Who will be the next coach of the Redskins and does it even freakin matter?

[mooby]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

There is a former Redskins player who has done a fantastic job as a GM, Martin Mayhew. I would hire him and let him find a coach.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Mayhew

Where did he do a fantastic job as GM? When he built those terrible Lions teams after serving as asst. GM to Matt Millen? Sure he's a senior personnel exec. for SF right now but how much credit do you give him for building that roster instead of John Lynch/Kyle S?

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by mooby

Where did he do a fantastic job as GM? When he built those terrible Lions teams after serving as asst. GM to Matt Millen? Sure he's a senior personnel exec. for SF right now but how much credit do you give him for building that roster instead of John Lynch/Kyle S?

If you lived here you would know.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.fre.../amp/482427002

[sdskinsfan2001]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

If you lived here you would know.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.fre.../amp/482427002

Not always a huge Dane Cook fan, but this stand up was absolutely amazing...

[mooby]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

If you lived here you would know.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.fre.../amp/482427002

Riiiiiiiight, but where do you draw the line between giving Mayhew the credit for building SF's roster and giving Lynch the credit for building SF's roster?

Have you ever considered maybe he's been effective in his role because there's literally no pressure on him?

Let me put it like this, are we giving Bruce Allen's assistants any heat for what a shitty job they do assisting Bruce in building our roster? Can you name any of Bruce's assistants without looking them up?

I'm not sold on Mayhew just because he's been an invaluable adviser to John Lynch on how to be a good GM.

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by mooby

Riiiiiiiight, but where do you draw the line between giving Mayhew the credit for building SF's roster and giving Lynch the credit for building SF's roster?

Have you ever considered maybe he's been effective in his role because there's literally no pressure on him?

Let me put it like this, are we giving Bruce Allen's assistants any heat for what a shitty job they do assisting Bruce in building our roster? Can you name any of Bruce's assistants without looking them up?

I'm not sold on Mayhew just because he's been an invaluable adviser to John Lynch on how to be a good GM.

First off Bruce Allen is worthlessness POS, Kyle Smith has done a fine job picking players the last 2 years. Mayhew would take over Allen’s role which oversees operations and would know Kyle is doing a fine job and would provide his input. Doesn’t mean what happened in Detroit was all his fault. Belichick was a failure in Cleveland, what happened after that? Mayhem is smart and well respected executive.

[mooby]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

First off Bruce Allen is worthlessness POS, Kyle Smith has done a fine job picking players the last 2 years. Mayhew would take over Allen’s role which oversees operations and would know Kyle is doing a fine job and would provide his input. Doesn’t mean what happened in Detroit was all his fault. Belichick was a failure in Cleveland, what happened after that? Mayhem is smart and well respected executive.

Which players has Kyle Smith personally picked over the last two years?

Last I heard picking players was a group effort, with Allen, Smith, Doug Williams, and Gruden all having input (up until this year when popular opinion is that Gruden was ousted from the group).

[SFREDSKIN]

Originally Posted by mooby

Which players has Kyle Smith personally picked over the last two years?

Last I heard picking players was a group effort, with Allen, Smith, Doug Williams, and Gruden all having input (up until this year when popular opinion is that Gruden was ousted from the group).

https://mobile.twitter.com/john_keim...52815898955776

https://mobile.twitter.com/john_keim...64957389873153

Look who created the draft board

[mooby]

Originally Posted by SFREDSKIN

https://mobile.twitter.com/john_keim...52815898955776

https://mobile.twitter.com/john_keim...64957389873153

Look who created the draft board

You're not showing me anything I haven't already seen. I'm already on the record as being a Kyle Smith fan. Just asking you where you draw the line between giving Kyle Smith all the credit for this draft class and giving the other major-decision makers credit too?

My entire point in this convo is you seem determined to give Mayhew the credit for John Lynch's success and the success SF has had building a team. I'm not sold on Mayhew leading a team just because of that. He's already tried to lead a dogshit franchise out of the dumpster and failed. We're not San Fran, we don't build teams the right way, and we've seen many a successful man come to this organization and have his name tarnished by the time he leaves. I don't think Mayhew is the guy that's going to buck that trend.