McNabb a REDSKIN!

[warpaint]

One other thing.

HAIL TO THE REDSKINS!

[diehard]

The only reason I like this move is that it obviously makes PHI a weaker opponent.

[irish]

This could work out for 1 season but all it does is delay the inevitable fact that the Skins dont have a long term franchise QB and until they solve that problem its going to be more of the same.

[johno]

Originally Posted by irish

This could work out for 1 season but all it does is delay the inevitable fact that the Skins dont have a long term franchise QB and until they solve that problem its going to be more of the same.

we have so many holes on this team, we can't address them all in one year. we now can take a LT without hesitation. mcnabb is a great stop gap measure. he will serve us well for a couple of years until there is a young qb available in either the draft/fa that the shannys like. mcnabb is an upgrade over JC, and he is now on our team, no idea why this is seen as a bad move.

[joethiesmanfan]

Originally Posted by irish

This could work out for 1 season but all it does is delay the inevitable fact that the Skins dont have a long term franchise QB and until they solve that problem its going to be more of the same.

He is an accomplished QB what more could you want? Ummm let me take a wild guess.

[CRedskinsRule]

Schefter on Mike and Mike says there have been NO contract talks at all between the Skins and McNabb.

[SmootSmack]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

Schefter on Mike and Mike says there have been NO contract talks at all between the Skins and McNabb.

He also said there will be soon

[MTK]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

He also said there will be soon

Yeah he basically said the trade happened so quick there wasn't any time, but it would be crazy to think something won't happen.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

He also said there will be soon

I would hope so obviously, but the fact appears to be that we gave up a pick next year with no confirmation that he will be on our team past this year.

[Beemnseven]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

He also said there will be soon

So the notion of McNabb being traded in some sort of a three-way deal with another team like the Rams isn't likely?

[warpaint]

JC is going to bring us a 2nd round pick.

McNabb knows our new offense, he has ran it for 11 seasons.

He knows the Eagles Offense and Defense in and out. Thats two wins right there.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by warpaint

JC is going to bring us a 2nd round pick.

This would minimize my dislike of the trade, but I don't see it happening.

McNabb knows our new offense, he has ran it for 11 seasons.

I've heard that said, but Kyle is our OC and calling plays, did Houston run the same offense as his dad? I don't know, I am asking because I would say Houston didn't seem to be a WCO.

He knows the Eagles Offense and Defense in and out. Thats two wins right there.

I doubt that.
Oct 26th game, we lost but here are the comparable stats
........................................YPC..TD..I NT..Rating
J. Campbell...29/43...284...6.6...2.....1.....91.6
D. McNabb....15/25...156...6.2...1.....0.....91.4

Nov 29th game, we lost, but led in the 4th quarter 24-16 and the defense gave up 11 points
J. Campbell...22/37...231...6.2...2.....2.....73.1
D. McNabb....21/35...260...7.4...1.....1.....80.7

[warpaint]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

I've heard that said, but Kyle is our OC and calling plays, did Houston run the same offense as his dad? I don't know, I am asking because I would say Houston didn't seem to be a WCO.

You are right I forgot about that but, It seems like it is going to be some type of merger of each others offenses

[warpaint]

Originally Posted by CRedskinsRule

I doubt that.
Oct 26th game, we lost but here are the comparable stats
........................................YPC..TD..I NT..Rating
J. Campbell...29/43...284...6.6...2.....1.....91.6
D. McNabb....15/25...156...6.2...1.....0.....91.4

Nov 29th game, we lost, but led in the 4th quarter 24-16 and the defense gave up 11 points
J. Campbell...22/37...231...6.2...2.....2.....73.1
D. McNabb....21/35...260...7.4...1.....1.....80.7

The reason I said that is, DM5 knows their tendecies on both sides of the ball. He knows their offense like the back of his hand and their snap counts. Which is going to be helpful for our D. He also knows how Andy gameplanes which is another plus.

[CRedskinsRule]

Originally Posted by warpaint

The reason I said that is, DM5 knows their tendecies on both sides of the ball. He knows their offense like the back of his hand and their snap counts. Which is going to be helpful for our D. He also knows how Andy gameplanes which is another plus.

Ok, so what you are saying, basically, is that since they let Brian Westbrook go, Byron no longer could give us inside information, therefore... we should give up 2 picks, 11mill without a guarantee past this year, so we have inside info on a team that we are one one season removed from sweeping with JC. Got it. I change my mind GREAT move. HAIL TO THE NEW BOSS, (same as the old boss?)