Was Jamie Dukes out of line on Ryan Mallett?

[53Fan]

Originally Posted by Shadowbyte

I don't why when ever there's any racial discussion going on Whites always have to play the Jessie Jackson Al Sharpton card. There's plenty of White racial ambulance chasers too. Especially Rush Limbaugh. Here's an example.



From Kids on Bus to Kanye West: Race Rules All in Obama's America

Also, Fox News says racist stuff about Blacks all day long. So to say there's a "double" standard is rediculous. As If Blacks are the only ones who make politically incorrect statements.

YouTube - Fox Attacks: Black America

Now I don't see any of you self righteous defenders of parity condeming what's happenign on the other side of the political spectrum. Also, as for the NFL network. I get sick and tired of them questioning the mental dexterity of Black QB's. All of the criticisms center around the mental and psycological aspects of the position. I've never heard a White QB on their get critisized for their ability to "read-defenses" or "study his playbook".

I understand your point. I really do. But maybe you're too young to remember Thomas "Hollywood" Henderson saying Terry Bradshaw couldn't spell "cat" if you spotted him the C. I don't think it's only Black QB's whose mental abilities are questioned. Personally I question Romo's and Eli's quite often.

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

JC is 60% for his career and seeing that Garrard has been 64%, 62%, 64% and 60% twice I would hardly call him inaccurate, and yes 5+ years of 60% and over is good.

[skinsfaninok]

^ it's decent not horrible but nothing special either. I'd take JC over garrard

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

^ it's decent not horrible but nothing special either. I'd take JC over garrard

And I would fire you as a GM. So 64% is "decent?" How many QBs are pulling in 70% passing accuracy?

[skinsfaninok]

^ not many but how many QBs are elite? Only a few , and back to Mallett I'm not a fan of his btw I wad just saying how unfair he's being treated and no one comes to his defense

[skinsfaninok]

I'd say 70% is good so garrard had a good year fair? Also romo is usually around 65 but most people dog him too

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

How many QBs are pulling in 70%?

[skinsfaninok]

^ well just assuming I'd say none to 1 at most , I'd say manning or Brady would prob be the closest to that .'maybe Rodgers or rivers also

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

^ well just assuming I'd say none to 1 at most , I'd say manning or Brady would prob be the closest to that .'maybe Rodgers or rivers also

double post

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Aaron Rodgers is only 64.4% for his career and I would call him elite.

[skinsfaninok]

Well I wouldn't say elite just yet let's wait and see another 3-4 years , that word gets tossed around to easily, he's a damn good QB no doubt and I'd take him over just about anyone. I dont even think Brees is elite either, manning and Brady are the only 2 imo

[skinsfaninok]

Tom Brady to me is the best QB in the league and has been since 01 he puts up great numbers and never losses, maybe the best QB of all time as I've said multiple times

[skinsfaninok]

Comp % is good but it's all about winning my man, that's the bottom line, Rodgers and Brees are amazing no doubt but if they are elite then rivers and Eli could be also, remember Eli has won a SB

[skinsfaninok]

Ok it's good there and I was basically talking about garrard, he's a decent player nothing more

[EARTHQUAKE2689]

Originally Posted by skinsfaninok

Comp % is good but it's all about winning my man, that's the bottom line, Rodgers and Brees are amazing no doubt but if they are elite then rivers and Eli could be also, remember Eli has won a SB

Winning has nothing to do with what we were talking about. Trent Dilfer won a SB, as did Brad Johnson. Winning a SB doesn't make you elite.