy. I like his easy to understand ranking system:

1. QB
2. JiffyLube

It check out

JD5 1
Mariota 1
Josh Johnson 1 but worked at Jiffy Lube 2014-2017, 2019-2020 and 2023
Sam Hartman 2 but his milkshake brings all the girls to the yard so he has to stay on practice squad so he can be on sidelines

88Commanders00 · 10-01-2025, 12:36 PM

Browns benched Flacco and go with Gabriel yet all the talk is about Sheddur.

Browns are screwed until they can get out of the Watson contract.

Browns likely to finish with double digit loses, regardless of how many games Gabriel and/or Sanders starts. Neither qb will be the long term future.

Haslam is likely to clean house after the season. Stefanski is in his 6th year. Browns have 2 #1 picks in 2026. Their own pick likely to be Top 10. The new guys will wants their own qb.

88Commanders00 · 10-06-2025, 01:50 AM

If the Bengals want to salvage their season; they need a different qb.

Kirk Cousins is probably too expensive for a one year rental but maybe the Bengals trade for the Giants backups- Wilson or Winston?

GridIron26 · 10-06-2025, 09:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 88Commanders00

Browns benched Flacco and go with Gabriel yet all the talk is about Sheddur.

Browns are screwed until they can get out of the Watson contract.

Browns likely to finish with double digit loses, regardless of how many games Gabriel and/or Sanders starts. Neither qb will be the long term future.

Haslam is likely to clean house after the season. Stefanski is in his 6th year. Browns have 2 #1 picks in 2026. Their own pick likely to be Top 10. The new guys will wants their own qb.

Gabriel did decent job, considering the game was in London. But yeah I agree with you, barring surprise wins, this is likely Stefanski's last year.

calia · 10-06-2025, 10:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 88Commanders00

If the Bengals want to salvage their season; they need a different qb.

Kirk Cousins is probably too expensive for a one year rental but maybe the Bengals trade for the Giants backups- Wilson or Winston?

I think Tyler Huntley remains unsigned. Just surprised that no one has picked him up. He’s had more than a few good games under his belt.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Chico23231 · 10-06-2025, 12:08 PM

Giants just turned the ball over again

88Commanders00 · 10-07-2025, 01:47 PM

Really? Bengals traded for Joe Flacco.

sdskinsfan2001 · 10-07-2025, 03:37 PM

The NFL hates Jameis Winston. He is better than Joe Freakin' Flacco.

skinsfan69 · 10-07-2025, 06:32 PM

Browns are such a loser organization. They just can't seem to get the QB right. I have no idea why they messed around w/ Flacco in the first place. He's got bricks in his feet. I would just blitz him on every single obvious passing down.

If you draft two young guys that have both played a lot of football stop being scared to play them. Same w/ the Giants messing around w/ Wilson. You don't draft a QB really high to let them watch. Makes no sense.

WCommandersfan99 · 10-07-2025, 11:32 PM

Flacco must really want to play football still lol. Dude is 40 with a ring and has evolved into a journeyman on crappy teams. One can't even say his legacy is being tarnished because the teams he's playing for suck so bad.

AnonEmouse · 10-08-2025, 05:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WCommandersfan99

Flacco must really want to play football still lol. Dude is 40 with a ring and has evolved into a journeyman on crappy teams. One can't even say his legacy is being tarnished because the teams he's playing for suck so bad.

The new Vinny Testaverde...

Maybe he's got a bet on to see how many times he can play against the Steelers?

88Commanders00 · 12-12-2025, 08:04 AM

The 2027 offseason is a key offseason for that 24 QB draft class.

1st round picks can have that 5th year option picked up and the then 3rd year, entering Year 4, players can negotiate a contract extension.

I’ll just talk about the first round picks since the other round picks have no impact.

5th Year Option

Williams and Nix have played the most and will
definitely get that 5th year option.

Maye is next and he will get the 5th year option.

Daniels is a question mark. Another injury plagued season and he doesn’t get the option picked up. He plays the full season, he gets his option picked up.

McCarthy and Pennix, even if they play the full season probably won’t get the option
picked up. They need more than one full season, to judge them.

Contract Extension

I think Williams, Nix and Maye will be offered the extension. Whether they do get one, is unknown.

Daniel’s might also be offered the extension, if he plays the full 3rd year.

I don’t know if McCarthy or Pennix will get offered an extension after one season of full play. If neither play a full 3rd year; definitely not. Right now they are closer to being busts than getting that 2nd contract.

Those contract negotiations will be interesting as 6 QBs will be looking for that extension/2nd contract. Who jumps first?

skinsfaninok · 12-15-2025, 03:32 PM

The odds are not good for JD5 to play a healthy season based on what we've seen.. I'm still a huge fan of his but I will say the concern for a consistent stretch of seasons is there

88Commanders00 · 02-10-2026, 10:30 AM

Now that everyone has been hired at the head coach level; it’s on to the QB carousel.

Since the draft really has one qb, Mendoza; the veteran market should be lively again. At least trying to a short term stopgap for this year and maybe next. Also, could see teams trying to get 1st or 2nd round picks in the 2027 draft; since next year is a more qb friendly draft.

Cousins should be released by the Falcons. Cardinals rumored to be moving on from Murray and the Dolphins to move on from Tua.

Could be a lot of teams tanking for the 27 draft class, since the 26 QB market is thin.

So look at the teams in the market:

Dolphins- They move on from Tua , what stopgap qb? Moving on from Tua takes a big bite of the cap.

Jets- Fields is done. No free agent will want to come here as Glenn is likely going to get fired at some point. They will have a high draft pick again in 2027.

Steelers- McCarthy might be able to convince Rodgers to come back for one more year but Steelers need that long term QB.

Browns- Probably run it back with Sanders and Dillon and since they are stuck with Watson’s contract; Watson might play also. I can see them to move to get more 27 picks ; so they can draft a QB.

Colts- Expect another year with Daniel Jones. They might wait a year before giving him a long term deal.

Raiders- Drafting Mendoza

Cards- If they trade Murray, maybe a short term deal with Cousins??? Who knows.

Vikings- They might get another long term qb, in case JJ doesn’t work out. JJ is closer to bustville than breaking out.

Falcons- They are releasing Cousins and give Pennix another go.

I can see teams trading for Murray and signing Cousins. Somebody might sign Wilson as a stopgap. I don’t see anyone wanting Tua.

AnonEmouse · 02-10-2026, 11:39 AM

If I were to predict:

Steelers and Rodgers go one more year. If not I can see the Steelers pursuing Cousins on a 1 or 2 years deal.
Dolphins probably look at a young FA, but could they afford someone like Willis? He's probably done enough to be paid well and Dolphins have Tua's cap money headaches.
Jets probably same as Dolphins so could be competing for the same FA talent pool.
Cards too will probably go young so I'm not sure about Cousins there. I think they could very well try and trade back in rd 1 and pick Simpson.

Rest I agree with.

10-01-2025, 12:36 PM	#152
88Commanders00 The Starter Join Date: Nov 2024 Posts: 1,280	Re: The annual QB carousel Browns benched Flacco and go with Gabriel yet all the talk is about Sheddur. Browns are screwed until they can get out of the Watson contract. Browns likely to finish with double digit loses, regardless of how many games Gabriel and/or Sanders starts. Neither qb will be the long term future. Haslam is likely to clean house after the season. Stefanski is in his 6th year. Browns have 2 #1 picks in 2026. Their own pick likely to be Top 10. The new guys will wants their own qb.

10-06-2025, 01:50 AM	#153
88Commanders00 The Starter Join Date: Nov 2024 Posts: 1,280	Re: The annual QB carousel If the Bengals want to salvage their season; they need a different qb. Kirk Cousins is probably too expensive for a one year rental but maybe the Bengals trade for the Giants backups- Wilson or Winston?

10-06-2025, 12:08 PM	#156
Chico23231 Warpath Hall of Fame Join Date: Mar 2009 Posts: 35,307	Re: The annual QB carousel Giants just turned the ball over again __________________ My pronouns: King/Your ruler He Gets Us

10-07-2025, 01:47 PM	#157
88Commanders00 The Starter Join Date: Nov 2024 Posts: 1,280	Re: The annual QB carousel Really? Bengals traded for Joe Flacco.

10-07-2025, 03:37 PM	#158
sdskinsfan2001 Living Legend Join Date: Sep 2010 Location: Hanahan, South Carolina Age: 42 Posts: 20,802	Re: The annual QB carousel The NFL hates Jameis Winston. He is better than Joe Freakin' Flacco. __________________ "You can be my wingman anytime." "Bulls**t. You can be mine."

10-07-2025, 06:32 PM	#159
skinsfan69 Living Legend Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Arlington, VA Posts: 17,570	Re: The annual QB carousel Browns are such a loser organization. They just can't seem to get the QB right. I have no idea why they messed around w/ Flacco in the first place. He's got bricks in his feet. I would just blitz him on every single obvious passing down. If you draft two young guys that have both played a lot of football stop being scared to play them. Same w/ the Giants messing around w/ Wilson. You don't draft a QB really high to let them watch. Makes no sense.

10-07-2025, 11:32 PM	#160
WCommandersfan99 The Starter Join Date: Sep 2015 Location: Oklahoma City, OK Posts: 2,122	Re: The annual QB carousel Flacco must really want to play football still lol. Dude is 40 with a ring and has evolved into a journeyman on crappy teams. One can't even say his legacy is being tarnished because the teams he's playing for suck so bad. __________________ Hail to the Commanders!

12-12-2025, 08:04 AM	#162
88Commanders00 The Starter Join Date: Nov 2024 Posts: 1,280	Re: The annual QB carousel The 2027 offseason is a key offseason for that 24 QB draft class. 1st round picks can have that 5th year option picked up and the then 3rd year, entering Year 4, players can negotiate a contract extension. I’ll just talk about the first round picks since the other round picks have no impact. 5th Year Option Williams and Nix have played the most and will definitely get that 5th year option. Maye is next and he will get the 5th year option. Daniels is a question mark. Another injury plagued season and he doesn’t get the option picked up. He plays the full season, he gets his option picked up. McCarthy and Pennix, even if they play the full season probably won’t get the option picked up. They need more than one full season, to judge them. Contract Extension I think Williams, Nix and Maye will be offered the extension. Whether they do get one, is unknown. Daniel’s might also be offered the extension, if he plays the full 3rd year. I don’t know if McCarthy or Pennix will get offered an extension after one season of full play. If neither play a full 3rd year; definitely not. Right now they are closer to being busts than getting that 2nd contract. Those contract negotiations will be interesting as 6 QBs will be looking for that extension/2nd contract. Who jumps first?

12-15-2025, 03:32 PM	#163
skinsfaninok Warpath Hall of Fame Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: UNITED STATES Age: 39 Posts: 36,242	Re: The annual QB carousel The odds are not good for JD5 to play a healthy season based on what we've seen.. I'm still a huge fan of his but I will say the concern for a consistent stretch of seasons is there __________________ “Mediocre people don’t like high achievers, and high achievers don’t like mediocre people.” ― Nick Saban

02-10-2026, 10:30 AM	#164
88Commanders00 The Starter Join Date: Nov 2024 Posts: 1,280	Re: The annual QB carousel Now that everyone has been hired at the head coach level; it’s on to the QB carousel. Since the draft really has one qb, Mendoza; the veteran market should be lively again. At least trying to a short term stopgap for this year and maybe next. Also, could see teams trying to get 1st or 2nd round picks in the 2027 draft; since next year is a more qb friendly draft. Cousins should be released by the Falcons. Cardinals rumored to be moving on from Murray and the Dolphins to move on from Tua. Could be a lot of teams tanking for the 27 draft class, since the 26 QB market is thin. So look at the teams in the market: Dolphins- They move on from Tua , what stopgap qb? Moving on from Tua takes a big bite of the cap. Jets- Fields is done. No free agent will want to come here as Glenn is likely going to get fired at some point. They will have a high draft pick again in 2027. Steelers- McCarthy might be able to convince Rodgers to come back for one more year but Steelers need that long term QB. Browns- Probably run it back with Sanders and Dillon and since they are stuck with Watson’s contract; Watson might play also. I can see them to move to get more 27 picks ; so they can draft a QB. Colts- Expect another year with Daniel Jones. They might wait a year before giving him a long term deal. Raiders- Drafting Mendoza Cards- If they trade Murray, maybe a short term deal with Cousins??? Who knows. Vikings- They might get another long term qb, in case JJ doesn’t work out. JJ is closer to bustville than breaking out. Falcons- They are releasing Cousins and give Pennix another go. I can see teams trading for Murray and signing Cousins. Somebody might sign Wilson as a stopgap. I don’t see anyone wanting Tua.

02-10-2026, 11:39 AM	#165
AnonEmouse Playmaker Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: UK Age: 59 Posts: 2,865	Re: The annual QB carousel If I were to predict: Steelers and Rodgers go one more year. If not I can see the Steelers pursuing Cousins on a 1 or 2 years deal. Dolphins probably look at a young FA, but could they afford someone like Willis? He's probably done enough to be paid well and Dolphins have Tua's cap money headaches. Jets probably same as Dolphins so could be competing for the same FA talent pool. Cards too will probably go young so I'm not sure about Cousins there. I think they could very well try and trade back in rd 1 and pick Simpson. Rest I agree with.

The annual QB carousel

Locker Room Main Forum