The Never Ending Thread

[jsarno]

Originally Posted by angryssg

No, I just don't get the whole Harry Potter thing. The story sucks. It would be better if Harry were actually a good Wizard and not a lucky one.

I wonder if that's why I can't get through the books...they bore me to tears, but i am entertained with the movies.
I too share that notion that he isn't as good as he should be. But I am wagering it will all come together in one of the later movies.
You can only have so much luck, and even he says in this movie that it's luck...I'm sure that will all change...they are showing the weak minded Potter, once he gets confidence he will be better.

ps- he also teaches in this movie.

[Lady Brave]

Originally Posted by jsarno

I wonder if that's why I can't get through the books...they bore me to tears, but i am entertained with the movies.
I too share that notion that he isn't as good as he should be. But I am wagering it will all come together in one of the later movies.
You can only have so much luck, and even he says in this movie that it's luck...I'm sure that will all change...they are showing the weak minded Potter, once he gets confidence he will be better.

ps- he also teaches in this movie.

How many of the books have you read?

[jsarno]

Originally Posted by Lady Brave

No more random than what you guys post.

Granted my post of the stages of depression was fairly random...but I was looking for the bionic Mexican cause of what you posted then drew a line to my post.
Just curious is all...now I understand you did it as a random thought cause we supposedly do random thoughts.

ps- I thought she was overrated!

[jsarno]

Originally Posted by Lady Brave

How many of the books have you read?

I tried two...just couldn't do them. Didn't finish either of them...not even close actually.

[KLHJ2]

Originally Posted by Lady Brave

If you haven't read the books then I don't see how you can critize it.

Are you telling me that the books can make sense out of this utter BS that has swept the world and been accecpted as greatness. Why dont you just make a movie called Ass and pass it off as a masterpiece.

[Lady Brave]

Originally Posted by jsarno

I tried two...just couldn't do them. Didn't finish either of them...not even close actually.

It starts getting better with the third book. The fifth and sixth books are excellent.

[Lady Brave]

Originally Posted by angryssg

Are you telling me that the books can make sense out of this utter BS that has swept the world and been accecpted as greatness. Why dont you just make a movie called Ass and pass it off as a masterpiece.

I fell in love with these books and the characters. If it's not for you then fine, but don't belittle the ones who find them interesting. What do you care anyway? When you actually read them then you can tell me why they aren't worth a crap.

[jsarno]

Originally Posted by Lady Brave

It starts getting better with the third book. The fifth and sixth books are excellent.

They are all the same author though aren't they?
I think I have difficulty with those kinds of fantasy book. I hate the cronicles of narnia, but liked the movie. For some reason I just can't read those types of books.

[Lady Brave]

Originally Posted by jsarno

They are all the same author though aren't they?
I think I have difficulty with those kinds of fantasy book. I hate the cronicles of narnia, but liked the movie. For some reason I just can't read those types of books.

Well, I hated reading before I got into these books. I think Rowling has a great imagination IMO.

[KLHJ2]

Originally Posted by Lady Brave

I fell in love with these books and the characters. If it's not for you then fine, but don't belittle the ones who find them interesting. What do you care anyway? When you actually read them then you can tell me why they aren't worth a crap.

Some of us read books and some of watch movies. To each his/her own. But if you are going to put a movie out and hype it up, then make it worth while. Some stories are meant for books and not for the screen.

By the way I never commented on the books. I said that the movies are crap.

[SmootSmack]

Happy 38th Anniversary of Neil Armstrong's and Buzz Aldrin's Walk on the Moon everyone!!

How are you planning on celebrating? Me and my buddies will probably do the usual...put motorcycle helmets on, a ski jacket, and some boots, jump off a stepstool onto a trampoline and hop up and down on one foot (you know, to simulate the experience)

[Lady Brave]

Originally Posted by angryssg

Some of us read books and some of watch movies. To each his/her own. But if you are going to put a movie out and hype it up, then make it worth while. Some stories are meant for books and not for the screen.

You could say the same thing about every book that has been made into a movie. Movies never do the books justice. It's only hyped up because the studios know the poor, unenlightened sheep like me will pay money to see it.

[KLHJ2]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

Happy 38th Anniversary of Neil Armstrong's and Buzz Aldrin's Walk on the Moon everyone!!

How are you planning on celebrating? Me and my buddies will probably do the usual...put motorcycle helmets on, a ski jacket, and some boots, jump off a stepstool onto a trampoline and hop up and down on one foot (you know, to simulate the experience)

Not really my opinion, but funny.

[jsarno]

Originally Posted by Lady Brave

Well, I hated reading before I got into these books. I think Rowling has a great imagination IMO.

That I do not doubt. I just think some books are better than others in terms of keeping my attention. I think I need to relate somehow...can't do it with potter. Love it on the screen, but not in a book.

[jsarno]

Originally Posted by angryssg

Some of us read books and some of watch movies. To each his/her own. But if you are going to put a movie out and hype it up, then make it worth while. Some stories are meant for books and not for the screen.

By the way I never commented on the books. I said that the movies are crap.

hate to tell you this angry, but Potter is WILDLY successful on the screen. The books apparently make amazing movies.
‘Harry Potter’ casts record spell at box office - Movies - MSNBC.com