Chase Young or Three First Round Picks?

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by Meks

after watching the CY highlight reel i wonder how he will do against NFL OT's. I'm all for taking a chance on his talent because he looks great, I just guess my eye test didn't leave me as BLOWN AWAY as some other folks. Although, it was my first time peeping the video so a 2nd look is needed. I
d be ok with trading down as long as the haul is well worth it, otherwise, you don't pass on a von miller type.

A22 Is better but I do think the hype train is a bit much

[MTK]

https://www.nbcsports.com/washington...s-garrett-were

The words "generational talent" have been thrown around frequently by NFL Draft experts when describing Ohio State pass rusher Chase Young.

NBC Sports Washington NFL analyst Charley Casserly was asked on The Sports Junkies to compare Young to some of the recent top draft picks at his position. Casserly made a point as to why Young is a better prospect coming out of college than all of them.

The first player Young was compared to was Seattle Seahawks defensive end Jadeveon Clowney, who was the No. 1 pick in the 2014 NFL Draft out of South Carolina.

"[Young is] better than Clowney," Casserly said. "Clowney had a spotted career where he was injured and wasn't consistent when he did play. [Young] is more consistent and he's played more games. All these guys played at a high level."

Like Young, Clowney was considered to be a transcendent player when he entered the NFL in 2014. In six seasons, Clowney has been named to the Pro Bowl three times and made the All-Pro team in 2016.

There have been a handful of edge rushers that have been considered to be elite NFL Draft prospects over the past two decades. Besides Clowney, names like Mario Williams, Julius Peppers and most recently in 2017, Myles Garrett come to mind.

Casserly explained where Young has the advantage over all three of those prospects.

"He's more consistent than Myles Garrett coming out," Casserly said. "He's a better athlete than Mario Williams, meaning he'll make more plays as an athlete. Going back to Julius Peppers who was taken second, he's a more instinctive player than Peppers was at that point."

Garrett, the No. 1 pick in 2017, has lived up to the hype thus far for the Cleveland Browns. He was a Pro Bowler and made the second-team All-Pro squad in 2019. He was on pace for another stellar year in 2019 before he was suspended for an altercation against the Steelers.

Williams, another No. 1 overall pick, made four Pro Bowl teams and one All-Pro squad during his 11-year career. In a draft that featured college stars such as Reggie Bush, Vince Young and Matt Leinart, the Texans selected the player who ended up having the best professional career of them all.

Peppers is a future Hall of Famer. Selected No. 2 in the 2002 NFL Draft by the Carolina Panthers, the North Carolina product made nine Pro Bowl teams and earned three first-team All-Pro selections over his 17-year career.

That's elite company for Chase Young to be in.

Casserly made the point that he's comparing Young to all these players when they were prospects, not their full body of work in the NFL. But by saying Young is better entering the league than all four of those players, all multiple-time Pro Bowlers, is a great sign for Young's future.

"I'm only comparing college careers. That's how you scout," he said. "You take a guy and start comparing him to people, and at the end, you go 'Oh, wow.' That's the way I look at the guy."

As for what the Redskins should do with the No.2 overall pick? Casserly thinks that the decision is easy.

"If I'm the Redskins I take Chase Young," he said. "I don't move back. He's that good of a football player."

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Meks]

Thanks for those clips Matty.

[skinsfaninok]

Host: "Any chance you're going to tip me off as to what you're going to do with that No. 2 overall pick?"

Rivera: "Yeah, we're going to pick us a good player."

[skinsfan69]

Take him. But is he a generational talent? IDK about all that. When I hear of that word I think about LT, Reggie White, Bruce Smith. Not Clowney or Mario Williams. We'll see....

[MTK]

^ Casserly was asked to compare Young to recent picks not all time greats.

[mooby]

Originally Posted by MTK

^ Casserly was asked to compare Young to recent picks not all time greats.

Also he clearly says he's comparing Young to where the aforementioned players graded out as prospects, not based on what they accomplished in their pro careers.

I think we forget every player, no matter how known or unknown they were, all enter the league as an unknown entity.

[skinsfan69]

Originally Posted by MTK

^ Casserly was asked to compare Young to recent picks not all time greats.

Casserly's evaluation is fair. In general the media has been hyping him as a generational talent. It's the Ohio State hype machine. He had some games where he wrecked the other teams offense, but he was also quiet in some others. If he comes in here next year and has 8 sacks and a solid but unspectacular year then everyone will call him a bust. That would be unfair.

I just hope we draft him, pair him w/ Sweat and see what those two can do. We may have our best set of DE's since Dex and Mann.

[NYCskinfan82]

Originally Posted by skinsfan69

Casserly's evaluation is fair. In general the media has been hyping him as a generational talent. It's the Ohio State hype machine. He had some games where he wrecked the other teams offense, but he was also quiet in some others. If he comes in here next year and has 8 sacks and a solid but unspectacular year then everyone will call him a bust. That would be unfair.

I just hope we draft him, pair him w/ Sweat and see what those two can do. We may have our best set of DE's since Dex and Mann.

Yes the good old days you just brought a tear to my eye.

[Chico23231]

turn the card in

[skinsfaninok]

So Ross Tucker said he has heard of a team in the top 10 that is very serious about moving up to #2 in need of a QB, That isn't Miami. Said they have 2 first round picks to offer, so clearly he's talking about the Jags.

Would you take 9 , 20 and their 3rd round pick for #2?

I think I would

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

So Ross Tucker said he has heard of a team in the top 10 that is very serious about moving up to #2 in need of a QB, That isn't Miami. Said they have 2 first round picks to offer, so clearly he's talking about the Jags.

Would you take 9 , 20 and their 3rd round pick for #2?

I think I would

No, they would have to throw their 2nd rounder and a 2021 1st for me to even consider it.

[skinsfaninok]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

No, they would have to throw their 2nd rounder and a 2021 1st for me to even consider it.

I doubt they would deal 3 #1's for it but what if they offered 9,20 and their 2nd this yr?

I'd say yes

[NYCskinfan82]

Originally Posted by EARTHQUAKE2689

No, they would have to throw their 2nd rounder and a 2021 1st for me to even consider it.

I'm with you next years 1st has to be included.

[EdmundDorf]

If they have fallen in love with their QB of the future we should screw them for as much as we a can get. Personally I wouldn't take less than x2 2020 1sts and a 2nd plus at least a 2021 2nd