Redskins vs. Giants Official Game Thread

[MTK]

Originally Posted by GMScud

All these people who think JC is the problem make me laugh. Shitty pass protection, dropped balls, and poor play calling aren't his fault.

I agree... it's absolutely ridiculous.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Mattyk72

I agree... it's absolutely ridiculous.

I do think you should start offering temporary bans to those who can't analyze a game without first blaming the quarterback. I'm not talking about the people who have (correctly) pointed out that Jason Campbell has not had a good 4 game stretch, or the people who suggest that we might want to get deeper at the position in the off-season. I'm talking about the people who think he hasn't had a good season and looks like a bust.

I'm all for dissenting opinion, but making crap up IMO need not be tolerated.

My favorite was the guy who suggested Campbell should be benched because he was "only average". By definition, admitting that he's better than 15-16 starting QBs in the NFL, but then suggesting that we need to find someone better amongst Colt Brennan and Todd Collins.

[htownskinfan]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

I do think you should start offering temporary bans to those who can't analyze a game without first blaming the quarterback. I'm not talking about the people who have (correctly) pointed out that Jason Campbell has not had a good 4 game stretch, or the people who suggest that we might want to get deeper at the position in the off-season. I'm talking about the people who think he hasn't had a good season and looks like a bust.

I'm all for dissenting opinion, but making crap up IMO need not be tolerated.

My favorite was the guy who suggested Campbell should be benched because he was "only average". By definition, admitting that he's better than 15-16 starting QBs in the NFL, but then suggesting that we need to find someone better amongst Colt Brennan and Todd Collins.

you gotta be shitting me,ban people for their opinon because you dont agree with it?
better ban me because i dont agree with you

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by htownskinfan

you gotta be shitting me,ban people for their opinon because you dont agree with it?
better ban me because i dont agree with you

Yeah, uh, that's not what I said at all.

[htownskinfan]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

Yeah, uh, that's not what I said at all.

I think you need to reread your post because thats exactly what you said,in your opinion people need to be banned for their opinion,they may not have exact facts to back it up,BUT ITS THEIR OPINION
as far as this qoute goes
"My favorite was the guy who suggested Campbell should be benched because he was "only average". By definition, admitting that he's better than 15-16 starting QBs in the NFL, but then suggesting that we need to find someone better amongst Colt Brennan and Todd Collins."

I believe TC beat the giants in NY last yr

"Collins led the Redskins on five scoring drives in his first start in 10 years, outplaying Eli Manning in a 22-10 victory that put a little doubt into the New York Giants' once seemingly certain road to the postseason"

am I saying TC is better than JC,it doesnt matter,its just my opinion
plus theres 32 teams in the nfl,by definition,if JC is 17th among them,thats pretty damn average
Right now hes ranked 12th in qb rating,but there 8 guys behind him that I would take over him,JC's 3 spots ahead of Peyton Manning,I'm not sure what to say about that

I dont mean to get into it with you,I usually agree with 99 percent of your post,I think were all just frustrated because the playoffs are slipping away when it looked like we had it made,I just think to suggest handing out bans for peoples opinions is not the right thing to do

[Ruhskins]

Originally Posted by GTripp0012

I do think you should start offering temporary bans to those who can't analyze a game without first blaming the quarterback. I'm not talking about the people who have (correctly) pointed out that Jason Campbell has not had a good 4 game stretch, or the people who suggest that we might want to get deeper at the position in the off-season. I'm talking about the people who think he hasn't had a good season and looks like a bust.

I'm all for dissenting opinion, but making crap up IMO need not be tolerated.

My favorite was the guy who suggested Campbell should be benched because he was "only average". By definition, admitting that he's better than 15-16 starting QBs in the NFL, but then suggesting that we need to find someone better amongst Colt Brennan and Todd Collins.

I think banning ppl for this would be pretty ridiculous. I mean we're in a frustrating stretch of the season, and people will say naive statements out of frustration.

[GTripp0012]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

I think banning ppl for this would be pretty ridiculous. I mean we're in a frustrating stretch of the season, and people will say naive statements out of frustration.

What I'm saying is that the same people who need to make stuff up in order to make a point aren't the people who are adding any sort of value to the site.

[DynamiteRave]

Originally Posted by Ruhskins

I think banning ppl for this would be pretty ridiculous. I mean we're in a frustrating stretch of the season, and people will say naive statements out of frustration.

I think what GTripp is getting at is that people talk out of their ass and can't back up their statements with anything substantial. I think we all know Jason Campbell isn't Hall of Fame material (yet), but he's no Ryan Leaf either, no matter how badly some people want to make it out to be.