Eli Manning vs Jason Campbell

[KingRaloIV]

No Burress in NY, I'll take JC over Eli anyday! He has comparable stats and he has got it done with lesser talent.

[Redskin Jim]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

NOTE: SUBJECTIVE OPINION ALERT

I don't think many coordinators would blitz Campbell at all if they didn't think they could break down our protections in the process. The 6+ man blitzes, designed at getting more rushers than the offense could pick up, were incredibly beatable by Campbell last year. It's the 5 man rushes and 4 man zone blitzes that we failed to pick up and resulted in pressure on the QB.

The protection schemes were lacking, but it's tough to say how much of that is on the QB, how much is on the coaches, and how much is on the line itself.

Very intuitive... I think each situation where the protection breaks down has to do with one, or a combination of of these things. It is subjective to each play in which factor(s), lead to the breakdown of the protection. In the case of the second half of the 08' season I believe JC, protection schemes or play calling (Zorn), and offensive line play, are ALL EQUALLY guilty of sub-par performance.

[WaldSkins]

Originally Posted by 53Fan

Peyton Manning was only sacked about 14 times. Based on that, should'nt the Colts have won the Super Bowl?

That doesnt matter in this thread

All you need to know is JC sucks and anyone else is better.

[DBUCHANON101]

Today on espn.com Mosley was asked what set Eli apart from the other East QB's? His answer. Mouth Breathing. lol

[pick-ups]

This doofus is not clutch and the league has a love affair with his last name.

[53Fan]

^ Priceless.

[saden1]

Quick, how many Super Bowls has JC won by throwing clutch passes against an 18-0 team in one of the greatest game of all time?

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by saden1

Quick, how many Super Bowls has JC won by throwing clutch passes against an 18-0 team in one of the greatest game of all time?

With the team he plays for how many opportunities has he had?

[DBUCHANON101]

Originally Posted by saden1

Quick, how many Super Bowls has JC won by throwing clutch passes against an 18-0 team in one of the greatest game of all time?

Touche'

Gotta give him some credit, they did do better vs the Pats that yr than we did. Definately one of the worse games ive seen us play in a long time. the whole team was dreadfull.

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by DBUCHANON101

Touche'

Gotta give him some credit, they did do better vs the Pats that yr than we did. Definately one of the worse games ive seen us play in a long time. the whole team was dreadfull.

Without a doubt. I wanted to go hit Brady myself.

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by DBUCHANON101

Touche'

Gotta give him some credit, they did do better vs the Pats that yr than we did. Definately one of the worse games ive seen us play in a long time. the whole team was dreadfull.

Agreed. Honestly, as much as I defend Campbell, I still think he has a lot to prove to be compared to a QB like Eli and Big Ben. Many have made very good arguments when you compare JC to Eli for example. But for the masses, Eli is a SB winning QB, and they will see nothing beyond that

With that being said, it is my hope that in the near future, JC can add winning a SB to his resume. I also hope that some of the positive factors that have helped the likes of Big Ben and Eli Manning win a Superbowl, can help JC and the Redskins succeed and win the big one.

[DBUCHANON101]

Originally Posted by 53Fan

Without a doubt. I wanted to go hit Brady myself.

When it became clear that they were running it up on Joe Gibbs that really PI$$ED me off. you dont disrespect a HOF HC like that, and thats why the Football Gods shunned them in the SB . HAHAHAHA

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by DBUCHANON101

When it became clear that they were running it up on Joe Gibbs that really PI$$ED me off. you dont disrespect a HOF HC like that, and thats why the Football Gods shunned them in the SB . HAHAHAHA

It would have been worth giving up a touchdown to allout blitz and smack that smug SOB in the mouth. I mean WTH, they were going to score anyway.

[DBUCHANON101]

Originally Posted by 53Fan

It would have been worth giving up a touchdown to allout blitz and smack that smug SOB in the mouth. I mean WTH, they were going to score anyway.

Funny you say that, i was tellin some NE fans the same thing. That a team will put a hit order out on Brady when they start runnin it up on them. Men in this game have alot of pride and wont stand for that foolishness.

[SBXVII]

Originally Posted by saden1

Quick, how many Super Bowls has JC won by throwing clutch passes against an 18-0 team in one of the greatest game of all time?

Uh please. Stop. They won yes. I'm not even a NE fan and I believe Eli was in the grass. The Refs should have called it. He throws up a hail marry. What would we be saying had a NE player caught the ball instead? The WR made the play. Barely. but he made the play. I would have also said the ball hit the ground cause in my eyes I'm seeing it move as the helmet hits the ground.

but you can argue the fact that they won. Skins have done nothing.