Espn:Eagles and Bills talk trade involving LB Spikes

[SmootSmack]

I kind of find the Holcomb move interesting. Does it mean McNabb might not be ready to start the season? Are they not comfortable with AJ Feely as the backup/possible opening day starter?

And what about the Bills QB situation. Might Carr go there to back-up Losman?

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

And what about the Bills QB situation. Might Carr go there to back-up Losman?

I wouldn't rule it out. There's a lot of Carr love around the league. I guess if you get your ass beat to a bloddy pulp for 5 seasons, poor play can be swept under the rug.

Not to beat a dead horse too bad, but Carr never did anything in Houston that Ramsey didn't do for us here. I think both guys can be very good backups somewhere, or argueably a low end starter on a team where the passing game is not the main focal point of the team.

I think Ramsey is marginally a better player than Carr.

[That Guy]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

I wouldn't rule it out. There's a lot of Carr love around the league. I guess if you get your ass beat to a bloddy pulp for 5 seasons, poor play can be swept under the rug.

Not to beat a dead horse too bad, but Carr never did anything in Houston that Ramsey didn't do for us here. I think both guys can be very good backups somewhere, or argueably a low end starter on a team where the passing game is not the main focal point of the team.

I think Ramsey is marginally a better player than Carr.

i'd argue that last point. carr's deep balls don't get thrown like javelins (no arc) or get intercepted as much. of course, carr's only plays well when he's down by 4 touchdowns and in no danger of being able to win the game, but that's a whole other issue.

[That Guy]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

I kind of find the Holcomb move interesting. Does it mean McNabb might not be ready to start the season? Are they not comfortable with AJ Feely as the backup/possible opening day starter?

And what about the Bills QB situation. Might Carr go there to back-up Losman?

AJ feeley sucks. nothing's changed, he's still the #3.

[BrudLee]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

I kind of find the Holcomb move interesting. Does it mean McNabb might not be ready to start the season? Are they not comfortable with AJ Feely as the backup/possible opening day starter?

And what about the Bills QB situation. Might Carr go there to back-up Losman?

I wouldn't be comfortable with AJ Feeley as third key at a 24 hour Car Wash. There are people out there who are questioning the Texans faith in Matt Schaub. Matt Schaub is AJ Feeley, with the possible exception that he can throw.