Are '08 rookies top 5 class ever?

[4thGenRedskin21]

Originally Posted by That Guy

his touch was fine in college and last year when he played... ramsey was the javelin tosser.

yeah you're right, he didnt overthrow anyone at all or anything like that

[DirtyLandry]

Re-post this thread in 3 years guys, seriously.

[4thGenRedskin21]

Originally Posted by DirtyLandry

Re-post this thread in 3 years guys, seriously.

yeah, it is hard to crown a class the best class ever this early on.. alot of players do good their rookie year and then flame out.. If all these rookies that have shown flashes can be consitant and have good years next year, then i can maybe start to think so.. it takes a while to see how good a draft class is, you def cant base it off two games.

[That Guy]

Originally Posted by 4thGenRedskin21

yeah you're right, he didnt overthrow anyone at all or anything like that

show me where i said he never overthrew anyone please. i mean, being passive aggressive is cool and all, but please don't put words in my mouth. thanks.

[mike340]

He was terrible at throwing the long ball. Everything was a line drive. I was complaining to my wife that Moss never had enough time to adjust to the ball. I mean, how many times did we see Moss wide open and Campbell threw it with such mustard that Moss couldn't get to it? And the pass in the corner of the endzone last year (I don't remember which game) which ended the game because he threw it on a rope (short distance but same idea) and it got picked off. If he was so good at throwing the long ball, why was our first TD pass to a wide receiver last year so late in the season? And did our receivers get so much better at running routes the moment Collins came in?
That said, the pass to Moss last week had a nice arc to it. I hope he keeps it up.

Originally Posted by That Guy

show me where i said he never overthrew anyone please. i mean, being passive aggressive is cool and all, but please don't put words in my mouth. thanks.