If we were to TRADE UP, who would you shoot for?

[jsarno]

Originally Posted by SmootSmack

But it's hard not to respond critically to the opinion presented in the first post. Especially in light of other comments/opinions by that same person.

I guess I need to post this again:

(please note, I am not interested in trading up, just not dismissing the possibility, and opportunity for discussion)

Also, most of my comments have been directed at not getting Chad Johnson. A serious cancer and head case who I wouldn't want even if we get him for only a 3rd round pick.
If you noticed, I was wanting to go after Roy Williams. I think you are unfairly trying to assume a point of view, when in actuality they are all separate issues. How can I be so willing to trade picks for Williams, but not for CJ? It has to do with age / contract / ability / size / and attitude. Every case is different. I prefer to keep our picks for good young talent, but if we can get someone the caliber and age of Williams for our 1st rounder, I'd go for it. If we could trade Portis for McFadden straight up, I'd go for it. (not that any team would do that). Every scenario is different.